Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 18 E Mt Pleasant Ave, Livingston, NJ 07039
Phone: (973) 994-1089
Website: https://tonyboys.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Tony Boys NJ: Home
Welcome to Tony Boy’s Sandwich House, offering gourmet sandwiches crafted with premium ingredients across multiple New Jersey locations.
Livingston, NJ Sandwiches | Tony Boy’s Sandwich Shop
Discover Tony Boy’s in Livingston, NJ – where authentic sandwiches blend with modern culinary artistry. Join us for an unforgettable dining experience in …
Tony Boys Sandwich House | Livingston Delivery Menu – Grubhub
Order delivery or pickup from Tony Boys Sandwich House | Livingston in Livingston! View Tony Boys Sandwich House | Livingston’s March 2026 deals and menus.
Reviews
Starlica Reiné
I hate to write this review. Gave this spot a 3.8 rating. I was honestly looking forward to raving about this place. I was looking for something healthier and this spot was close by. Ordered two Shrek wraps and added chicken ($36). Super pricey, but hey.. thought it would be worth it. At first glance the wraps were huge. It could easily last two days. The sandwich was sadly a complete wet mess with no flavor whatsoever. Extremely bland and so watery. The burrito was so soggy, it completely fell apart. Had to use a fork and a knife. The last half was a disaster tried to add seasoning, but it was no help. Pretty much threw the rest away. It was just so soupy. This visit was a complete fail.
Now, I can’t speak for other items on the menu, but if they are similar to this one, I won’t be back. Sadly a horrible first experience.
The place overall seemed cool and the staff were friendly. I’m sure there’s plenty to like.
… moreNow, I can’t speak for other items on the menu, but if they are similar to this one, I won’t be back. Sadly a horrible first experience.
The place overall seemed cool and the staff were friendly. I’m sure there’s plenty to like.
Chuck Mound
The Rock Star was the kid behind the counter managing the orders at the front of the counter. Phones ringing, people placing orders, door dash pick ups. He was an all star in my opinion. The cheesesteak for me was more like a steak sandwich. Different than what I have been presented with across the state. The sandwich was light on steak. The bread was good but overpowered the sandwich. It was good, and I would go back, but didn’t quite crack the top 10 on Scary Good Eats App just yet. Great Service.
… moreMargaret Smith
It took too long; I thought I wouldn’t have lunch at work. They do follow directions, and the sandwich is tasty. It could use some more vinegar, but other than that, no complaints. I love the shake, but I’m mad that I lost half my lunchtime waiting to eat, and I paid for priority delivery. I feel somewhat taken advantage of in that regard.
Additionally, it’s not worth the high price; it’s just a basic sandwich. I have had more stuffed sandwiches for less. They got a big ego cuz they are in Livingston. Not nasty, but not amazing; go out of your way for it.
… moreAdditionally, it’s not worth the high price; it’s just a basic sandwich. I have had more stuffed sandwiches for less. They got a big ego cuz they are in Livingston. Not nasty, but not amazing; go out of your way for it.
Lad Bell
Excellent local restaurant with a great variety of sandwiches and salads. The “Angry Bird” chicken sandwich was fantastic! Tender chicken cutlets meets sweet and a little spicy. Perfect combination. Outrageously delicious. The French fries were cooked equally as good. Great flavor with a nice crisp.
The restaurant is spotless clean with friendly and attentive service. Convenient parking in the rear.
… moreThe restaurant is spotless clean with friendly and attentive service. Convenient parking in the rear.
NJ Chicken King
Wow! Super professional sandwiches. The nutty pig sandwich with chicken cutlet was so amazing. Fresh crispy tender chicken cutlet , crispy smoky bacon and peanut butter sauce and jelly. Tons of options from sandwiches to salads and wraps. Shakes. Sodas. I wanted to try everything on the menu but I was so full. Had a few tables inside to hangout and some outside seating when it’s nice out. Fast friendly service. This is my new favorite place I will for sure be back to try everything on the menu.
… moreJocelyn Lee
A good sandwich spot if you’re looking for one. They specialize in their chicken cutlets sandwiches but everything else looks good. I think we got the classic chicken cutlets with mozz, balsamic and roasted red pepper and the angry bird which had pepperoni, chicken cutlets, hot honey and vodka sauce. I really loved the angry bird because it wasn’t messy, just the right amount of vodka sauce and it came warm. It actually really isn’t that hot either, just the right amount for taste. I appreciate the cutlets are thin and it reheats in well. The staff was super friendly and they kept inside clean.
… moreCasey
Recently bought 2 family meals for my husband’s birthday with about 7 adults and 5 kids. The drunken chicken was a hit and a great amount of food that we shockingly had leftovers everyone wanted to take home! Told everyone I know and work with what a great value it was. Nice guy at the register brought the food out to my car too and it was piping hot. Easy to order online. Easy pick up on my way home from work. I’ve loved everything we’ve ordered before, sandwiches are unbelievable. Dont even hesitate and order now!
… moreZachary Fox
If happiness were a sandwich, it’d be from Tony Boys.
I worked at the Meat House in Summit, so I don’t toss around “5 star sandwiches” lightly. But Tony Boys doesn’t serve good sandwiches — they serve great ones. These things are massive and addictive. The chipotle mayo is spicy, the mozzarella is fresh, and the lettuce is crispy.
My go-to: grilled chicken, fresh mozz, roasted red peppers, onions, lettuce, and that glorious chipotle mayo on a hero. Every bite is like a standing ovation for your taste buds.
I live in Chicago now but I crave this place every time I’m in the area. Plus, the staff is always super nice.
… moreI worked at the Meat House in Summit, so I don’t toss around “5 star sandwiches” lightly. But Tony Boys doesn’t serve good sandwiches — they serve great ones. These things are massive and addictive. The chipotle mayo is spicy, the mozzarella is fresh, and the lettuce is crispy.
My go-to: grilled chicken, fresh mozz, roasted red peppers, onions, lettuce, and that glorious chipotle mayo on a hero. Every bite is like a standing ovation for your taste buds.
I live in Chicago now but I crave this place every time I’m in the area. Plus, the staff is always super nice.
Loner Mom
The sandwiches here are so delicious flavorful and filling… fresh ingredients and super fast delivery…. I can’t wait to try a salad next… you can definitely split a sandwich if it’s lunchtime the portions are huge… definitely get your moneys worth
… moreItsFayyy
For my lunch today, I had an Italian hoagie from Tony Boyz. It was fresh, loaded, and full of flavor. Everything was on point. If you’re not eating Tony Boyz sandwiches, you’re missing out.
… more