Kristen Schumacher
Honestly, love Johnny pepperonis and the food is fantastic however the prices are absolutely outrageous for the quantity of food that you receive. You are better off going down the street to Napolis for 1/2 the price. Pic attached- one chicken cutlet for $35.. delicious but that’s actually insane. I have been coming here for awhile and this was the smallest amount of food I’ve ever recieved.
… moreKristen Sullivan
Johnny pepperonis is the BEST!!! We have been many times for dinner and takeout and their pizza is amazing! I decided to do an Italian theme for my bridesmaid proposal and knew I had to host it at Johnny Pepps and I’m SO glad I did. The service, food, and vibes were amazing and we had the best night! The staff was so friendly and accommodating and went above and beyond to make the night special for us!! I highly recommend hosting your next dinner party at Johnny Pepperonis. Thank you so so much for an incredible evening!!
… moreSeerat Chopra
We got the hot honey pepperoni pizza & the chocolate lava cake – both were good!
… moreQ W
FANTASTIC restaurant!!! Outdoor seating + pet friendly. We ordered the shrimp scampi (which doesn’t not come with pasta) and a wonderful handmade custom pie. Everything was fresh, high quality and deliciously made.
Didn’t know about BYOB, but that’s good to know for the next time!!
… moreGio Lauretta
Nice esthetic, amazing young waitress. But the chicken parm / margarita pie were both underwhelming simple sauce , simple boxed noodles served temp. For 70$ dinner experience was not expected.
… moreM Hooks
This was a very pleasant experience. I wish I would have gotten a photo of the pizza we ordered too but we devoured it. There is a highly rated pizza place i always go to when I’m in Manhattan and I have to say Johnny Pepperoni is my never favorite pizza place in the area.
… moreDavid S
Quaint little Italian eatery with a wonderful collection of old time photos throughout. We ordered a plain cheese pizza and Caesar salad and the pizza was very good with excellent cheese and a great crunchy crust. The sauce was plain, though, and needed a little work. The Caesar salad was very good, clean-tasting with a tasty Caesar dressing. Great service and about $40 for a pizza , salad, and 3 drinks. No free refills for a tiny 8 oz soda, but I asked and the waiter was kind enough to give us a refill free of charge.
… moreLarry Pollack
We like the pizza. These guys used to be reliable but something has gone wrong. Each of the last three delivery orders were messed up. First delivery took verrry long time. Had to call multiple times. Second screw-up: sent completely wrong pizza (square with no toppings vs round with two). Third screw-up: out of mushrooms (called to tell me) and pizza arrived without other topping. First two screw-ups they gave me a credit. Last one, they’re refusing. I think we have to move on to another pizzeria.
… moreKimberly Favara
I hosted my sister’s bridal shower at Johnny Peps this weekend. It was the perfect place to have all of our family and friends come together to celebrate. We chose the Appertivo package which came with a plentiful amount of food that was all so fresh and delicious! Everyone commented that they enjoyed the food. We did the full restaurant buy out which was great because we then decorated the tables and bar area with our theme. I would definitely host another party here!
… moreAnita Karr
Split the kale and fennel salad, it was very fresh and I liked the originality. Rigatoni Penne was incredible! Service was a little slow but we sat outside so didn’t mind too much
… more