Andrew Hulfish
Highly disappointed with Marlton, Gaetanos. Ordered a LARGE buffalo and barely any sauce on it. Convinced my son to come here tonight over another place and what a big disappointed. Not worth going back for a fix.
… moreBrian Gressel
Although the staff was polite and the place was clean, I can’t give a positive review after being charged $3 for fried onions on my cheese steak. It probably cost them .05 cents for what they charged $3 for. The steak was $24 as it is, and that is excessive also. Gaetanos was one of the best places to get food from at a reasonable price once upon a time, but not anymore.
… moreUna Sutton
Sandwiches shrink each time we go. Definitely not worth $28 anymore!!!!
And those can mushrooms are disgusting . Please get fresh mushrooms, slice them, throw on the grill and add to the meat. Will make all the world in the taste.
… moreJ McCullough
This place is CLEAN… The cheesesteak I had was fantastic. Meat/ cheese ratio perfect.
Looks like the Owner works it Himself
( With help during busier time of day).
He’s very personable and engaging and makes you feel like he knew you forever.
… moredesiree pittman
Almost everytime I go and visit out there I go order me a cheesesteak sandwich. It be so good! I wish there was one bye closer.
… moreOrin Nester (OrinJ)
Pricey but overall a pretty good sandwich. They do try to upsell you on the items that should be in sandwich already but they barely put in enough i comparison to the size of the of the sandwich
… moreMark Heck
Best cheesesteaks. You will not be left hungry.
Pictured Jersey Chicken Cheesesteak (with fries on it, my fav) and
Cheesesteak.
… moreBrian Brown
I bought the 11″ cheesesteak with fried onions and Cooper sharp. When I checked out it was over $16 and thought way to expensive. However it was huge and delicious can’t wait to buy another one! I went back a second time ordered a whole Cheestaek for about $26 bucks but was disappointed as it was dry and not as good as last time.
… moreJesse G
Grandma pie undercooked. Even after extra oven time at home not good. Ordered buff chicken steak sandwich no cheese and got a regular chicken cheese steak. 11 dollars for 3 sloppy mozzarella sticks is criminal as well. Also took almost an hour for a pickup order they forgot about
… moreAnthony Ramirez
Cheese steak was horrible and not much on it for what you pay for the 17″
… more