Address and Contact Information
Address: 2612 New Butler Rd, New Castle, PA 16101
Phone: (724) 598-3500
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Fat Jimmy’s LLC, New Castle, PA 16107, US – MapQuest
Fat Jimmy’s LLC is a local establishment in New Castle, PA that offers a variety of food and beverage options. With a focus on providing a casual dining …
Fat Jimmy’s LLC – Best Barbecue in New Castle, PA
If you ever find yourself in New Castle, Pennsylvania, Fat Jimmy’s LLC is a must-visit dining gem tucked away at 2612 New Butler Rd. This cozy, rustic eatery …
Fat Jimmys BBQ LLC | New Castle PA – Facebook
Fat Jimmys BBQ LLC, New Castle. 154 likes · 302 were here. Barbecue Restaurant.
Reviews
Inda Akenhead
Fat Jimmy’s has tantalizing flavors that bring out the best in their food. Everything I have tried is delicious. Frog legs, Gator tail, and Pig Wings are my favorite next to their amazing baked beans. You can buy them by the quart also and it’s always worth it. I definitely recommend going. The staff is always friendly, helpful, and go out of their way to make your meal perfect.
… moreBenjamin Duncan
Awesome food in quality and value. My wife and I got the BBQ Sampler (see photos). It easily fed the both of us and was under $25! We’ll most definitely be going back.
… moreHeather Jost
Food was great, was kinda bummed on Not having the chicken wings, but hopefully next time we can get em!
… moreAllison Reynolds
Wow!!! Talk about the best little hole in the wall. Every single thing we ate was home cooked and absolutely delicious with decent prices and great portions! Between the four of us we had brisket sandwiches fries onion rings baked beans Mac and cheese and fresh steaks (made fresh on the grill out back – perfectly cooked to our asking). The sweetest waitress working her butt off serving everyone in the restaurant. Very small place but the seating in the back was made completely of wood with an adorable fire place to boot. Will be returning frequently as possible. Fresh brewed sweet tea was great too!!!
… moreTami Lee
Cozy little place! Prices were more than reasonable. Had enough parking. The staff were friendly and attentive. Kept my party with refills and napkins. It was cool to see the cook prepare the food behind the counter. Food came out correct to order. Now let’s talk food… Freaking amazing! Definitely was tasty and hit the spot! I will say that it was a little hot inside the building and my hair surely carried the grease smell home with me. But if in that area again, I would not hesitate to return to Fat Jimmy’s for another plate!
… moreGloria Jarrett
This is a great little hometown diner where you walk in and everybody knows your name. When we come in for breakfast you find all the regulars sitting at their favorite table or on a bar stool at the counter. The breakfasts are just right and very reasonably priced. Their BBQ is excellent and we were very satisfied when they catered it for our 4th of July family celebration. Service is very friendly and very attentive. No matter how busy they are, everything comes to your table timely and perfectly cooked.
… moreJoan Weaver
We were passing by and saw the sign so we turned and went back. The place doesn’t look like much but it was clean & cozy. The food is the winner we had pulled pork sandwiches with home made potato salad it was the best hubby had fresh cut fries the sandwiches were so delicious. Service was fast & friendly. We live about 90 miles away but we WILL return to try something else… yummy!
… morebrandon l
I’ve been wanting to try this place for a long time. They were the absolute worst ribs I’ve ever had. They were super dry and tough. I just ended up eating the sides and not eating the rest of the ribs. I gave them 3 stars because the waitress was so nice.
… moreJohn B (Johnb380)
Went for breakfast and the food was amazing. Staff was polite and helpful. Overall a great experience. They have buckwheat pancakes and they’re very tasty! Have to return for the BBQ or Saturdays they have steak night but great breakfast food and service!
… more