Chill neighborhood parlor serving a menu of pies, calzones, subs & salads beneath the High Line.
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Highline Pizzeria
Highline Pizzeria – A New York authentic pizza restaurant at 503 W 28th St, New York, NY 10001.
Highline Pizzeria | New York NY – Facebook
Highline Pizza is serving slices all night – we’re open till 5AM tonight! Whether you’re parading, partying, or just craving the city’s best pizza, come …
Highline Pizzeria (@highlinepizzeria) · New York, NY – Instagram
Highline Pizzeria 503 West 28th Street NY · Highline pizza grand new opening! Scott is back! · Photo by Highline Pizzeria on October 19, 2020. Pick up the …
Reviews
m m
Want a steaming hot, flavorful slice of pizza at half past midnight? Get your slice, pie, or anything else HERE! Really friendly service in person or via speedy delivery. I just moved to the neighborhood and was really sad to no longer have my favorite home slice nearby. I now have a new favorite spot for cheesy goodness. The sauce is really flavorful. The variety of toppings is endless. I love an unpretentious pizzeria that doesn’t assault my wallet. You’re not coming here for white glove table service. You are guaranteed a decent NY slice served with a side of good music (in person). And the late hours most nights of the week really can’t be beat.
… morePatrick Zajac
Got the chicken bacon slice and the flavor and crust were on point. Little more bacon leaning than chicken but the crust was so crunchy and perfect. I thought that this slice was going to have a white sauce but I don’t think it had a sauce at all because it was pretty dry.
… moreJordan Gonzales
Highline Pizzeria is back, and it’s better than ever! This gem in Chelsea just reopened, and you can feel the love the new (original owners) put into every pie.
I had the classic pepperoni, and the crust was perfection—thin, crispy, and just the right amount of chew. The sauce is fresh, and the cheese is perfectly melted. The new owners have turned this place around, creating a warm, welcoming spot for locals and visitors alike. If you’re craving authentic NY pizza, Highline Pizzeria on 28th St is a must-visit.
… moreI had the classic pepperoni, and the crust was perfection—thin, crispy, and just the right amount of chew. The sauce is fresh, and the cheese is perfectly melted. The new owners have turned this place around, creating a warm, welcoming spot for locals and visitors alike. If you’re craving authentic NY pizza, Highline Pizzeria on 28th St is a must-visit.
G Lee
Pretty good pizza, especially for this part of town where pizza parlors are scarce. About $5 on average per slice. Cheese is on par with Joe’s, I think. But the chicken parm was pretty damn good. Love the crispy crust from the ‘re-bake’. And they have some seats out front (none inside).
… moreAllen Evans
10/5/25
At 12 noon on a Sunday, the service was quick and efficient.
This is a must-stop highlight on every trip to “the City”.
… moreAt 12 noon on a Sunday, the service was quick and efficient.
This is a must-stop highlight on every trip to “the City”.
Ziad Awartani
This is a small shop for carryout or eat outside. The pizza is amazing. $6 a slice. 10/10 recommend. They are open as of 7/5/2025
… moreDaniel Tran
Visit: July 2024
The first NY slice I’ve had. It was pretty good! The base and crust were nice and crispy. Got the chicken parm slice. Would have liked a bit more chicken though
… moreThe first NY slice I’ve had. It was pretty good! The base and crust were nice and crispy. Got the chicken parm slice. Would have liked a bit more chicken though
Paula Zackeru
The best Grandma pizza EVER! The pizza was so tasty and the staff warm and friendly. We will be back!
… moreElise Zvirzdin
This place is the best! We just happened to be walking by and stopped in for lunch, and are so glad we did! I will definitely be going back for their mini spinach pizzas. They do not scrimp on spinach, which is exactly what I like! It was excellent with a little balsamic vinaigrette drizzled on top.
… moreKaty McClintic
Looking for an authentic but delicious NYC pizza experience? Head to Highline Pizzeria. For its namesake, you can even walk on the beautiful Highline Trail to or from the pizza place. It is located right by a main entrance to the trail.
This pizzeria is a classic, small pizzeria with very little seating space but a cozy and homelike vibe. We actually got to eat our pizza slices right out on the sidewalk on bar stools set up outside. They have a large assortment of pizzas and you can get them by the slice or as whole pizzas. The pies themselves are quite delicious and a filling meal for a dinner or a lunch. Great price as well! I will definitely be going back on my visits to NYC.
Try the Grandma Pizza ! (P.S. Its what real New Yorkers call a Margherita pizza 😉 )
… moreThis pizzeria is a classic, small pizzeria with very little seating space but a cozy and homelike vibe. We actually got to eat our pizza slices right out on the sidewalk on bar stools set up outside. They have a large assortment of pizzas and you can get them by the slice or as whole pizzas. The pies themselves are quite delicious and a filling meal for a dinner or a lunch. Great price as well! I will definitely be going back on my visits to NYC.
Try the Grandma Pizza ! (P.S. Its what real New Yorkers call a Margherita pizza 😉 )