Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Monday | 3–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 3–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 3–8 PM |
| Thursday | 3–8 PM |
| Friday | 3–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3800 N Calumet Ave, Valparaiso, IN 46383
Phone: (219) 312-7882
Website: http://www.lennysvalpo.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Lenny’s Coal-Fired Pizza | Valparaiso, Indiana
Lenny’s coal fired pizza, brought to you by Costas Restaurant Group, is Valparaiso’s newest and most unique pizza restaurant.
Lenny’s Coal-Fired Pizza – Indiana Dunes
Lenny’s Coal-Fired Pizza · 3800 Calumet Ave. Valparaiso, IN 46383 · [email protected] · 219-312-7882.
Lenny’s Coal Fired Pizza | Valparaiso IN – Facebook
Some pizzas just work — and The Dublin Deli is one of them. Corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss, mozzarella, and our house Thousand Island all coal-fired …
Reviews
Shelly Funk
First, the food was really good! We got the monthly special, mashed potato pizza, and enjoyed it! It had really thin and crispy crust with tasty mashed potatoes, crispy bacon, and a really good sour cream sauce drizzle.
The service kinda sucked though. We are visiting from out of state and after driving 30 minutes just to get this pizza, we arrived 20 minutes before closing. Realizing that wasn’t great, we decided to just walk in and order to go, so we would keep them open late. After walking in and to the hostess stand, where there was a sign that said Wait to be Seated, the hostess literally just stared at us. She didn’t say a single word. It was so awkward. Then we asked if we could place a To Go order and weren’t directed to go online and/or offered a menu. Thankfully we knew what we wanted and she took out order.
The pizza was ready quickly (which was appreciated) and before their posted closing time. The hostess just handed us the pizza box and we weren’t thanked for our order or wished a good night or anything hinting at good customer service.
… moreThe service kinda sucked though. We are visiting from out of state and after driving 30 minutes just to get this pizza, we arrived 20 minutes before closing. Realizing that wasn’t great, we decided to just walk in and order to go, so we would keep them open late. After walking in and to the hostess stand, where there was a sign that said Wait to be Seated, the hostess literally just stared at us. She didn’t say a single word. It was so awkward. Then we asked if we could place a To Go order and weren’t directed to go online and/or offered a menu. Thankfully we knew what we wanted and she took out order.
The pizza was ready quickly (which was appreciated) and before their posted closing time. The hostess just handed us the pizza box and we weren’t thanked for our order or wished a good night or anything hinting at good customer service.
M K
Lenny’s Pizza is hands down one of the best spots around. The pizza is fresh, perfectly cooked, and loaded with flavor. The crust has that ideal balance — crispy on the outside, soft on the inside — and you can tell they use quality ingredients.
The staff is always friendly, the service is quick, and the place has that classic neighborhood pizza vibe that just feels right. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or ordering for the whole family, they never disappoint.
If you’re looking for real, old-school style pizza done right, Lenny’s is the place. Highly recommend!
… moreThe staff is always friendly, the service is quick, and the place has that classic neighborhood pizza vibe that just feels right. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or ordering for the whole family, they never disappoint.
If you’re looking for real, old-school style pizza done right, Lenny’s is the place. Highly recommend!
David Chalmers
Wings were ok. Pizza and meatballs were really good! Definitely will return!
… more1GnarlyNarwhal
This is our families favorite pizza in valpo! The wings are also excellent! We always have good service, friendly staff and a welcoming vintage-ish atmosphere. Would definitely recommend if you enjoy coal fired pizza!
… moreRichard Amburgey
Fantastic Coal-Fired Pizza at Lenny’s Pizza
First impression of Lenny’s Pizza? Cozy and inviting. The restaurant has both a bar area and a dining space, offering a great atmosphere for any type of visit. What really stands out is their coal-fired pies.
I went with the Lenny’s Pie, and it was fantastic. The sweet and spicy combination hit all the right notes, and the crust? Perfectly cooked with a great undercarriage—just enough char for that signature coal-fired taste. The Supreme pie was just as impressive—cheesy goodness with a flawless crust that held up without a flop, and that slight char added an extra layer of flavor that made it all come together perfectly.
I paired my pizza with a Bell’s Brown Ale, which was great. However, it could’ve been colder coming out of the tap—though, in fairness, it was 2° outside, so I probably should’ve just stuck my beer outside to cool it down for that frosty, refreshing taste.
Lenny’s offers about 20 beers on draft, plus a selection of domestic beers in cans and bottles, red and white wine, and cocktails. The variety is solid, so there’s something for everyone.
Service was great, and the restaurant maintained a clean environment, including spotless restrooms. Oh, and I have to mention the napkin game—A+.
Overall, Lenny’s is a great spot if you’re in the mood for Newark-style, coal-fired pizza with excellent beer and a welcoming atmosphere. Definitely worth a visit if you’re in the Valpo area!
… moreFirst impression of Lenny’s Pizza? Cozy and inviting. The restaurant has both a bar area and a dining space, offering a great atmosphere for any type of visit. What really stands out is their coal-fired pies.
I went with the Lenny’s Pie, and it was fantastic. The sweet and spicy combination hit all the right notes, and the crust? Perfectly cooked with a great undercarriage—just enough char for that signature coal-fired taste. The Supreme pie was just as impressive—cheesy goodness with a flawless crust that held up without a flop, and that slight char added an extra layer of flavor that made it all come together perfectly.
I paired my pizza with a Bell’s Brown Ale, which was great. However, it could’ve been colder coming out of the tap—though, in fairness, it was 2° outside, so I probably should’ve just stuck my beer outside to cool it down for that frosty, refreshing taste.
Lenny’s offers about 20 beers on draft, plus a selection of domestic beers in cans and bottles, red and white wine, and cocktails. The variety is solid, so there’s something for everyone.
Service was great, and the restaurant maintained a clean environment, including spotless restrooms. Oh, and I have to mention the napkin game—A+.
Overall, Lenny’s is a great spot if you’re in the mood for Newark-style, coal-fired pizza with excellent beer and a welcoming atmosphere. Definitely worth a visit if you’re in the Valpo area!
Kevin Flynn
Quick review – Best pizza by far in the area and some of the best I’ve had. Italian Beef was great. The lemon rice soup was very good. Kid friendly great family atmosphere.
Full review – I’ve seen this a few times driving by and tonight we decided to try it due to our favorite restaurant being packed. When I arrived it was very slow its Saturday night so that was concerning. When we walked in it smelled like cleaner and our table was sticky so I was starting to get worried. We ordered and the staff was great. The food was very quick as well.
The pizza by far is some of the best pizza I’ve had. The sauce has alot of flavor, nice and crispy but not burnt.
The Italian beef was packed with flavor and juicy.
The lemon rice soup was surprisingly very good. It shocked my wife and I. The kids loved the food and we left very happy.
Overall its very underrated I feel and we definitely will be back. New favorite pizza spot in the area.
… moreFull review – I’ve seen this a few times driving by and tonight we decided to try it due to our favorite restaurant being packed. When I arrived it was very slow its Saturday night so that was concerning. When we walked in it smelled like cleaner and our table was sticky so I was starting to get worried. We ordered and the staff was great. The food was very quick as well.
The pizza by far is some of the best pizza I’ve had. The sauce has alot of flavor, nice and crispy but not burnt.
The Italian beef was packed with flavor and juicy.
The lemon rice soup was surprisingly very good. It shocked my wife and I. The kids loved the food and we left very happy.
Overall its very underrated I feel and we definitely will be back. New favorite pizza spot in the area.
Roy
It’s all about the crust…..Lenny’s neopolitan crust is OK, a slight chew and slight crispiness……Maybe if the edges were built up you would get a better chew and pillowy crispy crust…..Check out Piccolo Buco’s photos for that perfect crispy, chewy crust……The main problem was that the undercarriage was burnt and just left a bad burnt aftertaste…..The sauce was excellent, a light fresh sauce that was not oversauced to make the pizza soggy, just sauced to perfection…….The sausage was very good just none to be found…..Topped off with a great mozz cheese made this a very good neopolitan pie
… moreKarl Merkner
We happened to be in town and wanted some pizza. This was the closest place and the food and service was good! Pizza is solid, and they also had really good fried pickled spears.
… moreMark Gore
We are at Lenny’s once a week and it’s always so good. The staff is kind and attentive (shout out to Jessica and Malia) and the food is great. The Lenny’s pie is our favorite!
… moreJosh Rock
Went to the newest pizza place in town this evening, we heard it was too die for because it is coal fired pizza. We got the meatballs, and garlic bread for an appetizer, a pepperoni pizza, and a veggie pizza. The pizzas were just meh, not bad but average at best. The crust tasted good but no different than when I cook a pizza on my grill. The meatballs had eggshells in them, so that was an unpleasant surprise texture for sure. We sent the meatballs back and were taken off the bill of course, but they acted like they were doing me a favor by taking it off the bill. Maybe we will try again after the newness wears off.
… more