Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 17 North Ave, Pleasant Valley, NY 12569
Phone: (845) 635-9500
Website: http://www.madisonspizzacafe.com/!contact-madisons-pizza-cafe/cyha
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Menus | Madison’s Pizza Cafe in Pleasant Valley, NY
Everyday Special. Large Cheese Pie, 2 Orders of Boneless Wings, and a 2 Liter of Soda $37.95. Cocktails; Catering Menu; Special Events Menu; Pizza …
Madison’s Pizza Cafe
MOBILE WOOD FIRED PIZZA TRUCK NOW AVAILABLE FOR PARTIES AND EVENTS! INQUIRE TODAY! ×. Skip to main content. 17 North Avenue, Pleasant Valley, NY 12569 (845) …
Catering Menu | Madison’s Pizza Cafe in Pleasant Valley, NY
Appetizers … Half serves 10, full serves 20 … Chicken Wings … Half … Full … Sampler … Half … Full … Fried Calamari … Half … Full … Cheese Platter … Half … Full.
Reviews
ArachnoBoss
Best place in town to go! I both order delivery, & dine in. It is beautifully set up and has a lovely atmosphere. It also has a bar and can cater to most size parties. If you go in with twelve people, you’ll be fine. Or call a head and set up for 30. All of their food is but im quite partial to their chicken, cheddar, bacon, ranch Pizza and the chicken cheddar bacon ranch wrap. Those are my absolute favorites and my normal go to’s. But they also make a amazing Sicilian, and their pasta is fantastic. I usually get chicken fetuccini, Alfredo or chicken franchise. Both are amazing! I if you get a large Sicilian with extra cheese and extra bacon, it will blow your taste buds away. Garlic knots are on point, so is their fried calamari and fried clam strips, and that’s a lot coming from me because I stopped eating seafood years ago! So overall, I highly recommend this place. And if you’ve never been to madison’s I highly recommend that you, at least place an order one time check out their menu, it’s worth it. And they are very fair priced!
… moreHeidi Wohlfahrt
I was craving their salad pizza all day. Madison’s has the BEST salad pizza! Veggies are always fresh and crisp.
It was exactly as I wanted. I love the balsamic dressing too
… moreIt was exactly as I wanted. I love the balsamic dressing too
Chance Horetz
5 stars all around. Madison’s is a fantastic dining establishment. I eat there often. Normally we have the food delivered, but from time to time we go to the actual location and it is nice. It’s quiet and it has a bar. It is a beautifully designed place with fantastic women that run the counter. There’s not much more you could ask for in a restaurant! Eat their if you haven’t! Their chicken, cheddar, bacon, ranch pizza & wraps are amazing! And there’s sicilians are amazing. I always get a large with extra cheese and bacon and it is an amazing pizza!
… moreAnne Wetter
We always order delivery. The food is amazing. The service is great. And they have a great gluten free menu. The employees on the phone are always professional and friendly. Highly recommend this place.
… moreAngela
Always good vibes the second I walk in. The food is consistently top-notch, super fresh and packed with flavor. We order catering from here all the time for work events and family parties because it’s always a hit. Can’t recommend enough!
… moreJim laffin iii
Fantastic!!! Best Chicken Parm personal pie I’ve had around by a large margin. Staff is always on point and always a great variety of dinner specials weekly!
… moreKristy Ciavardini
Ordered a large cheese pie. I was there to pick it up in 15-20 minutes. It was ready when I got there. I went home and found a very over cooked pizza. It was only luke warm and the crust was not crisp. I really felt like they had a pie left over from the afternoon and they reheated it. I waa really looking forward to this pizza and it really sucked.
… moreJames Leatherman
I haven’t had a slice yet that wasn’t amazing. I lived in the Bronx for years, and this is the closest I have had to real New York pizza this far out of the city. We have had the margherita, sausage, meatball and onion, buffalo chicken, and stuffed slices and each one of them were outstanding. Also tried the lobster bisque and it too was perfect.
… moreNiki Ashmawy
We always stop here if we’re passing through town. The dough is soft and pillowy and has a nice crust. Nicely seasoned. We usually get the Upside Down pizza which is the best pizza I’ve ever tasted(showed in pic) and a couple slices out of the case. Slices are huge.
… moreExistential Crisis Dog
Love this place for pizza, sandwiches, and everything else. It’s hard to find a good pizza place that does it all, but they do it here. They had me at jalapeno poppers with the choice of cream cheese or cheddar
… more