Kevin Alzate
Was recommended this spot by a local and it did not disappoint. The food was great and I loved seeing all the Batman decor. Ended up talking to one of the brothers who owns the restaurant and I loved to hear his passion/enthusiasm regarding Batman. Food was very reasonably priced as well.
Only “con” was this one mother who let her kids run around and they were touching every toy on the walls and ruining the atmosphere. The gremlins were nearly ripping the toys off the wall.
… moreAndrew Izzo
We have been here many times and it’s always a good experience. I’ve gotten takeout from here also. Plenty of parking around the diner. The staff were all friendly and helpful. Very at tentative to us when our drinks were running low. The whole restaurant is Batman themed. From the second you walk through the front door, both sides have large Batman statues and memorabilia. Once inside, it is decorated around the entire restaurant with toys, posters, etc. Definitely a kid friendly environment. Breakfast is served all day.
The food here is great. Any burger selection comes with two onion rings. The fries are some of the best I’ve ever had anywhere. We started with a loaded waffle fries and mozzarella sticks. Both great starters. The cheese on the waffle fries was spread throughout just not on the top. Almost every fry had a topping. I got the Philly Cheesesteak Burger. It was cooked exactly how I wanted. When you look at the picture, it seems like possibly too much. Once you put on the top bun, it creates a cohesive unit of deliciousness. As good as it was, I want to try a different burger next time. I heard good things about some of them. I highly suggest stopping in here if you are in New Milford.
… moreCaitlyn Henderson
Decided to check out Three Brothers on a Sunday evening. It was a great spot to bring two young kids- they were entertained by all of the decor as well as Toy Story being on the TV. Kids menu was great, burgers for dinner were good. Their menu is essentially diner food. Was a little disappointed in the cleanliness- floor and booths looked like they could be better cleaned. Overall had a good experience.
… moreDeanna Lee
Seated pretty fast. Got hot coffee right away. Atmosphere is very cool ( Batman lovers ) Ordered food and waited…. Took almost 30 minutes to get breakfast for two. Only to get cold eggs ,Taste was good , if you don’t mind cold eggs!
… moreAzra Gradincic
We’re visiting and chose this diner because it has good reviews but now I’m super confused. How did this place get 4.4 stars?! We were so hungry and hoping for a good meal but everything was so bland and tasteless. And even though we left our plates nearly full, our stomachs feel so heavy… I don’t know what it is. I had few bites but it feels like I ate bricks. How is it possible for food to be bland and heavy all at the same time?
Also, I think the staff might have overcorrected with the service in response to criticism that they were ignoring their guests because this time they kept bugging us every few minutes. We felt rushed because they kept asking if we’re ready every two minutes.
… moreDonna S (DonnaS)
A fabulous establishment. The food is fresh and perfectly prepared. The staff is extremely attentive. The atmosphere is fun with its Batman decor. I will definitely go back.
… moreJerrod Ewing
I had breakfast with my uncle and Dad at Three Brothers. The Saturday brunch menu contained some great options. I had the salmon omelette, which was good. The salmon is mixed into the omelette, which means that it is well done. Not my preferred preparation, but the omelette was good and something I’d order again. My dad and uncle had the shrimp and grits. The preparation was a little different than traditional versions from the south. They enjoyed the dish anyway (the shrimp was good and grits were a good breakfast version). I tried a cannoli on a whim and enjoyed the treat. Service was fast and attentive.
… moreDarren Blankenship
We both ordered a chicken sandwich. It was very tasty and generous, and the bun was toasted. The coleslaw and French fries were also very good. Cute batman decor. Friendly staff. Reasonable.
… moreNeil Mandel
Stopped in for breakfast while passing through the area on a bicycle tour. Although it was a Sunday morning and they were pretty busy, I was seated right away and my order taken promptly and served soon afterwards. I ordered the French Toast and 2 eggs and coffee and I have no complaints. The server was friendly, and stopped by several times to see if I needed anything. The Batman theme was also interesting. Would recommend this eatery.
… moreC J C
What makes it standout is the decor. If you have a Batman fan in your party this place is a MUST! Batman EVERYWHERE. Fun for the average person, probably a near religious experience for major fans.
Other factors: Food was good (great fries and waffles), staff were friendly and laid back, clean environment, ambiance was fun (if not to my personal taste ), outdoor seating, plenty of parking…basically it checks all the boxes.
Prices were average diner / family restaurant prices, though maybe on the higher end of average. Portions were reasonable and more than enough for us. We kept eating the fries after we were full though because they were so good!
… more