* visit our website to order online! * We have been making authentic East New York pizza since 1971. Looking for real NY pizza? You found it. Established in 1971. Caterinas has been serving the East New York community for over 4 decades- that’s a lot of pizzas. We still make our pizza, pastas and dinner plates the same way we did back in 1971- If it ain’t broke don’t fix it.
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Caterinas Pizzeria – Brooklyn, NY – 907 Livonia Ave – Hours, Menu …
Local residents have made Caterinas Pizzeria one of the most popular in the area. Sample what they have to offer and see if you agree. Immerse yourself in the …
Caterina Pizza – Brooklyn, NY – 3035 Fulton St – Hours, Menu, Order
Traditional Pizzas · Best Seller. Cheese Pizza. Classic cheese or create your own pizza. $14.00 · Extra Cheese Pizza. $18.00 · Anchovies Pizza. $18.00 · Best …
Caterinas Pizzeria Delivery Menu | 907 Livonia Ave NY, Kings County
Order delivery or pickup from Caterinas Pizzeria in NY, Kings County! View Caterinas Pizzeria’s March 2026 deals and menus. Support your local restaurants …
Last Updates
Reviews
korra dale
A great dine‑in experience with tasty, well‑made pizza and fresh ingredients. The service is excellent—friendly, quick, and attentive throughout the meal. The atmosphere is relaxed and comfortable, making it an easy spot to enjoy good food without any fuss. Overall, a solid choice for a satisfying sit‑down meal.
… moreLeonardo Casali
Ordered via DoorDash, they made me wait almost 1 hour and then simply canceled the order for no reason at all. After 1 hour of wait.
… moreMina Dunston
If you looking for real authentic Italian pizza this is the place to go very clean respectful and everything is fresh and made with love ❤️
… moreAndwelle Crick
I watched the guy in the green shirt handle about 5 different customers food directly after handling money both bills and coins. This is DISGUSTING and I don’t know how inspection hasn’t caught up to them yet. I really hope they do after this post just out of concern for all the unsuspecting customers
… moreBeyard L. Davis
I smelt Caterinas Pizza when I got off the bus gotta have “TWO SLICES ” you know like Radio Raheem didnt have the boombox or attitude waited for the first pie fresh from oven its served in the box I opt for paper plates got’em flip the parch paper with slices one on top of other toss the box out position,g the hot girls bite it hot hot hot ok it’s good no condiments needed finished them by Stan lee Ave next time I’m sampling spett/mballs CIAO
… moreZoraida Velez
Just as expected!..Excellent NYC slice of Pepperoni pizza with a mango mandarin orange Snapple
… moreSONIA C
Food is always Delicious and thankful for the Regular Delivery
… morecito king
Still one.of the best pizza shops in ENY…has been for yrssss too
… moreJulio Almonte
This pizzeria has been around since I was a kid! Always had good New York style pizza!
… moreMarc Quadagno
Read the newspaper clipping on the wall: they are known for their deep dish pan pizza. Be smart: order the thick crust. I like the chicken, tomato & basil slice. And they have other things, too.
… more