J. Ray
Stopped by on my way back from NSB. Was craving a Stromboli. Got one. It was SO fresh, Ooey, gooey, meat-filled, delicious. I thought it was short/small but it was packed full of toppings. I loved it. Wish it was bigger. I enjoyed the sauce on the side, too. Very tasteful. Clean inside. Nice employees. Support local.
… moreGun Slinging Gringo
Decent pizza spot to grab a few slices or get some food. The pizza was decent and everyone seems pretty nice inside. So definitely a spot to go check out if you haven’t been already.
… morePameLA MB
LOVE LOVE the Pizza. They do not skimp on the toppings. It’s just a little place, but usually clean. Thank you.
2 Large pieces of pizza + drink $5.50
… moreSharri Clifford
“John and the boys” took such great care of our baseball team families while we were in town for a tournament. So accommodating. Really good pizza and stellar, friendly service.
… moreDan Jackson
Are you tired of Pizza Hut, Domino’s & Papa John’s? Do you want a Ma & Pa Pizza made to order? I finally checked out this little Pizzeria in Holly Hill on US1. Been there since the 70s. Pizza reminds me of Pete’s or Anthony’s except with a much better sauce. I did takeout. See the Monday Night Specials.
… moreShawn Rossi
I truly want to support this local business, and I appreciate the friendly staff and their dedication to the community. However, I’ve found myself consistently underwhelmed by the pizza here. Every six months or so, I give it another try, hoping for a different experience—but I’m always reminded of how unremarkable it is.
I recently spent $50 on two pizzas—one deep dish and one traditional—and unfortunately, both were disappointing. The crust was undercooked and overly doughy, the flavors were flat, and there’s a noticeable lack of originality in the recipes. For a restaurant of this nature, I expect something that feels more authentic, more thoughtfully crafted.
By contrast, when I order from Domino’s, I end up eating more than I should simply because it tastes good. And when I make the 15-minute drive to Genovese’s in Ormond, I’m rewarded with what I consider the best pizza in town—authentic Italian flavor that feels worth every penny.
One thing that also makes it tough to be a regular customer is the limited availability. They close early on Fridays and aren’t open at all on Saturdays or Sundays, which are prime times for family pizza nights.
I say all this not out of malice, but out of hope that feedback might inspire improvement. The people and the potential are there; the flavor just needs to rise to meet them.
… moreBil Ped igo
Haven’t had Sorrentos in forever. Still holding it down after all these years!! Za was really good. Sauce was great. Highly recommended
… moreKim Pritchett
Food was horrible. We had pizza slices that tasted like they had been sitting for hours. Definitely wasn’t fresh and they weren’t even warm
… moreJesse Wenrich
Classic Pizza in a classic spot. Tha kid for a great lunch!!
… moreWilliam Nickerson
Absolutely great time wonderful ppl and atmosphere you can feel as you walk it very welcoming.
… more