Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Plaza Pizza® restaurant has been a beloved local spot for the Claggett family since it opened in Newark in 1971. Plaza Pizza® has introduced generations of families to our thin-crust creations, made with our distinctive, zingy sauce and served hot, fast, and fresh. That special Plaza Pizza® flavor made the Claggett family fall in love with all things pizza as kids, and when the chance to become owners arose in 2019, they jumped at the chance. Under Ben, Brian, and Olivia Claggett’s guidance, we’ve built Plaza Pizza® into a one-stop shop for pizzas made the same way, and with the same love, as ever.
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Plaza Pizza | Best Pizza in Ohio | Pizza near me
Welcome to Plaza Pizza. Ohio’s favorite neighborhood, family-friendly pizzeria is serving up smiles across Newark, Heath, and Johnstown! Visit any of our other …
Review of Plaza Pizza in Johnstown Ohio – Facebook
Never had it, but I grew up around Johnstown/Croton and Johnnie’s Villa Pizza is elite. The location of this pizza shop has changed several …
Order Plaza Pizza – Johnstown, OH Menu Delivery [Menu & Prices]
Get delivery or takeout from Plaza Pizza at 90 S Main St in Johnstown. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first order!
Last Updates
Reviews
Scott Axel
Very disappointed overall.
The pizza does have a unique and flaky crust but lacks seasoning and flavor.
The size names don’t matter. Yes, you can say it was my error for not realizing that “Large” actually meant “13 inches” and left a family of 3 still hungry.
The biggest disappointment is the location. One of the biggest convenience aspects of the location when it was Dirkos was the drive up window, which is gone now. My truck is pretty much as long as the limited parking so safely backing out of it was a great time.
… moreThe pizza does have a unique and flaky crust but lacks seasoning and flavor.
The size names don’t matter. Yes, you can say it was my error for not realizing that “Large” actually meant “13 inches” and left a family of 3 still hungry.
The biggest disappointment is the location. One of the biggest convenience aspects of the location when it was Dirkos was the drive up window, which is gone now. My truck is pretty much as long as the limited parking so safely backing out of it was a great time.
MA.CRISTINA DE GUZMAN
Plaza Pizza in Johnstown, Ohio is a great place for delicious and satisfying food. The pizza is flavorful with generous toppings and a perfectly cooked crust. The staff are friendly, welcoming, and provide fast service, making the experience even better. The restaurant has a comfortable and casual atmosphere, perfect for family and friends. Overall, Plaza Pizza is a reliable spot for quality pizza and good service. Highly recommended!
… moreSean
We’ve ordered pizza probably around a dozen times since you’ve opened. About 60 percent of the time our order is prepared the way we ordered it, the other 40 percent it’s not cooked extra crispy or for some reason there’s extra cheese on it, which we never order. I think adding an APP surcharge and auto-filling a 20 percent tip (even though you can change it) on a take out pizza is just crazy, especially when you can’t even get the order cooked right. We appreciate you trying to make it right, but that’s the thing, you should be getting it right the first time. Consistency is key.
… moreKhaleb Surio
Delicious pizza with fresh toppings! Each bite was a flavor explosion. Staff is friendly made experience better. Highly recommend!
… moreAnand Prabhakar
Tried today for the first time since they opened. Great crust and well done pizzas. Loved the buffalo chicken and garlic bread and veggie was amazing as well. Slightly disappointed I couldn’t find an option to customize or build my own. Maybe I missed that option or that’s not your thing. Will definitely keep coming back. Also would have been great if you had wings.
… moreDustin Barkhurst
Update. Plaza Pizza made it right. Appreciate a business that cares.
Wrong pizza was made. Not a big deal. I asked the girl to remake both pizzas so they were fresh together. She said she would. Went back to get the pizzas and she lied to me and tried to sell us the old pizza. Then lied again when I asked her about it. Not impressed.
… moreWrong pizza was made. Not a big deal. I asked the girl to remake both pizzas so they were fresh together. She said she would. Went back to get the pizzas and she lied to me and tried to sell us the old pizza. Then lied again when I asked her about it. Not impressed.
LhadyRixxie
recommend by a friend, we tried they’re pizza and i can say their pizza taste so good. I really enjoyed it.You guys should try it too
… moreShiela Regina Delos Reyes
The pizza is so good, very flavorful and they have a very friendly crew. It’s gonna be our new hang out place.
… moreKelcey Drumm
*UPDATED— Because they made it right! Give them
a try! It’s DELICIOUS
My family and I get this pizza at least once a week and love it! But the sole reason I get the pizza I do is for the house made ranch (I know that’s probably weird) but tonight it was not even edible It tastes like nothing? And looked different too. I’m so sad because I bought 5 sides and can’t use any of it. I called the store and he said it may have been a new employee that made it but that it was all they had and couldn’t offer me anything else. PLEASE get the ranch consistent or don’t have it at all so I’m not disappointed. We love the pizza and I don’t want to stop eating it!
… morea try! It’s DELICIOUS
My family and I get this pizza at least once a week and love it! But the sole reason I get the pizza I do is for the house made ranch (I know that’s probably weird) but tonight it was not even edible It tastes like nothing? And looked different too. I’m so sad because I bought 5 sides and can’t use any of it. I called the store and he said it may have been a new employee that made it but that it was all they had and couldn’t offer me anything else. PLEASE get the ranch consistent or don’t have it at all so I’m not disappointed. We love the pizza and I don’t want to stop eating it!
Andrea Stroup
Edit: This review was for Dirko’s Pizza in Johnstown, Ohio in 2024, which has now been sold to Plaza Pizza.
Check out Plaza Pizza for their grand opening Jan 31, 2025. Fingers crossed hoping they’ll consider selling stromboli like Dirkos
——
It’s SO GOOD.
Try the chicken bacon ranch pizza. The pictures don’t even do it justice — it’s seriously delicious. Perfectly crispy bacon and the right amount of ranch.
We’ll be back to try the stromboli another time.
Update: The stromboli is perfect too! We also got to try a new pizza, buffalo cbr — nice kick.
… moreCheck out Plaza Pizza for their grand opening Jan 31, 2025. Fingers crossed hoping they’ll consider selling stromboli like Dirkos
——
It’s SO GOOD.
Try the chicken bacon ranch pizza. The pictures don’t even do it justice — it’s seriously delicious. Perfectly crispy bacon and the right amount of ranch.
We’ll be back to try the stromboli another time.
Update: The stromboli is perfect too! We also got to try a new pizza, buffalo cbr — nice kick.