Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
The Nightingale Supper Club has been serving Door County families since 1913 and is the go-to for prime rib and Friday night fish fry. Our menu offers a wide selection of entrees including nightly specials. Come in early and quench your thirst with our bar’s happy hour and the great selection of craft beers, wine, and spirits. We are not a club that requires membership, anyone is welcome to enjoy the Supper Club experience in our cozy atmosphere.
Old-school Wisconsin supper club & bar serving steakhouse fare & a Friday fish fry in a cozy space.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1541 Egg Harbor Rd, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235
Phone: (920) 743-5593
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: nightingalesupperclub.comopentable.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Nightingale Supper Club | American Restaurant in Sturgeon Bay, WI
Experience the charm of Nightingale Supper Club, a Sturgeon Bay tradition since 1913. Enjoy timeless cuisine, cozy ambiance, and unforgettable evenings.
Menus | Nightingale Supper Club in Sturgeon Bay, WI
See the menus for Nightingale Supper Club in Sturgeon Bay, WI. Serving seafood and American dishes for kerbside pickup, takeaway, and dine-in!
Nightly Specials | American Restaurant in Sturgeon Bay, WI
Experience the charm of Nightingale Supper Club, a Sturgeon Bay tradition since 1913. Enjoy timeless cuisine, cozy ambiance, and unforgettable evenings.
Reviews
Deena Ovist
First time dining here; came for the Thursday night prime rib special. Hubby and I arrived early for our reservation giving us time to order cocktails from the friendly bar staff. Once seated for dinner, everything from the warm fresh bread, crispy dinner salad with tasty blue cheese dressing, and medium-rare prime rib with creamy horseradish sauce were delish. Haley R. was our friendly server. She was busy but Haley made time/effort to make sure we had everything we needed. Great first experience for us; we will return for another dinner. Highly recommend.
… moreLeslie Denneau
One of the best supper clubs we’ve been to! We loved the atmosphere- traditional supper cluby with modern updates. The bar area was great with comfortable seating, drinks and wonderful bartender.
I had scallops and French onion soup. Husband had tenderloin and loaded baked potato. The food was done perfectly and so delicious. Our server was Zach and he was top notch. I highly recommend nightingale!
… moreI had scallops and French onion soup. Husband had tenderloin and loaded baked potato. The food was done perfectly and so delicious. Our server was Zach and he was top notch. I highly recommend nightingale!
LCDR Christopher Hanson
Enjoyed an amazing Anniversary dinner with my wife on Saturday. The wait time is misleading as we had a reservation yet arrived early for a couple of drinks at the bar. We were seated exactly at our reservation time.
Atmosphere is pure, authentic Wisconsin Supper Club. Service was outstanding, staff are very friendly and knowledgeable.
Fresh bread and salads were delicious. My Prime Rib was perfect and a very generous serving. My wife said her Tenderloin was excellent.
Overall an excellent experience and we will continue to stop here during every visit to Sturgeon Bay.
My only wish would be to have an actual salad bar instead of the plated salad. However, that did not at all detract from our experience.
… moreAtmosphere is pure, authentic Wisconsin Supper Club. Service was outstanding, staff are very friendly and knowledgeable.
Fresh bread and salads were delicious. My Prime Rib was perfect and a very generous serving. My wife said her Tenderloin was excellent.
Overall an excellent experience and we will continue to stop here during every visit to Sturgeon Bay.
My only wish would be to have an actual salad bar instead of the plated salad. However, that did not at all detract from our experience.
Tracy Wehringer
An absolutely wonderful date night at the Nightingale Supper Club in Sturgeon Bay. From the moment we arrived, the atmosphere felt warm, classic, and exactly what you want from a true Wisconsin supper club experience.
Ron ordered the prime rib, which was cooked perfectly; tender, flavorful, and served with rich au jus and delicious garlic mashed potatoes. It was truly outstanding.
I had the filet mignon with shrimp, and it was also cooked to perfection, beautifully tender and full of flavor.
Everything about the evening felt special: great food, great service, and a relaxed supper club ambiance that makes you want to stay and enjoy the moment.
If you’re in Door County and looking for a fantastic dinner, I highly recommend the Nightingale Supper Club. We will definitely be back.
… moreRon ordered the prime rib, which was cooked perfectly; tender, flavorful, and served with rich au jus and delicious garlic mashed potatoes. It was truly outstanding.
I had the filet mignon with shrimp, and it was also cooked to perfection, beautifully tender and full of flavor.
Everything about the evening felt special: great food, great service, and a relaxed supper club ambiance that makes you want to stay and enjoy the moment.
If you’re in Door County and looking for a fantastic dinner, I highly recommend the Nightingale Supper Club. We will definitely be back.
Laura Benton
We went for a classic supper club dinner – and we got it! The prime rib was delicious and the Traditional Old Fashioneds were some of the best we’ve ever had. There is a great kids menu but our daughter had the fried shrimp and said it was great. We’ll be back when we’re in the area.
… moreJim Jorstad
Service was efficient and friendly. Steak bites for an appetizer are a must. Ordered the Tuesday night special of grilled salmon on a bed a fresh asparagus. Slight outer crust on salmon and nice flavor internally. Side salad and baked potato were nice accompaniments.
… moreRicky Bellows
This place was STUPID good, says my wife. The food was incredible. For about $140 we got 4 cocktails, steak, pasta, a starter, steak bites for my daughter, soups and salads. We didn’t have one bad thing. A meal like this in the city would be $300-$400+. Highly recommended. Also, other than the amazing steaks, the fettuccini Alfredo (while also being the only pasta on the menu) was again, stupid good. Go eat at this place NOW.
… moreDanny Wilson
Can we add a 6th star?? Amazing food, some of the best steak I have ever ate. Megan was a great waitress.
… moreJenny O
I am 30 weeks pregnant and have been cravings for barbecue ribs I am so glad that my husband took me here for my birthday dinner He ordered steaks he shared it to me and it was fantastic, I ordered barbecue baby back ribs and it was amazing! I had a crab asparagus soup for my side it was superb! all the food we ordered from here fullfilled my pregnancy cravings. 4 thumbs up from me and hubby definitely recommend this place to our friends. We are from Madison by the way
… moreBen Meissner
Nightingale is a great spot to stop for some good Wisconsin supper club atmosphere. The restaurant is well decorated and often has live music. We went for 2 nights. We went on Friday to get the fish fry, and on Saturday to get the 16oz prime rib special. The fish fry was good but nothing special, but the prime rib was amazing! The prime rib seems to be what they’ve become known for. Definitely recommend stopping here for some live music and good food.
… more