Mike Robinson
Wiseguys Pizza may be the only pizza I’ve ever had in the Pittsburgh area, but that doesn’t make them any less amazing. I visited Pittsburgh with my fiancé and a friend the weekend of December 12th-14th, 2025. After hours out checking out the city the snow got to be a little much on the 13th, and our friend who was driving had lost control of his car temporarily while visiting a spot an hour away from the city proper, he was at this point done driving for the night, but we had no food in our rental so we began searching for a place to order delivery, but fearing nobody would come out in the snow. Not only did Wiseguys Pizza show up in the snow that night, they were timely and the food was FANTASTIC. The pizza we all split, a 20 inch pie, I did not expect three people to be able to eat … was devoured. The handcut fries? Amazing. I remarked to my fiancé “wish we had fries this good near us back in Philly”.
For my money, if I’m ever back in Pittsburgh, there’s no question who’s pizza and fries I want. Delicious, and absolute KINGS for coming out on a snowy Saturday night when we didn’t really have any backup plans. Thank you so much Wiseguys!
… moreJason Anthony
Haven’t ordered from there in a while, but as usual, it did not disappoint. Ordered a large plain, steak hoagie and small cheese fry and all 3 were great. Shout out to the delivery guy Dave, who was real cool and even pet my kitten. Next time I will not wait too long to order.
… moreThomas Sinagra
Great evening for me is getting a shower after work, sitting in my recliner, and dialing up Wiseguys. Love the pizzas, the sauce is robust, and the toppings are generous. The hoagies are large and in charge! Delivery is always prompt. Drivers are cool and nice to have a quick sports chat with too.
… moreTony Starks
This is not the original Wiseguys pizza! The taste of the pizza is different, and all of the staff is new. They say it’s the same, and hasn’t been bought out or changed the pizza recipe, but if you know Wiseguys, this is not it! Pizza taste just like everyone else in Pittsburgh….plaine, and greasy I’m so mad Jeff left this place a while back, it sucks now. Thought I would never say that smh.
… moreKit Mozeko
Hot and fresh literally every time I order. The 1 topping pickup special will keep me coming back for years
… moreAnthony Comiskey
Best Pizza in Pittsburgh; Hands down. Great selection of specialty pizza available. Hoagies are tremendous too. The employees are friendly and helpful. Can not recommend this place enough.
… moreCharles Wagner
Have been ordering from Wiseguys for a very long time. Started when I lived in the area and now that we live outside of the city we always make a point to order Wiseguys when possible. My wife simply loves their white pizza!!!!
… moreTim sean
The pizza is Delicious!! The service is amazing!! Both categories are consistent which is the key factor for me. Wise guys pizza is a great pick for your takeout and delivery needs
… moreStacey Branch
I used to order faithfully from here for many years. Now they have a new ordering system and want to charge an additional $1.00 for mayo if you get the Italian dressing. Seriously they are ripping people off.
… moreBrian Lego
Best pizza in the Northside, bar none. Treat yourself to a steak hoagie as well. Delivered quicker than I expected for a busy night.
… more