Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
Absolutely loved this beachfront gem! The view was stunning, the breeze was perfect, and the lobster roll was fresh and full of flavor—definitely one of the best I’ve had. The servers were so kind and welcoming, making the whole experience even better. Can’t wait to come bac… more… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Key West Restaurant at Islip Town Beach – Facebook
600 South Bay Ave, Islip, NY, United States, 11751. Links. . sunsetislip.wix.com/sunsetrestaurant. Contact info. . (631) 277-5500. . [email protected] …
KeyWest Waterfront Beer Garden (@key_west_islip_beach) · Islip, NY
1.5K+ followers · 174 posts · Key West presents our food truck themed beach hut with delicious food & tasty drinks! ☀️ MON-FRI 11:30am-9pm SAT-SUN 9am-9pm …
Key West Islip Beach – Delicious Beachfront Dining Awaits
Experience the vibrant flavors and laid-back atmosphere at Key West Islip Beach. Enjoy a diverse menu featuring delicious comfort food, refreshing cocktails …
Reviews
Thomas Kempster
Great place off the main strip of South Shore. Nice mix of straight barbecue and seafood outside overlooking the bay. Totally awesome with sun going down and Country music performed by Tom Country! Food and service was even better than expected. Definitely a warm weather gem to enjoy!
… moreNicole A
Absolutely loved this beachfront gem! The view was stunning, the breeze was perfect, and the lobster roll was fresh and full of flavor—definitely one of the best I’ve had. The servers were so kind and welcoming, making the whole experience even better. Can’t wait to come bac
EXP Smith
Great place, hidden Gem…great Sunset and great Pizza Sal is a gentleman.
… moreJoe Yen
It is close to Key West feel as you can in Long Island. Nice set up with plenty outdoor seating, music. Has clean bathroom and outdoor shower. Next to the beach, the food is good and not over priced. Other than the rocky sands and brown color ocean you would really think you are in key west…Can’t fix long island beaches..,
… moreJ ProShots
You need to be a town resident during summer season. Love this place and the restaurant KEY WEST they have some refreshing drinks and some tasty food. They have grill on the other side so you can BBQ and the beach is right there don’t need to walk miles to jump in the water
… moreLisa Ungar
I have eaten here before, I work nearby. The food has always been good and the view of the bay is beautiful. I took my daughters here for the first time as we were looking for a casual place with good seafood. After what happened with my daughter though, I was very disappointed. She ordered the grilled Mahi-mahi with vegetables for $25. She was given the wrong order of a fried fish sandwich with French fries. (She doesn’t eat fried food). They offered to bring vegetables but for an extra $5. The sandwich they brought was about $17-18 on the menu which they acknowledged they overcharged her, but did not offer to fix the mistake or offer a refund. As much as I enjoy the food and the vibe here, the customer service is lacking. My food was good, but did not enjoy it because the whole experience. I would hope that the wait staff gets better training in customer service.
… moreLiliana Alvarado
Quiet little beach, mostly for sitting, catching the sun or having nice dinner by the sea on the restaurant. I wouldn’t go in the water but there is a lifeguard , so you can go in
… moreSandy L
A great local getaway! A weekend visit or on your weekday lunch break… drive down, eat your lunch while enjoying the cool breeze and pretty waves. Bring the kids to enjoy the playground area. Cute Tiki Bar/Restaurant, Outdoor Deck, Outdoor Showers and Plenty of Seating, Tables, Benches and Gazebo for a shady retreat. Stop by and take a look if you’re in the Islip area, just off downtown Main Street, South all the way to the end.
… moreD. Bell
We really enjoyed ourselves! The atmosphere was peaceful and of course the day we were there the Sun was shining so you almost got the feeling you were somewhere out in the Caribbean. The food was delicious and the service was outstanding!
… moreNina Ungar
the customer service sucked. if you go here really specify what your ordering I ordered the grilled mahi mahi platter and the cashier(really sweet young girl, but seemed very confused and spacey) rang me up for 25.00 but they gave me a key west sandwich instead which is only 17.00 when I told them they gave me the wrong thing and I can’t eat what they gave me they said they could give me the vegetables for an extra 5.00. After I was already over charged by 8. The girl told me the price difference was only a few dollars stating the sandwich is 22.00 and change. But I looked at one of the signs after everyone was done eating and a big sign that said key west sandwich with a picture of exactly what they gave me said 17 and change. I was with my mother and sister and didnt want to make more of a situation and ruin their vibe but I left hungry and super disappointed the staff did nothing to remedy the situation after I spoke to 3 different people about it I was excited to eat here and the experience was just super disappointing and the staff didn’t seem to care at all about the patrons after complaining they just said I made the wrong order even though I never asked for a sandwich I asked for a mahi mahi grilled plater :/ so yeah 25.00 down and still super hungry not sure what I paid for. I could’ve gotten a really good meal elsewhere. I hardly write reviews unless I really feel wronged. But figured people should know coming here that you might leave without eating your food because the cashier couldn’t get the order right and no one else is willing to do right by a customer that got the wrong order
… more