Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 10 AM–5 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–5 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–5 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–5 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–3 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3700 S Lafountain St, Kokomo, IN 46902
Phone: (765) 480-9727
Website: https://tastefullyindiana.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Tastefully Indiana: Delicious Homemade Bakery
Indulge in our mouthwatering homemade bakery items. From sweet pies & fruit pies to pot pies, cookies, and brownies…we have all your mouht-watering needs!
Tastefully Indiana | Kokomo IN – Facebook
Tastefully Indiana, Kokomo. 3589 likes · 4 talking about this. Homemade pot pies, sweet pies, cakes, cookies, and more!
Tastefully Indiana Bakery – Kokomo, IN
Our cake shop is a haven for those with a sweet tooth, offering a delectable selection of cookies, cupcakes, pies, cheesecakes, and tempting weekly specials.
Reviews
J.K. UNK
Very easy to work with. Thanks for hosting a small tasting event for wedding. Very attentive to details and suggestions. Cake and Cupcake options were agreed upon. Butter Pecan, Lemon, and French Vanilla. Yum Oh! Oh yeah…..they also have great breakfast and lunch options.
… moreJoJo Loves Jesus
The staff was very knowledgeable about the different types of foods and drinks. To be fair, I didn’t have any food. Just coffee. The coffee wasn’t hot and it was weak.
… moreUnlucky
Stopped in with my boyfriend to grab some sweets and ended up walking out with enough to last us two weeks. We tried the espresso cheesecake, strawberry pie, and a various other treats. Everything was fresh and delightful. The atmosphere was incredibly charming and the staff were very friendly! Kelsey helped us with some recommendations and told us about some of her favorites. We only got sweets this time but their savory pies looked delicious too, we’ll definitely be returning to try some of their dinner options. The sloppy Joe and chicken pot pies looked hearty and delicious. Definitely recommend to anyone looking for a sweet treat and to support a local business!
… moreShelly Israel
My hubby is hooked on their cookies. They have pot pie and other foods also.
… moreCynthia Crull
I posted the pictures of the Purdue cake, Cookies and Cream Brownie and the Chocolate cream pie. Sheri made my son’s Purdue Cake very flavorful very moist..The Cookie and Cream brownie and Chocolate Cream pie was awesome. I’ve since tried the Birthday popcorn so good. Highly recommend both Sheri and Tastefully Indiana for all your baking needs.
… moreDee Reese
I was on a school outing and found this gem. After looking at the reviews, I walked in being greeted by all the workers. Very friendly, nice, attentive, but I was asked if I liked to try a candy… Hook line and sinker… Yum A beautiful Creamy Buckeye. The gentleman who started with me helped another set of customers when they came in since I was still deciding. I bought a French onion beef pot pie that he suggested, a chicken pot pie that another customer said was AWESOME, and lastly, Raspberry Cheesecake slice that was SUPERFANTABULOUS I told the workers, you are going to get my into trouble. So we laughed and I left. I got home and heated the French onion beef pot pie for my husband….IT WAS DEMOLISHED! SUPER HIT! My husband loved it! I am eating my chicken pot pie today. You all hit it out of the park! Thank you so much, and I will be back for sure. Dee Reese
… moreYvonne Edwards
I am very happy that Tastefully Indiana has moved into the former Mom’s Pies location on S.Lafountain St. I’ve had several of their menu items and enjoyed all of them. They have a menu that changes monthly with unique foods such as cheeseburger pot pie, white bean chili pot pie with a cornbread crust, and French onion pot pie to name a few. They have a selection of sandwiches, spreads and dips as well as cookies and dessert pies. Everything is homemade and the taste proves it. Check out their Facebook page for current menus. I highly recommend Tastefully Indiana. They also carry hand made items from local artists.
… moreStephanie Massouda
Love the cheesecake. I tried the French onion pot pie and the little Bundt cakes and wasn’t impressed, but the millionaire spaghetti was good. Tried to order the pie flight this week to give them another shot, and despite someone seeing my messages no one ever responded. I’ll take it as a sign to stay away from anything but the cheesecake.
… moreJanet Allbaugh
This was my first visit here. My husband said their apple dumplings were about the best he’s ever had! The chicken pot pie is amazing. German Chocolate cake, my husband loved. Kahala muffin Yummy! The young lady that helped us was so friendly and helpful. Great experience, highly recommended; I will be return customer soon!
… moreEmily White
It’s tradition that every year I order my husband a pineapple upsidedown cake for his birthday and I decided to try them. I was worried it wouldn’t be enough time if I ordered on a Tuesday and needed it by Friday/Sat as some places need to know well in advanced. They got back with me right away and I picked it up on Friday evening. (Just a small cake for 6-8 people)We didn’t eat it till Sunday evening (refridgerated it) and it was delicious! Would definitely order from them again! They had a lot of delicious options in their store too
… more