Address and Contact Information
Address: 1299 McCarter Hwy, Newark, NJ 07104
Phone: (973) 482-8000
Website: https://simplybagelsnw.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Simply Bagels
At Simply Bagels, we specialize in providing high-quality catering services … 1299 McCarter Highway Newark, NJ 07104. Copyright © 2026 Simply Bagels.
Simply Bagels (@simplybagelsnw) • Instagram photos and videos
261 Followers, 213 Following, 130 Posts – Simply Bagels (@simplybagelsnw) on Instagram: ” |#1 Bagel in Newark, NJ |Hand-Rolled Artisan | 1299 McCarter …
Order Simply Bagels – Newark, NJ Menu Delivery [Menu & Prices]
Get delivery or takeout from Simply Bagels at 1299 Mccarter Hwy in Newark. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first order!
Reviews
Jenny Ramos
Great little bagel shop in town. It was crowded but the line moved quickly. I had a bagel with walnut cream cheese. It was so good. My husband said his breakfast sandwich was good as well. We will be back.
… moresharonlee del valle
As a native new yorker used to the convenience of a good bagel right at your own very corner finding a good bagel in jersey was difficult. Texture would be off, too stiff or bland .
Until I stopped here. They have such a variety of bagels. They are always fresh. The cream cheeses have flavor. I’ve tried a few items on their menu and they never fail. I’ve bought bags of bagels to various work spaces in new york and everyone will rave and even question if they were really jersey bagelYou can even dine in & sit and eat in peace. Multiple seating, parking and the staff are amazing. Thank you simply bagels for providing a tasty, clean quiet space for this new yorker to feel at home with a yummy bagel and coffee. Ohh did I mention their coffee is the right amount of wake-up. Much success always.
… moreUntil I stopped here. They have such a variety of bagels. They are always fresh. The cream cheeses have flavor. I’ve tried a few items on their menu and they never fail. I’ve bought bags of bagels to various work spaces in new york and everyone will rave and even question if they were really jersey bagelYou can even dine in & sit and eat in peace. Multiple seating, parking and the staff are amazing. Thank you simply bagels for providing a tasty, clean quiet space for this new yorker to feel at home with a yummy bagel and coffee. Ohh did I mention their coffee is the right amount of wake-up. Much success always.
Empower The World
Today was my first time ordering from simply bagels and I must say I am extremely pleased the breakfast sandwich, bacon, egg, and cheese was top-tier and the Tre Leche cake was out of the park. Fantastic. I give it a resounding 10!
… moreKaren Villafane
We tried to resolve this privately, but unfortunately, the owner Salvador and Sandra Garcia showed no accountability!!
We placed a large, important order for a community event: 50 bagels with individual spreads, coffee, and muffins. Not only did it arrive 40 minutes late, but it was missing all the spreads, which then took an additional 20-30 minutes to arrive. The delay completely disrupted the timing of our event, caused unnecessary stress for our team and guests, and made us look disorganized, all because they couldn’t deliver what was promised.
What made this worse was how it was handled. No apology, no clear communication, just defensiveness. We were even told we had called “too many times” when we were just trying to ensure things went smoothly. On top of it all, the milk provided with the order was expired. See photo attached!!
We reached out directly to give them a chance to make it right, requesting a refund or a replacement order. They refused to take responsibility and offered no meaningful resolution.
Bottom line: If you’re planning an event or ordering for a group, do not trust this place. They will not deliver on their promises, and if something goes wrong, they will not own up to it. Save yourself the stress!!! Stay away!!!!
… moreWe placed a large, important order for a community event: 50 bagels with individual spreads, coffee, and muffins. Not only did it arrive 40 minutes late, but it was missing all the spreads, which then took an additional 20-30 minutes to arrive. The delay completely disrupted the timing of our event, caused unnecessary stress for our team and guests, and made us look disorganized, all because they couldn’t deliver what was promised.
What made this worse was how it was handled. No apology, no clear communication, just defensiveness. We were even told we had called “too many times” when we were just trying to ensure things went smoothly. On top of it all, the milk provided with the order was expired. See photo attached!!
We reached out directly to give them a chance to make it right, requesting a refund or a replacement order. They refused to take responsibility and offered no meaningful resolution.
Bottom line: If you’re planning an event or ordering for a group, do not trust this place. They will not deliver on their promises, and if something goes wrong, they will not own up to it. Save yourself the stress!!! Stay away!!!!
D.
Today I try to buy a everything with cream cheese bagel. The price $3.75. I gave my debit card. He insisted I had to spend $10 to use debit card. I explained to him just charged me. The 3% credit card fee, like the rest of the world. He said, no, it has to be $10 to use a debit card. I refuse to be strong armed into paying for $7 worth of more food. I don’t need just to use a bank card.
Then my colleague bought a bacon egg and cheese on a bagel they charged him for double egg, double meat, they have refused to bring down their prices to accommodate for the shortage of eggs, He only received a regular egg and meat sandwich, but they insist on double charging him for double to make up for the price inflation.and paying their overhead expenses.
HORRIBLE work plan. He may be taking advantage of the unprivileged in that neighborhood who don’t know their rights, I was not taken advantage of and did not pay. Do not give this business anymore of your hard-earned dollars for a simple bagel. And cream cheese or for any other food?
… moreThen my colleague bought a bacon egg and cheese on a bagel they charged him for double egg, double meat, they have refused to bring down their prices to accommodate for the shortage of eggs, He only received a regular egg and meat sandwich, but they insist on double charging him for double to make up for the price inflation.and paying their overhead expenses.
HORRIBLE work plan. He may be taking advantage of the unprivileged in that neighborhood who don’t know their rights, I was not taken advantage of and did not pay. Do not give this business anymore of your hard-earned dollars for a simple bagel. And cream cheese or for any other food?
Shar Donat
The best bagel ever. After looking for so long for a place that has fresh bake and big bagel, I found it accidentally on door dash. Now I am hook. As a bread lover this like finding a mine
… moreSritty B
I ordered a scallion creem cheese on a bagel toasted. They gave me regular cream cheese and upcharged for the scallion. The bagel was not good, so thin. Only tasted the crust.
… moreTamara Jones
I have been coming here for years.Always have a great customer service experience. great breakfast. The cook is consistent.
… moreHenry Pinto
I HIGHLY RECOMMEND!! Great Fresh Hot Bagels and tasty cream cheese. We ordered from this place for a school event and Simply Bagels offered great customer service and provided us with fresh hot bagels. We requested it to be delivered at 7:00 AM and they met our request. That shows that they are a very responsible business. Their Bagels are very great and soft. While you’re at their place they offer a variety of bagels and foods. I recommend to try all their burgers, wraps and egg, cheese and sausage in a bagel. Very great place! Try their Colombian coffee it’s really fantastic and fresh.
They also offer a lot of parking!
… moreThey also offer a lot of parking!
Michael Hoffman
Very very good. One of the best bacon egg and cheese bagels I have had in recent memory. Very low key local spot. Nothing fancy but great food. Check it out
… more