Michael Berl
Been going to Carusos for years. Never a disappointment. It’s a hike from Smyrna, but always worth the trip. We were greeted and seated promptly. Our server, Gabby, quickly introduced herself and took our drink order. She never missed a beat. Everything was cooked to order and served professionally. Our meals were cooked to perfection and our stay was unrushed.
Thank you Gabby and Carusos for a nice experience.
… moreSaundra Ferrara
Perfect location, the waitress was perfect, so kind and quick. The place is decorated perfectly. But unfortunately there were fruit flies like crazy in the restaurant. They were so bad it started to turn us off. The food had flavor, and it would be perfect it it truly wasn’t for the flies. The leftovers we ended throwing out because we didn’t feel comfortable eating it.
… moreAri Barnett
I have FINALLY after living here for 15 years, found the only good pizza place in all of Delaware. Awesome pizza!!! This place reminds you of a NY pizzeria from the moment you step in. The (I think must be) owner always greets me with a smile at the register and I can’t resist picking up a random slice in addition to the order my wife usually calls in. Keep up the great work guys, and don’t ever change
… moreTom Jarrett
We love this place. Melina and Olivia are fantastic! The owner greets us every time we go in for dinner. Food is delicious! Highly recommend Chicken Francese and Chicken Marsala.
… moreNicole Lopes
Went in quick off the highway during a road trip for slices. They warmed them up for us and they tasted great! Nice chewy, crunchy crust. One guy was yelling at another behind the counter hence the four stars.
… moreAngela Walker
Absolutely one of the poorest experiences. Server was rushed. Sat us at a very small table and when we asked for a larger one, she gave us an attitude. It wasn’t busy and plenty of open tables. Calzone order was wrong and pizza was so undercooked and floppy. Told her the calzone was wrong and we couldn’t eat most of it. She apologized but seemed flat and didn’t offer to adjust the bill.
… moreJamal Tarib
We are new to the Middletown DE area, as we just moved from New York, so we were looking for a pizzeria which serves New York style pizzas. Caruso’s pizza was nearest to our new place and had decent reviews. The cashier was new but the owner was besides her helping her. Both of them were courteous and welcoming. They helped me choose the pizza I wanted and it was ready by the promised time. The pizza was good, and as it was a large one, we even saved some for the following day and it did not disappoint. We found our pizza joint and would highly recommend.
… moreJKReacher458
Went twice. Pizza is super greasy and not crispy. Got sick second time for two days from the sausage pie. Just another sub par Delaware pizza joint.
… moreGreg Safian
Hands down the best NY style pizza in New Castle County. Even if you don’t live in Middletown, it’s worth the trip. They have a large and unique selection of slices that come out perfectly crispy. Service is great! Our favorite pie to take home is the upside-down square pie add sausage. This place is a must try!!!
… moreNail Bar HAPPY PARADISE
Our children thoroughly enjoy those pizzas. The crab pizza is exceptional and a unique offering not commonly found elsewhere.
… more