Kirby
Overall a good pizza. Sauce a bit of a tang to it which was nice, cheese good crust good. Tasty. Score 7.4
… moreKristen Minamyer
I actually didn’t order the pizza so I have no idea of cost, friendliness or anything like that. We had it at a cub scout meeting and it was FANTASTIC! The crust was amazing. The sauce was sweeter than I think most people would expect but to me that made it so much better!! I’ll be ordering from Romeos in the future!!
… moreDawn
Update:. Haven’t been contacted by anyone still but we’ve ordered several times since my original review. The Large one topping special is definitely THE way to go! But… Sometimes it’s *OMG this is the best pizza ever!* and other times it’s *Eh… The sauce seems different.* Haven’t put my finger on it, but we’re determined to figure out the common denominator. (When the sauce is on point… The sauce is ON POINT!)
——————————————————————–
I’m giving three stars because the pizza tasted good. The sauce is zesty but sweet, so I really liked it. But I ordered a large “Tuscan Pepperoni” and I thought a large pizza was supposed to have 10 slices. I was given an 8 slice and I paid $20.99! Unfortunately I didn’t look at the pizza until I got back home. Then, I looked at the menu that I grabbed when I picked up the pizza and saw the “Grand Opening Special” which is a large 1 topping for $10.99. I could have purchased a regular pizza with old world pepperoni and saved 10 bucks! I basically paid all that extra for a little bit of fresh mozzarella cheese! I think that was kind of shady of Romeo’s… Not a good way for a new business to gain loyal customers!
(A tip for anyone who wants to order by phone… Their menu doesn’t list prices, but if you go to the website and click “order online” and add items to your cart, it will give you the cost of each item in there at checkout. Then you can just cancel and call to place your order.)
… moreWilliam Bell Jr
Ordered two large pizzas, one with pepperoni and one with sausage. My order was placed at 1126. After an hour and a half I called to check the status of my order and was asked if my order was for pickup or delivery. I said it was for delivery, the young man on the phone seemed surprised and told me it was out for delivery. I live five minutes from Romeo’s, it took another twenty minutes for my order to be delivered.
The pizza was luke warm as if they tried to reheat it real quick and get it delivered. The pizza sauce was too sweet for my taste. The pepperoni was crispy which I liked.
I WILL NOT BE ORDERING FROM HERE AGAIN… I DID NOT LIKE THE PIZZA.
… moreVic Berlon
We order from Romeo’s quite a bit. The last time our pizza showed up and hour and a half late and cold. We tried contacting the store a few times but there was no answer. Finally after an hour we talked to someone who told me that door dash didn’t pick up our order. How do you let an order sith there and not call the customer to tell them there’s an issue? We were offered nothing for the inconvenience. Reached out to the corporate office and got no response. Right after the phone call ended door dash texted that our order would be delivered. Which makes me wonder was door dash even contacted?
… moreJeffie Cruz
I absolutely LOVE their pizza. I work at the Red Roof Inn in Poland, ever since the new location open I have been referring all my guest to order from them and order as often as I can myself. The manager Brandy was amazing when I had an issue and was so quick to resolve it that the issue itself is not even worth mentioning! Thank you so much for being as loyal to your customers as we are to you!!!
… moreSteven Tompkins
Sauce was as advertised, good. But price/value one star. Green peppers and mushrooms one on pie just south of $20.00. I’ve got more green peppers on my salad. Ordered two large pies and both came with a couple of slices about inch and half wide. I can get bad cut pizza at Marco’s for half the price.
My first visit will go back to Domino’s and Marco’s for better deals.
… moreLyndsey Nelson
The BEST pizza. The taste in general is unique and the sauce is sweet. The service is always good, wait times is short and pizza is always ready on time and warm. A bit more pricey than some other places but I’d rather pay a few extra bucks and get better quality pizza. This pizza is always my go to choice
… moreSarah Green
Listen, we love pizza and trying New kinds of pizza. Very impressed with Romeo’s.Crispy crust (perfectly baked!), sweet pizza sauce (which we really enjoyed) and friendly staff. We ordered a medium Romeo’s Deluxe and Pepperoni Feast. The price with applied coupons (online) was overall reasonable and worth every bite! Watch out Cocca’s!!
… moreM Liggett
Pizza was tasty. Ordered online easily however did not get what was ordered. Ordered a pizza with sausage, green peppers. What we got was sausage, pepperoni, tomatoes, red onions and hot peppers. Considering it was ordered online, there’s no reason to mess up the order that bad. 5 people inside, no one bothers to check order is right?
… more