adalie hoke
Alfredo is bland, but noodles are cooked nicely, and it’s very saucy. Wings probably would be better. Bone in. Not much flavor on them, but still good. Cheese bread is pretty good. I liked it. Pizza is pretty good. it’s delicious. I want to visit in person, but today, I ordered delivery to New Prague from the Belle Plain location. I got the Greek Hoagie, and it was very cheesy and looked amazing.
… moreTaylor Knick
Placed a to-go order this evening and was not disappointed! We got Kenzie’s bacon cheeseburger pizza and my 3 year old ate more than I’ve ever seen her consume in one sitting. The hoagie was also delicious and I can’t wait to eat the leftovers for lunch tomorrow! We’re looking forward to dining in sometime in the future.
… moreRyan Quattrocchi
Multiple times of me trying, and its not ok for me. Mind you this is only a review on the food.
Overly priced, poorly cooked, soaked in grease.
Tonight i tried a Hoagie…a Bacon Ranch Hoagie…and it was disgusting. Soaked in grease, burnt bread and the bacon was burnt…no flavors besides grease.
The pizza isnt good, to much cheese, to much grease.
The pasta is great!
The wings..well the wings are straight garbage like the hoagie i just tried.
I will consistently say the pasta is top tier. But the rest is absolutely trash especially the pricing compared to other places.
Service and time wise top tier.
… moreJill Ibel
Fantastic! If you had a bad experience try again. I was a 50 yr old child in a candy store when I opened my box and found it loaded with fresh ingredients. For the past 2 Deliveries. Our Meals were delivered before it was promised. Mizzys is our spot for good.
… moreSeth Peake
Mizzy’s is a nice clean joint. A couple tables and chairs. But the MAIN attraction is the ingredients. Fresh! And the dough. It’s got the cell structure that I looks for big airy bubbles within the crust. I make neopolitan pizza myself. And the double 0 flour I use produces crust with a lot of “cell structure”. I find that in their dough. They indeed have a perfect crust for their pizzas. With that being said. If your in Belle Plain or even traveling through it. STOP HERE for some absolutely incredible pizza!
… moreEmma Mankowski
I’ve generally had a positive experience ordering from this place, primarily for delivery. While the food tends to arrive lukewarm, I attribute that to my location in Henderson, and it’s not a big deal—I usually just reheat it in the air fryer or microwave, which works perfectly.
My go-to order is their Fettuccine Alfredo, which I customize by adding broccoli and mushrooms. Some reviews mention that the Alfredo can be flavorless, and I agree it could use a bit more seasoning. However, considering the affordability, I find it satisfying enough.
The hoagies are excellent—really flavorful and well-made—and the garlic Parmesan bites are absolutely delicious. I haven’t tried their pizza yet, but based on everything else, I plan to do so soon.
Overall, a solid option, especially if you’re craving comforting, reasonably priced Italian
… moreRebekah Trudel
Food was great. No service at all. Had to ask for something to drink, my husband had get up n get menu. Then the young man said when ur ready to order come up to the desk. Only service was they brought the food
… moreR Storlie
Ordered curbside due to social distancing. Online order was easy and even had coupons on their website. We ordered two 12-piece wings-hot, bbq, and oven roasted variety with blue cheese and ranch dressing packets, and they were very good! The owner had a table outside that he cleaned in front of me, then placed my order on it. Hopped out of my car to retrieve and was able to stay 6 ft apart easily. Owner was super friendly and appreciative. Was only in the area to drop off TP to a friend but if I lived closer I’d order the wings again.
… moremickkie
I have been a returning customer to mizzys since 2020. We live in le Sueur, we don’t care about paying the extra delivery fee because the food was so great. Just recently we had ordered a pizza and it never came- called the next day asking what happened. Was told the driver had a hard time finding our house and delivered it to our neighbors. He said they will send us another one – free of charge (although we were still charged for our stolen pizza.)
So I am waiting for our second pizza and we see the delivery guy going to the wrong house- AGAIN. My husband ran down the street as the driver was getting out of his car with our pizza talking to some lady at her house. My husband yells “Dude you got the wrong house.” He replies, “Well I’ve never been to this town before.”
Long story short- after a loyal two years- no more mizzys! This is how our pizza looked as well. Such a shame. They need better help!
… moreSara Davis
This is the best pizza, everything is always so fresh and tasty! The staff is very friendly and the restaurant and restrooms are very clean. It’s a great place to grab a quick lunch when you are in Carver.
… more