Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
The Shop brings new world inspiration to the traditional dishes and ingredients of the old world. We are a one stop Shop for Artisanal pizzas, hand crafted pastas, and sandwiches that are destined to make you feel like you are back in the old country. If you are looking to cook at home, we offer a wide array of imported specialty goods along with prepared sauces, chef inspired recipes, and fresh breads. The Shop has a brand new dining room space which holds 50-60 people events. Please call if you are interested in renting the dining room.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 465 Main St, Chatham, NJ 07928
Phone: (973) 635-2757
Website: http://www.theshopchatham.com/
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Pizza Shop – CLOSED, 465 Main St, Chatham, NJ 07928, US
Get more information for Pizza Shop in Chatham, NJ. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Under New Ownership, The Pizza Shop in Chatham Takes its Food …
The Shop has taken over the Cafe Villa in the Main Street Chatham (New Jersey) Shopping Center.
Favorite Pizza Shop in Chatham, NJ – Facebook
My new favorite. The Pizza Shop in Chatham NJ User shares their new favorite pizza shop in Chatham, NJ, and receives comments about the …
Reviews
Chuck Mound
Scouting for the Pizza Hunters App. No Plain slices here, or I was told that the Main Street was their Regular Slice. This is what I Ordered. It was a good slice, but needed more ingredients. Nice Crunch to the Crust, just not enough Cheese and Sauce to balance the slice. 3.5. The layout was excellent as well as the Pizza Presentation. A New Location that will continue to get better. They are off to a solid start with the Pizza. I will be back for sure.
… morePaul H
Newly opened and recommended by a friend and colleague who lives in town. They raved about their takeout. We ordered pizza (Sunday Gravy) and pasta (Genoa Pesto) to go.
At home they both looked very good prior to reheating and both reheated very nicely. Nice! The pizza had flavorful meat topping and cheese. Loved the crust a little too much in the sense that you try not to eat the crust-ends so that you can have another slice, but you windup eating the crust-ends anyway and have to put off the extra slice for the next day to avoid over eating more of this delious pie. My wife puts this pizza in the top 10% of the places she’s had. The pasta and pesto was flavorful and balanced without being oily and overly seasoned. We want to go back for more takeout to try some of their other dishes. Though we did not eat there, I did note they had three distinct dining areas (High tops, small tables and what appeared to be another area for slightly larger parties).
On a personal note: though the state has temporarily rescinded mask-wearing, the food preparers and wait staff were maksless. For anyone who cares about this sort of thing.
… moreAt home they both looked very good prior to reheating and both reheated very nicely. Nice! The pizza had flavorful meat topping and cheese. Loved the crust a little too much in the sense that you try not to eat the crust-ends so that you can have another slice, but you windup eating the crust-ends anyway and have to put off the extra slice for the next day to avoid over eating more of this delious pie. My wife puts this pizza in the top 10% of the places she’s had. The pasta and pesto was flavorful and balanced without being oily and overly seasoned. We want to go back for more takeout to try some of their other dishes. Though we did not eat there, I did note they had three distinct dining areas (High tops, small tables and what appeared to be another area for slightly larger parties).
On a personal note: though the state has temporarily rescinded mask-wearing, the food preparers and wait staff were maksless. For anyone who cares about this sort of thing.
Ellie Terrett
Had lunch at The Shop with some friends and the food was off the charts! Aside from having the best pizza in the area, they also have great restaurants-style entrees. Pistachio-encrusted salmon was one of the best I’ve ever had.
… moreEric Williams
The Shop is awesome! I work nearby so I come here often for lunch.
The pizza is delicious, everything from the plain to the elaborate. Thin crust, great sauce, and generous on the cheese. I highly recommend the Pesto Grandma and the Chicken Fresco. I watched the chef build the Chicken Fresco, and it was like watching an artist. The fresh mozzarella, tomaotoes, and basil are delicious; the drizzle of balsamic brings it to the next level.
They have a great lunch combo during the week, any two slices plus a can of soda (or bottle of water) for just $7. Awesome.
Shout out to Gustavo behind the counter, he’s a good guy and is passionate about food.
Update: Today I had the Italian Beef sandwich, and it was fantastic. Nicely spicy, but not overly. Really great cheesesteak with onions and hot peppers, and generous cheese on top!
… moreThe pizza is delicious, everything from the plain to the elaborate. Thin crust, great sauce, and generous on the cheese. I highly recommend the Pesto Grandma and the Chicken Fresco. I watched the chef build the Chicken Fresco, and it was like watching an artist. The fresh mozzarella, tomaotoes, and basil are delicious; the drizzle of balsamic brings it to the next level.
They have a great lunch combo during the week, any two slices plus a can of soda (or bottle of water) for just $7. Awesome.
Shout out to Gustavo behind the counter, he’s a good guy and is passionate about food.
Update: Today I had the Italian Beef sandwich, and it was fantastic. Nicely spicy, but not overly. Really great cheesesteak with onions and hot peppers, and generous cheese on top!
Nick Laul
Fab food. Pizza crust was spot on. Crispy edges with a chew in the center. And not overdressed. Enjoyed this pizza as much as some of the other ones I’ve had in Brooklyn. Pesto was slightly under salted but flavour was amazing and the fact you could see the pine nuts meant that this is the real thing. Will definitely eat here again.
… moreChristopher Bezzone
Friendly neighborhood spot, with excellent pizza and simple Italian pastas and sandwiches for any type of guest. Good place to bring the kids and take out. The private room in the back is perfect for any kind of family, friends or company party. Love it here!
… moreSally Simonfay
I have been to the Shop three times since it opened- most recently last night for a party in their back room. The party space is bright, clean, and tastefully simple. The traditional Italian menu was delicious…fresh ingredients. The leftover tomato/ red sauce from my chicken parm was so good that I actually ate it with a spoon. The unexpected surprise was the pizza…the crust was so freaking amazing. Finally, I loved how the lettuce leaves in my salad were chopped into smaller pieces – it tastes so much better that way! Lots of menu items for my kids….both of whom have nut allergies
… moreMarie Lachanski
We had dinner her for the opening of the “Supper Club” and everything was perfect. We had the ricotta raviolini as our first course and they were a perfect blend of homemade goodness. For our second course, we had the short ribs and the salmon which were both melt in your mouth amazing and more than enough food that we had to take some home. Everyone was friendly, accommodating and the service was impeccable.
For this being their first Supper Club opening it was outstanding because you always expect some quirks. There was not one and we cannot wait for our next visit.
… moreFor this being their first Supper Club opening it was outstanding because you always expect some quirks. There was not one and we cannot wait for our next visit.
Thomas Snarr
As first timers, we tried the basic – a cheese pizza. Ordered online fast and convenient using Apple Pay. Pleasantly surprised by the square pan crust. Good flavor – crust, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil and the sauce. All good.
Only drawback – sauce was a bit runny so the middle slice in a square cut pizza was also. They will figure this out.
We will go back – flavor was great.
… moreOnly drawback – sauce was a bit runny so the middle slice in a square cut pizza was also. They will figure this out.
We will go back – flavor was great.
Lisa Cinotti
The pizza here is outstanding! The “funghi” pie, the eggplant pie with delicious slices of fried eggplant … impossible to pick a favorite! I don’t always eat the crust on pizza, but ate every bit of it on the slices that I enjoyed today. We recently ordered for a work event, and were extremely pleased with The Shop.
… more