Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Carmelita’s Mexican Restaurant in Cicero, NY, is the proud second generation of a beloved family-run eatery that many remember fondly from Syracuse in the 70’s. Our roots run deep in tradition, and we’ve brought back the same authentic recipes, fresh ingredients, and welcoming spirit that made the original Carmelita’s a local favorite.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 6195 NY-31 #14, Cicero, NY 13039
Phone: (315) 699-7550
Website: http://carmelitasmexican.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: spotapps.co
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Carmelita’s Mexican Restaurant – Cicero, NY
Authentic Mexican, Made Fresh Daily. At Carmelita’s, every dish tells a story – rooted in tradition and bursting with bold, authentic flavors.
Carmelita’s Mexican Restaurant | Cicero NY – Facebook
Great food, family time, and delicious flavors all in one place. Join us today! ❤️ (315)699-7550 6195 State Rt.31 Cicero NY TUE/WED/THU 4pm – 8pm FRI 4pm – 9pm …
Reviews
Katherine Cummings
We absolutely love Carmelita’s – it is one of our top Mexican restaurants. I highly recommend the Birria tacos which they do Friday and Saturday. The food is very flavorful, especially if you choose one of the spicy plates. Service is always excellent.
I tried the nacho flight and it was just what I wanted.
… moreI tried the nacho flight and it was just what I wanted.
Melissa Vanilla
We walked in to a fragrant and inviting atmosphere. The lovely owner was so very kind and friendly. The food was amazing. I havent had a burrito in so many years fue to Celiacs, this place is a game changer with home made tortillas to boot! D to the licious. Try it, I bet you will enjoy this place! We sure did!
… moreShannon Koss
First time here and loved it. Great service and yummy chips!! My husband had two margaritas and slurped them down. I had the mushroom and spinach quesadillas, which were the perfect size and delicious. We will certainly be back!
… moreAmy G
We stumbled upon Carmelita’s and what a lovely place! Great food and atmosphere. The menu is 100% gluten free which is awesome! Will definitely be back when in the area!
… moreMike 1965
Listen folks, I’m a local resident of Cicero and I go here all the time. The food is amazing. Understand this is NOT your chain “Mexican” restaurant. You are not going to get free chips and salsa. All of the food is handmade, not purchased in bulk. Chips are made and fried right there and don’t come in a bag. The homemade salsa is like no other, made fresh each day and is very different from those that come in a jar. It is amazing. The food is very fresh and tasty. Theresa (owner/chef) knows to make my chicken verde extra spicy. She can do anything you wish. The birrea is the best, I mean, the best I’ve had, a bit salty but again made fresh and extremely tasty. If you want the same old Americanized Mexican food, don’t go here. If you want a local family friendly restaurant with delicious food made with fresh ingredients daily, and unique flavors, then this is your place. Don’t be upset if you have to wait because others feel the same way and sometimes the slightly small restaurant can be filled on a Friday/Saturday night, but for me it is absolutely worth it. Great drinks as well – not from a mix.
… moreTheresa Haley
We had heard good things about Carmelita’s, but unfortunately it was very disappointing. Service was friendly and attentive. The restaurant is cute and clean. They did not give you chips and salsa as most Mexican restaurants do when you are seated, so we ordered a trio of queso, salsa and guacamole. The chips were awful. Some chips were over cooked and tasted burnt and others were so undercooked that they were chewy. I ordered the shrimp tacos for $15 and got two very small tacos with a total of six small pieces of shrimp. There was cheese and a few tomato chunks in the taco, but no lettuce or sauce or cabbage slaw, etc. The shrimp was cooked well, however it had no seasoning. My daughter ordered chicken enchiladas which came with rice and beans for $18. The rice was hard (completely undercooked) and was not edible. The few bites she did take tasted like plain white rice. The shredded chicken in the enchiladas was also flavorless. My daughter had a spicy margarita which she did enjoy. However, this meal cost us close to $80 with tip and we were completely disappointed.
… moreRudy Rosique
Staff is extremely nice and appears to be family oriented ( which was amazing ). It has a decent Mexican atmosphere but the food is just subpar. It’s Mexican labeled food with American flavoring. $65 for 2 plates and an appetizer, which if a single item was even halfway decent I would not mind. I am assuming they catered the food towards caucasian people, b/c it was just not worthy of a Mexican dish label.
… moreDoopie
The staff was incredibly kind — everyone was friendly and very accommodating. The food, however, was just okay and not something I’d go out of my way to come back for. We ordered chips with bean dip, burritos, and quesadillas with sides of rice and beans. I’m usually obsessed with Mexican restaurant rice and beans, but these were just alright.
… moreGray Pettitt
If you’re looking for an authentic delicious Mexican place to enjoy tasty drinks and food, look no further. The food, staff, and atmosphere were all amazing and we will be back! Thank you again!
… moreInthawa Sisombath
It was our first time at Carmelita’s, my daughter and I enjoy Mexican so we wanted to try it out. The service and atmosphere was good our server was very nice and attentive. We ordered the nacho sampler which was a special we enjoyed that it was good however our entrees unfortunately fell flat. My daughter ordered two tacos she said it was cold and very bland, I ordered the Azteca which I was very excited about because our server said it was her fave and I love enchiladas I order them at almost every Mexican restaurant I go to. Unfortunately I was very disappointed it was very bland no salt no flavor and watery. I couldn’t have cocktails this time around because I’m pregnant so I would give Carmelita’s another chance just to try their drinks and appetizers other than that the entrees sadly weren’t great.
… more