Ryan Coon
Best Pizza place north of Hyde Park I’ve visited. I’m from down state and the pizza up here is usually trash. Image you do contractor work for the guy who owens the place… You see how well he takes care of his mother, then after finding out he owns a pizza place and find out he seems to love making pizza with the same passion with which he loves his family. Thats Italian style cooking, with a passion and a love for the craft that not many have around here. The only place making pizza close to this is Fredrick in Winthrop. That said, as a Pizza snob… They have the best pizza from east to west north of Poughkeepsie. I drove from Potsdam to get this because even cold or reheated, it’s the best!
… moreTasia Ynocencio
Man! This place is definitely amazing! Super clean and welcoming. The pizza was hott, fresh and super cheesy I loved the sweet tasting sauce. The chicken wings were crispy and fresh and the garlic knots were great too! I’ll definitely be getting more chicken wings before I leave town. My son also enjoyed watching the guy make pizza
Thank you!!!!
… moreJay Lynch
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Review: New York Pizzeria — Gouverneur, NY
I stopped at New York Pizzeria in Gouverneur while heading home on a long 7-hour car ride and just needed something quick and satisfying. I ordered three slices to go, and they were fantastic.
The crust was crisp but soft in the center, the sauce had great flavor without being too sweet, and the cheese had that perfect stretch you hope for in a good New York-style slice. Even reheated a bit later in the trip, the pizza still tasted fresh and delicious — which says a lot.
The staff were friendly and quick, and my order was ready in minutes. Exactly the kind of hometown pizzeria you hope to find on the road — great food, great service, and genuine small-town charm.
Highly recommend stopping here if you’re anywhere near Gouverneur. It’s definitely worth the detour.
… moreSydney Grosso
My family and I stopped here on our way home and we were blow away! My sister’s and I have a severe gluten allergy (celiac) and they had gluten free pizza. I get extremely sick with the smallest amount of cross contamination and they were more than willing to make sure everything was made seperately. They made the pizza in the back away from the main area, on a sheet, and they used new cheese and opened a new can of sauce so I felt more comfortable. I have never had service like that and they were beyond sweet when interacting with me. I know it’s not easy or fun to work with allergies all the time but they were so nice and so accommodating! They also had a separate fryer for the wings so we could eat them too. They checked all the sauces with us individually so we could read the label and feel more comfortable with our decision. The food was amazing! The gf pizza was huge and the garlic wings were the most tender ones I’ve had; there was a pool of butter at the bottom which was great for dipping the wings. Overall an amazing experience and the service was outstanding. Small and family owned can’t be beat. We will be coming back every time we get to drive through the area!
Attached is the gf pizza (we ate a few slices before taking the pic) They also put it in a separate box and used a new cutter so there was no chance of cross contamination.
… moreKatherine Sosebee
I ordered take out. Two large pizzas and 30 hot honey wings. For $80 + dollars I expect my order to be correct. It was not…… I have never had a problem before tonight. The young man taking my order on the phone didn’t seemed distracted and unfamiliar with the menu.
… moreNate Bloxham
I don’t know what to say about this place other than I love the food so much. The sauce and cheese were amazing and the crust is so thin! Their pizza is the best in the north country.
… moreJames Larry
EXTREMELY DELICIOUS FOOD. Came here for Flag Day Parade and decided to give it a try. I highly recommend that if you ever in Gouverneur stop and eat here. You will not be disappointed.
… moreGreg Heelan
Absolutely LOVED this pizzeria. Got the thin crust NY Style and enjoyed the quality food and table service. It’s worth the drive up from Antwerp.
… moreMichael Reddick
By far the best pizza in the area and whenever we travel we always compare other places to our hometown pizzaria. Nothing compares to their quality and their service is phenomenal. Even when there is a mishap they always remedy the situation and still make a great experience! Thank you guys for all that you do!
… moreErin Weldon
I ordered a pizza on a busy Friday night. Back pickup area is convenient and service was quick.
I ordered a garlic pizza and it was the best pizza I’ve had in a long time. Highly recommend!
… more