4.4 – 318 reviews • Pizza restaurant
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
slicelife.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Last Updates
Reviews
Mr Cintron
Unfortunately my card got charged and I didn’t have any money. There’s a guy with bald head, glasses gave it to me for free! Can’t believe that happened to me. God is good. Unexpected! Was gonna wait to go home, but it was in time. They have a patio, parking, nice place to chill at. Perfect location and decent prices. Come check it out!
… moreK S
Pizza was awesome today!
Update… Waited long period of time for the food. Pizza was borderline burnt. Cauliflower side had about 6 pieces. Called the manager and he was being obnoxious and made excuses and then did not make any offer for future visits. I let them no tgar my original review would be updated and no longer will be a customer.
… moreRobert Ebersole
Great pizza place. Greasy pizza you’ll need napkins to soak up. But hey, it tastes great!
Staff seemed friendly. Plenty of seating. Nice and clean. I got a pizza to take home, and it was still as good as the one we ate at the place.
From Sring Grove to Mcsherrystown: all three Brother’s pizza, on 116, never disappoints.
If I could change one thing at the shop. I’d put a pinball or arcade machine in. Claw machine is fine, but pinball is better.
… moreWilliam Ruiz
From a New Yorker, I’ve got to say this pizza is delicious. The right amount of consistency of dough, the crust was perfectly crisp. Just the right amount of great to dip the crust. The specialty slice allowed you to taste every ingredient. Definitely will be back! Great customer service, very friendly atmosphere
… moreHunter Sassani
This was the first time we’ve ever gotten their food. My wife was just in the area driving home from an appointment. Well, the way they packed everything made The food stay very warm for the 18 minute drive. Everything was prepared very nicely and the food was absolutely delicious. The prices are absolutely incredible especially with how expensive everything else is around this area. I highly recommend this place. We will absolutely be back. 10/10.
… moreRebecca Beas
LOVE their Pizza! They hook me up with extra garlic when I ask, and always deliver on time if not a little quicker than expected. Few times I’ve gone in, staff has been kind and accommodating. Gotta love the fountain Pepsi as well. Pairs perfect with hot cheesy pizza. Brothers is my #1 pizza place!!!
… moreTabitha Madison
Stuck waiting for load to be ready. Found Brother’s Pizza on Maps search. We ordered the Sicilian special & onion rings. So delicious !! Being in a Semi, we had it delivered to the Rutter’s. Driver called when he got here to make sure he was going to the correct truck. We will definitely be back to try more from the menu! Highly recommend if you are in the York, PA area!!
… moreDexter Scott
Awesome local restaurant! Called close to closing and they made my order in record time and I enjoyed there talk ! And the food is the best! Thanks guys for making a trucker happy
… moreMatt Griesemer
This little pizza shop is a hidden gem, serving up some of the best New York-style pizza in the York area. The crust is thin, crisp, and holds up perfectly, no flop at all. My only minor critique is that I would’ve liked a bit more sauce, but overall, I really enjoyed the large cheese pizza we ordered. The staff were all friendly and made a genuine effort to greet us and thank us for stopping in, which added to the great experience. Prices were very reasonable. I’ll definitely be back!
… moreDaniel L.
Omg great experience. Friendly crew. Delicious pizza. Excellent price. What more can you ask for?
Alex (manager) runs a good program here. Open kitchen is very clean and sanitary.
Def coming back for the two cheese pizza deal.
… more … View more