Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
A retro styled coffee house known for our fun monthly drink features, and serving up pDillano’s Coffee Roaster’s drip coffee, plenty of speciality espresso and cold brew beverages, energy drinks, and an array of coffee-free drinks. We also serve breakfast sandwiches, lunch sandwiches and salads, and a selection of delicious baked goods. Join us inside, take it to go, or stop by our convenient drive-thru. Call ahead orders are accepted for speedier service! If you’re looking for retail coffee bags, loose leaf tea and tea bags, gifts, and more, be sure to come inside to browse our selection. It’s time to shake up your taste buds!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 15 E Lincoln Ave, Myerstown, PA 17067
Phone: (717) 628-5160
Website: http://www.sugarshakercafe.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
The Sugar Shaker: Coffee Shop
Coffee shop with inside seating and convenient drive-through, featuring espresso beverages, energy drinks, lunch, & breakfast.
The Sugar Shaker | Myerstown PA – Facebook
The Sugar Shaker, Myerstown. 4629 likes · 21 talking about this · 1308 were here. The Sugar Shaker is a small, retro styled coffee shop also serving…
The Sugar Shaker – Visit Lebanon Valley, Pennsylvania
Myerstown, PA – The Sugar Shaker’s retro-styled coffeeshop and drive-thru are the place to go for a variety of coffees, teas, sweet treats and savory sandwiches …
Product
Reviews
Tim V
Awesome coffee shop. Love the 50s theme. The girl who served me today for my first visit on 02/27/2026 was friendly and polite. Five stars for service right there. It’s also nice to get out in Myerstown and see some of the nice people in town. I had a breakfast sandwich (sausage egg and cheese on an English muffin) and an iced chocolate banana mocha. The sandwhich was pretty good, but the mocha was the star of the show. Good size and the flavors were on point. It is a little pricey, not terrible and what isn’t these days, but definitely a great spot that I will hit up once a week. Probably a weekend stop for me. Thank you Sugar Shaker staff!
… moreRachelandCorby Wolfe
The atmosphere here was super fun. They’ve got some retro island vibes and it was definitely an experience to remember. The lady that spoke to us was super friendly and knowledgeable about their entire menu.
We got a mocha latte with coconut, masala chai frappe, chicken salad croissant, knuckle sandwich, and a cinnamon roll.
The mocha latte with coconut: well balanced, not too sweet. My husband was expecting decadent, but was pleasantly surprised at how smooth and balanced it was. The espresso shot was pulled pretty well and it wasn’t bitter.
The chai frappe: very good. It definitely felt like a treat, not just a frozen coffee. The lady shared they use a frappe powder, so it would make it more sweet, to which I was fine with. Overall a good chai, just wish it had a bit more of a kick with being labeled as “masala”.
Chicken salad croissant: the croissant was warmed up, which I thought was a nice touch. All the flavors blended really nicely.
Knuckle sandwich: good hearty sandwich with lots of flavor, but nothing that made it “extraordinary” in comparison to similar sandwiches elsewhere. If we’re being honest, it was not quite worth the $9. If there was any way it could be cheaper, like $6, it definitely would be worth that. It would definitely be a sandwich I’d come back for again. Same goes for the chicken salad croissant — overpriced.
Cinnamon Roll: well worth the price. They warmed it up and the icing was just the right amount and not overly sweet. It was nice and soft. Not the best cinnamon roll I’ve had (check out Olga’s Cinnamon Rolls if you’re ever in Gatlinburg ), but their price for it was definitely representative of it and very satisfied for that price.
Overall very good experience. A couple things that would’ve made this 5 stars, would be adjustment of pricing on a few items to reflect similar pricing to other places in comparison to quality, or adding something “special” or “unique” to the items to make them worth the price (like a special sauce or side).
… moreWe got a mocha latte with coconut, masala chai frappe, chicken salad croissant, knuckle sandwich, and a cinnamon roll.
The mocha latte with coconut: well balanced, not too sweet. My husband was expecting decadent, but was pleasantly surprised at how smooth and balanced it was. The espresso shot was pulled pretty well and it wasn’t bitter.
The chai frappe: very good. It definitely felt like a treat, not just a frozen coffee. The lady shared they use a frappe powder, so it would make it more sweet, to which I was fine with. Overall a good chai, just wish it had a bit more of a kick with being labeled as “masala”.
Chicken salad croissant: the croissant was warmed up, which I thought was a nice touch. All the flavors blended really nicely.
Knuckle sandwich: good hearty sandwich with lots of flavor, but nothing that made it “extraordinary” in comparison to similar sandwiches elsewhere. If we’re being honest, it was not quite worth the $9. If there was any way it could be cheaper, like $6, it definitely would be worth that. It would definitely be a sandwich I’d come back for again. Same goes for the chicken salad croissant — overpriced.
Cinnamon Roll: well worth the price. They warmed it up and the icing was just the right amount and not overly sweet. It was nice and soft. Not the best cinnamon roll I’ve had (check out Olga’s Cinnamon Rolls if you’re ever in Gatlinburg ), but their price for it was definitely representative of it and very satisfied for that price.
Overall very good experience. A couple things that would’ve made this 5 stars, would be adjustment of pricing on a few items to reflect similar pricing to other places in comparison to quality, or adding something “special” or “unique” to the items to make them worth the price (like a special sauce or side).
Angelina
Stopped in with my daughter for a macchiato and a snack. Loved the atmosphere and decor. Service was friendly and our order arrived quickly and was delicious. Will definitely be back
… moreKennilyn
Great little place to stop. Sweet smiling faces, awesome atmosphere and service. Disappointed with the sandwiches and bagels. Some where along the line, food quality went down from years ago. Remember some really nice sandwiches packed with eggs, bacon and cheese. What happened?
… moreNyasia Perez
Great place. Love their steamers! Everyone is kind and colorful! Love it here! I hope they open more locations and expand their business hours!
… moreBrad Moyer
First time stopping here and it didn’t disappoint. Got a medium iced Carmel macchiato and it tastes wonderful! Inside is decorative with a good theme and employees were wonderful!
… moreKaren Aranha
Very 50s themed cute little coffee shop with about ample space to fit about 10-15 max.
Currently running specials for Valentine’s day. I tried the Strawberry cupcake latte and it was delicious. The Not so Plain Jane bagel sandwich was good too. We will be back.
… moreCurrently running specials for Valentine’s day. I tried the Strawberry cupcake latte and it was delicious. The Not so Plain Jane bagel sandwich was good too. We will be back.
Tammy Douglas
What a cool place! The peppermint mocha latte was perfect. I was greeted immediately and the level of customer service was phenomenal. The pet snacks were a nice surprise and got a 4 paws up review from our furbaby. I can’t wait to go back for some of the food options and teas.
… moreMackenzie Feeley
Sugar Shaker never disappoints! Weekend lunch from the The Sugar Shaker. I ordered the Knuckle Sandwich made with egg, sausage, bacon and ham with pepper jack cheese on toasted everything bagel & a Mango Smoothie as a sweet treat. Their breakfast sandwiches, coffee, and other menu items are SO good! If you haven’t already, check out the Sugar Shaker for your next meal.
-Follow @centralpafoodie on Instagram for more PA food reviews & pictures!
… more-Follow @centralpafoodie on Instagram for more PA food reviews & pictures!
Katrina Burkholder
Finally checked this place out and was not disappointed! The retro atmosphere was pleasant and our drinks and food were delicious! Will definitely be back!
… more