Elle L.
I gave this place five stars because of the service that I received. A customer came in after me and saw that I had not finished deciding my order. She then proceeds to talk to the cashier and place her order. The cashier understood what she wanted and then explained that she’ll place that order in as soon as she’s finished with me! That was so nice of her to acknowledge me and not just disregard me. So I’m writing this post because kindness goes a long way and I’d like to give her a thank you her name is Michelle! I will definitely be coming back and recommend me this place just because of her!!!
… moreG .u
Be careful when purchasing food from this pizzeria I was charged twice for the same transaction. My wife had ordered pizza for delivery which she had paid for with cash . A day or two later, I was just checking my debit card app and somehow Marios pizzeria had a charge on my debit card as well which is completely unacceptable
One pie of cheese, pizza, almost, ended up costing me $60 along with the extra charge on my card with out my authorization . Be aware of this place they will charge you multiple for times for the same thing
… moreC O
Ordered a chicken bacon ranch pie and was told it would be 20 minutes for pick up. Got to Mario’s 25 minutes later and was told it would be just a few more minutes. The restaurant wasn’t busy so I’m not sure what took so long but I ended up standing there waiting another 20 minutes. If it’s going to take 45 minutes just say that instead of having people wait.
The pie has always been good so I figured it would be worth the wait, however it was extremely greasy and was falling apart.
Won’t be returning.
… morejoseph henry
8/24/24 ordered vodka pie with some garlic knots probably one of the best slices I’ve had service was great food was excellent blows others away
… moreRichard A Waskewicz
Very good pizza. Friendly service. Had grandma slices. Would definitely go back. Recommend.
… moreJay Fac
Slowest service I have ever seen, five people standing behind the counter nobody online I stand here for five minutes, waiting for them to take the slices and put them into the oven. I then watch as five guys stand around. I asked the girl you haven’t even put my slices in the oven yet and her response is I’m sorry we’re very backed up. Granted there is nobody online. There is five people working behind the counter. I don’t know who’s running this place but they should stop looking at their phones which they’ve been doing the entire time of standing here and focus on helping some customers.
… moreJohn N Mk
One of the best pizzeria/restaurants in town. Chicken marsala and spinach & ricotta topped pizza are really delicious. They could serve as an entree on their own. The standard silician pizza is so good as well. The crust is baked well, crispy.and the mozarella cheese used is high quality. The pizza isn’t too greasy or the crust too thick either. Wraps and paninis are also served here. Try the eggplant and pesto panini. The breaded eggplant patties are thin but extremely flavorful and the sauce is amazing! The staff greet you when you walk in and are friendly and accomodating. Mario’s is rapidly becoming a destination eatery right here on Long Island. Enjoy.
… moreMelinda Starnes
The pizza was delicious and the staff was great!
… moreJames
There pizza is always delicious and cooked perfectly every time.
… moreJonquel NYC
This place is so clean it’s spotless! The service was very friendly, the Pizza really good, the Calzone was huge, And there’s parking!
… more