Brandon Whittemore
For a small eatery, I must give it 5 out of 5 for the awesome mushroom swish burger. Maybe 10 min wait, fries were hot. The burger was hand pressed which is an oddity today. And they did not charge extra for the grilled onions.
… more**
I ordered a mushroom swiss burger. It was cooked to perfection. I have had burgers in other places statewide. This was one of the best that I have ever had. The burger was not overcooked, undercooked, greasy, or lacked meat. They had a brand new cook there and I must say the presentation of the meal, including the meal itself, was great!!
The place was clean and friendly.
Thank you very much for your service.!! Yummy !
… moreBen VanLoon
Hit this place up for lunch from out of town.
Great server and food was delicious.
Philly Stilly was a perfect serving size.
… moreKristoffer Farrar
Yeah!! They are open again. Enjoyed the square pizza with ricotta cheese, basil and tomato. Are waitress was a sweetheart with a great attitude and excellent service. Prices were surprisingly low. The place was lively and would highly recommend making it your restaurant stop in Wellsville.
… morerob ford
Food comes pretty fast now since they’ve opened. Everything we’ve ordered has been good.
… moreJason Hamilton
Stillwater is an absolute gem! I’ve been here a few times and have yet to be disappointed. The food is fantastic—I’ve tried a bunch of different items on the menu, and each one has been delicious. The staff is always on their A-game, super friendly, and incredibly attentive without being overbearing. Plus, if you’re a sports fan, the atmosphere is perfect for catching a game. Highly recommend!
… morekatrina nelson
Beth the server was excellent and I highly recommend the harvest salad! Hands down the best I’ve had in a long time.
… moreIng Beck Anderson
We had the best experience and the food exceptional… vampires slyer pizza is amazing!!! Service A++…..thank you Kelly Forness! We will be back again to see you!
… moreMichelle Leitten
We have been here 4 times in the past two months and have been super impressed each time. The chicken sandwich tastes very fresh and is cooked perfectly. The harvest salad is loaded with toppings and is big enough for two people. I am fussy about my G&T and each time the bartender made it perfectly and the server showed patience and kindness. Also to note, the owner has been on the premises each occasion which included weekend and weeknights. The outdoor seating is a plus and the restaurant seemed very clean. My ONLY comment was that the outdoor music was a tad loud, but I am old and I asked if they would consider lowering the volume and they did, so thanks so much.
… moreKellie Graves
Very satisfied with your server Beth. She’s always busy, never standing around. Made our experience here very enjoyable. Of course great food! Sad to see some of the other employees just standing around. Overall, ask for Beth❣️ Employee of the year!
… more