Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 36 James St, Middletown, NY 10940
Phone: (845) 342-1222
Website: https://www.caputospizzany.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Caputo’s Pizza – Online Ordering
Thank you for ordering from Caputo’s Pizza! Please do not ask for … Location & Hours. Caputo’s Pizza 36 James Street, Suite 2. Middletown, New York 10940
Caputo’s Pizza | Middletown NY – Facebook
Caputo’s Pizza, Middletown. 1834 likes · 28 talking about this · 363 were here. Italian Restaurant.
Caputo’s Pizza (@caputospizza) · Middletown, NY – Instagram
Serving you and your family for 20 years! Call now for Delivery or Pickup! Online ordering in the bio ⬇️ 845-342-1222 845-342-5002 845-381-1652 …
Reviews
Anna Marie LeBeau
Friendly staff. Pizza is delicious. I think the best in town! They will be my new pizza guys
… moreSharon Reynolds
I like everything about this place. Very cordial service, good prices but most of all delicious food. I went to another place I won’t name and ordered a meatball parm hero. So disgusting I couldn’t eat it, but im never disappointed at Caputos. Middletown is lucky.
… moreDorothy Bartomeo
First time ordering here, did take out. We got a plain pie, garbage pie, and chicken fingers with fries. The plain pie reminded me of Queens, so that’s a huge win. The garbage pie was tasty, but needed a little more time. I recommend ordering it “well done”. The chicken fingers and fries are kid approved 100% as they were gone before I could get a picture. Overall, probably the best pizza in 10940 and 10941 that I have tried so far.
… moreYanira Quinones
Honestly by far the greatest pizza place I’ve gone to in Middletown! I always order from here whether it’s pasta, ice cream, Stromboli, wings everything is delicious. Mind you this is a size small Stromboli. I had leftovers for lunch the next day. And the wings had surprisingly a lot meat on them. I’m so happy this place is right around the corner from my house. 10/10 would recommend coming to eat here.
… moreDonna Niell
I’ve been eating at Caputo’s for years , since they were located up North St in Middletown. They relocated to a beautiful new location Downtown (and they brought the fish tank with them) The food is still great especially the veal parm hero. The pizza is just right not too doughy and not too thin. The reason for this review is not only to mention the food but what a great staff that works there. My best friend had a medical emergency at ORMC so they called another pizza place to deliver for the family that was stuck at the hospital waiting. After waiting for 2 1/2 hrs and no delivery my friend called me in a panic. I called Caputo’s and they had two pies ready in 10 minutes. when I showed to pick them up(they do deliver but that was not an optional this time) I explained the situation and Brittany allowed me to use one of the pizza holder warmers to deliver them to the hospital. they went out of their way service wise. If you have to travel downtown Middletown, To the DMV, Library, City Hall, Court or the Police station stop here and have a slice or great sandwich or dinner. Highly recommended.
… moreMichael Ryan
I honestly ordered here by mistake but it turned out to be a the best food mistake I’ve ever made. Their ingredients are top notch and super fresh, pizza wasn’t greasy and tasted amazing. When I got there they were very welcoming and the place is super clean. I will definitely be ordering here from now on.
… moreJenna dm
I have refused since 2013ish when I 1st started eating here, to ever like any other pizza place at all. Mark is amazing… They catered my baby shower 1 1/2 yrs ago – everything was so good, put together perfect, & done right on time seamlessly. He made the process so easy for me (I planned my entire shower by myself & this was so helpful). I also recently got 8 personal pies worth of dough to fly to FL with & my FL friends got to taste REAL NY pizza for the 1st time. They were beyond impressed. Mark called me & step by step walked my through how to travel with them & make them. He was worried about the flight, but they made it down there & were absolutely DELISH!!!! The garlic butter wings are my fav & I get them frequently – crispy, juicy, & flavorful. The desserts are always fresh, as are the other ingredients used. This time I got Nonnas meatballs for the 1st time (omg delish) & their fried ravioli – which I am so picky about anytime I order them anywhere, but here they were perfectly CRISPY, not too moist, & the sauce was heavenly. 1000 out of 10 recommend to EVERYONE & tell them this is LEGIT the best in all of the upstate tristate area. I fight people who say otherwise because what are you eating if it isn’t CAPUTOS!! I’ve been a ride or die since their first location. Here until the end because they’ve NEVER switched up! *original review left on TikTok, so good google needs it too*
… moreGood Egg Of Wisdom
Great spot to take the family to. We had a blast of great food, not only pizza but multiple varieties of things to choose from, even desert and Icecream.
… moreLidia Tavella
Best pizza in the area! The older man who makes the pizza, I don’t know who he is, but he needs to be protected at all costs! Incredible!
… moreJherry DI DANCA
Before I finish this scrumptious pizza I had to write this review. WOW now that’s PIZZA. The rich cheese and the SAUCE IS PERFECT. The garlic knots I can eat a dozen of. I found my new favorite pizzeria in Middletown. Oh and the customer service when I walked in till the time I sat down.
… more