Address and Contact Information
Address: 8809 Mitchell Blvd, New Port Richey, FL 34655
Phone: (727) 339-3003
Website: http://primanypizza-fl.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Prima NY Pizza: Best Pizza Restaurant in New Port Richey, Florida
Enjoy authentic Pizza cuisine at Prima NY Pizza in New Port Richey, Florida. Online order, delivery, and pickup available. Order now!
Prima NY Pizza | New Port Richey FL – Facebook
Beautiful place! Come visit! Bring your family and have some pizza We are the #1 pizza place in trinity. Pizza is made out of New York water.
Order Prima Pizza – 8809 Mitchell Boulevard | New Port Richey
Get delivery or takeout from Prima Pizza – 8809 Mitchell Boulevard at 8809 Mitchell Blvd in New Port Richey. Order online and track your order live.
Reviews
Trina Wiegand
Saw a review about this place and couldn’t wait to try. I’m so glad I did this pizza was as close to New York as I could find. All fresh ingredients and they use New York water! I will definitely be back. Try the chicken parm pizza omg. So good! The owner was extremely friendly too! Can’t wait to try the penne vodka pizza!
… moreCollin Birren
I recently visited this pizza spot and was thoroughly impressed from start to finish. We ordered a large cheese pizza that delivered authentic NY-style perfection—thin, foldable crust with just the right amount of char and a delicious cheese-to-sauce ratio that hit all the right notes.
The garlic knots were a standout side. They arrived perfectly crispy on the outside while remaining soft inside, loaded with flavor that didn’t disappoint. The marinara sauce served alongside was fresh and complemented the knots beautifully.
Everything tasted incredibly fresh, which made a noticeable difference in the overall experience. The restaurant itself was spotlessly clean with a welcoming atmosphere that made our visit enjoyable.
What really set this place apart was the outstanding service. The staff was genuinely friendly and went above and beyond. When we mentioned taking our pizza to go, our server thoughtfully offered to cook it a little less than usual, explaining it would reheat better at home. He even took the time to box everything up carefully for us. This kind of attentive service shows they truly care about the customer experience beyond just making a sale.
I highly recommend this pizzeria for anyone craving authentic NY-style pizza with top-notch service. We’ll definitely be returning.
… moreThe garlic knots were a standout side. They arrived perfectly crispy on the outside while remaining soft inside, loaded with flavor that didn’t disappoint. The marinara sauce served alongside was fresh and complemented the knots beautifully.
Everything tasted incredibly fresh, which made a noticeable difference in the overall experience. The restaurant itself was spotlessly clean with a welcoming atmosphere that made our visit enjoyable.
What really set this place apart was the outstanding service. The staff was genuinely friendly and went above and beyond. When we mentioned taking our pizza to go, our server thoughtfully offered to cook it a little less than usual, explaining it would reheat better at home. He even took the time to box everything up carefully for us. This kind of attentive service shows they truly care about the customer experience beyond just making a sale.
I highly recommend this pizzeria for anyone craving authentic NY-style pizza with top-notch service. We’ll definitely be returning.
Sarah Keane
Their food is absolutely DELICIOUS! The staff members are great, friendly, and welcoming! Highly recommend! It’s nice and quiet during the weekdays not too sure about the weekends, so if you want to have somewhere to eat that’s quiet during the weekends at night, this is your place! They have a little bit of everything which is very nice for people who are picky (like myself!)
… moreRamzy Saleh
This place is a hidden gem. From the first bite, you can tell the quality is there—the crust has the perfect crunch on the outside while staying light inside, and the sauce is flavorful without being overpowering. The toppings are fresh and generously portioned, which makes every slice satisfying.
We also tried the minestrone soup, and it was excellent—warm, hearty, and packed with flavor. The food feels homemade and done right. We’ve already come back multiple times, and it’s quickly become one of our go-to pizza spots. Highly recommend stopping in if you appreciate really good pizza and comforting Italian food.
… moreWe also tried the minestrone soup, and it was excellent—warm, hearty, and packed with flavor. The food feels homemade and done right. We’ve already come back multiple times, and it’s quickly become one of our go-to pizza spots. Highly recommend stopping in if you appreciate really good pizza and comforting Italian food.
Jess
Great pizza! We live in a small town, in the middle of no where, and I am always looking for good NY pizza to bring me back to my childhood. This hit the spot. And the owner is great! We will be back when we come to visit the in-laws again!
… moreLloyd Braden
My first visit, I met a large group for lunch. I had the meatball parmesan hoagie, it was very good! Others had pizza, salads, rolls (like a calzone) and everyone said theirs was very good. The service was a little slow because there was only one person on staff, but he was hustling to take the counter orders, prepare food and deliver to our table. Considering the size of our group, he did a great job getting our orders out as timely as possible. Overall very good, I will definitely go back again.
… moreMatthew Clockel
The app I developed told me to come here. This pizza shop made the top pizza near me so I decided to try this place out. This was really good pizza and I am glad I found this place so close to my house. I will be back. I ordered the pizza alla vodka with some extra toppings and fried raviolis.
… moreKezia
Incredible! This place is the bomb. Got the penne a la vodka pizza and it was so mouthwatering. The vodka sauce had the perfect tang but it was impossible to eat more than one slice because of how filling it is. We also got the chicken roll though we were so full we haven’t tried it yet but it smells and looks amazing. Everything was HUGE and well worth it for the pricing. We will be back ASAP.
*they use water from New York. Trust me, this makes a big difference
… more*they use water from New York. Trust me, this makes a big difference
Mitchell Hammond
The owner was very kind and even gave us a complimentary two liter of Diet Coke. The pizza was great and came out really quick. Fair warning, the 28” pizza is MASSIVE there was 6 of us and we couldn’t finish it, which is saying a lot because I can eat a lot. Overall the place was excellent, highly recommend!
… moreMegan Manaras
Ordered pizza from here for the first time tonight. It was seriously the best buffalo chicken pizza I’ve ever had. The other pizza we had was great too. Will be back!
… more