Jacob Duffy
The pizza here is fantastic, with a perfectly baked crust and just the right balance of sauce and cheese. I usually stick to simple flavors, but they have a wide variety to choose from, and every option I’ve tried has been delicious.
… moreKen Callan
Grandma slices are good. Pricey!!!
4.30 for 1 slice. Had them cut it in 2 so I could drive and eat. Doesn’t look appealing reheated.
No business at 630pm. This place was always busy a few years back. What has happened to lose so many customers. Food cost and wages are two things but successful businesses find a way to market themselves to become the place to go in a small town.
… moreTammy McDONOUGH
Delicious pizza and friendly staff. Delivers to parts of Cinnaminson.
… moreKatie Rhodes
Ordered trays of chicken parm, baked ziti and garlic knots for a party. Everything was fantastic and all of the guests absolutely loved it! Someone said they were the best garlic knots they had ever eaten (probably because they were entirely covered in garlic with some left over). Highly recommend!
… moreZadok
I’ve never had a bad experience at this Montegrillo location. Maple Shade Montegrillo is definitely superior. The owner is so nice and personable and I’ve never had a bad experience with the food. I love the sports salad, grandma’s pizza, white pizza, gormet buffalo chicken pizza, hot wings, and lasagna the most. You should definitely give Maple Shade Montegrillo a try.
… moreMatthew La Raque
First time here. Went bc a fb friend posted some strong positive statements along side some gorgeous pics of pizza from this place. I’ve never heard of the place so I was intrigued….and I wasnt disappointed. Great food for a good price; And the pizza slices had a nice crispy undercarriage just as I hoped and liked! That chicken Alfredo slice was insane! And the hoagie… So refreshing 🙂 I’ll think of this place again when it come time to eat like this.
… moreTracy McWilliams
Can’t go wrong with anything you get. The food is so delicious and you get a lot for the money.
… moreG Mail
On 101025, I ordered takeout, and when I went to pick it up, the cashier didn’t wash his hands before picking up a roll that was placed uncovered on top of the oven. He grabbed my dinner roll with his bare hands when he could’ve used tongs or worn gloves instead. I was immediately disgusted because his hands could’ve touched all kinds of things. It appears to me that this is normalized to them.
… moreKacie Levandoski
Me and my family love coming here. The pizza is so delicious and the staff is super friendly. The town wouldn’t be the same without Montegrillo. Best pizza around!
… moreWilliam Baker
Pizza – both the pan and Sicilian pizzas are really good and on point. Unfortunately, the regular crust pizzas are sometimes inconsistent as far as crusts go – one week burnt and too crisp, the next week fine. The “grandma pie” is my favorite!
Dinners – never had a bad meal and they give you a good size portion for your money.
Atmosphere – it’s a pizza parlor…nothing glamorous.
… more