Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1869 NY-52, Liberty, NY 12754
Phone: (845) 292-0007
Website: https://www.stellatwo.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Stella 2 – Liberty, NY – 1869 NY-52 – Hours, Menu, Order
Enjoy the best pizza in Liberty like the locals do. Liberty residents have made Stella 2 one of the most popular pizzerias in the area.
Stella 2 – View Menu & Order Online – 1869 NY-52, Liberty, NY 12754
Specialty Pizza · Best seller. White Pizza · Best seller. Margherita Pizza · Artichoke Spinach Pizza · Vodka Pizza · Hawaiian Pizza. Ham & pineapple. · Best …
Stella’s Pizzeria 2, 1869 State Route 52, Liberty, NY 12754, US
Own this business? Claim it. See a problem? Let us know. United States ›New York ›Liberty ›Stella’s Pizzeria 2. Partial Data by Foursquare. See …
Reviews
Lisa Pontorero
I LOVE their Grandma Pizza!! The sauce is spot on. The crust is nice and thin.
If you’re tired of the “same old same old,” check them out! This will be your new favorite pizza!
… moreIf you’re tired of the “same old same old,” check them out! This will be your new favorite pizza!
Mary Alvarado
Good pizza place, better than others in the vicinity. Sometimes the person on the phone can be a little grumpy but its whatever. I know their wings are good, and they have options other places around here don’t have. Not super, but not bad either. 7.5/10
… moreMelissa S
I placed an order on DoorDash for delivery now explain to me, how the soups came extremely hot and the appetizers came lukewarm close to being cold. I honestly don’t get it since I’m not that far from Stella’s. Were they sitting out and made for someone else?
… moreValerie Rifflard
Today I was a littl disappointed with my crispy chicken wrap. I ordered through door dash. I requested cheddar, they ignored the request but omitted the onions as requested. Completely forgot the mayo. No fork for my salad or napkins.
… moreMantee
Veal Fricassee + Caesar Salad
I ordered the veal fricassee with a side Caesar salad and left feeling disappointed overall.
What Worked:
The croutons in the Caesar were excellent — homemade, crunchy, toasty, and full of flavor. The Caesar dressing itself was creamy and bold, easily the highlight of the meal.
The breading on the veal was good and flavorful, showing the kitchen knows how to season properly.
What Didn’t Work:
The salad portion was laughable: maybe four pieces of lettuce total. Calling it a “salad” felt like false advertising.
The veal itself seemed like it had been sitting in a freezer too long. It looked unusually pale, had an off smell, and carried that faint old-meat taste that fresh seasoning couldn’t cover up.
Verdict:
There’s potential here — the flavors and seasoning were solid — but the quality of the veal and the tiny side portion ruined it. If fresher meat and better portions were used, this could’ve been a great meal.
Rating: 2.5/5
… moreI ordered the veal fricassee with a side Caesar salad and left feeling disappointed overall.
What Worked:
The croutons in the Caesar were excellent — homemade, crunchy, toasty, and full of flavor. The Caesar dressing itself was creamy and bold, easily the highlight of the meal.
The breading on the veal was good and flavorful, showing the kitchen knows how to season properly.
What Didn’t Work:
The salad portion was laughable: maybe four pieces of lettuce total. Calling it a “salad” felt like false advertising.
The veal itself seemed like it had been sitting in a freezer too long. It looked unusually pale, had an off smell, and carried that faint old-meat taste that fresh seasoning couldn’t cover up.
Verdict:
There’s potential here — the flavors and seasoning were solid — but the quality of the veal and the tiny side portion ruined it. If fresher meat and better portions were used, this could’ve been a great meal.
Rating: 2.5/5
Britney Matthews
Walking in you can smell the fresh bread and pizza dough. Busy little establishment. We had their Philly cheese steaks which were quite tasty. The bread is fresh and slightly toasted. Come hungry as tackling the entire sandwich is quite a task. Don’t forget the side of garlic fries! If not interested in Philly steaks they have a number of other items on their menu from pizza to other sandwiches and salads.
… moreToolTek MD
This food was awful. I ordered a large onion and mushroom pizza, mozzerella sticks, and 2 Liter Pepsi. The pizza was overcooked but somehow the toppings were completely raw. It seems as though they baked the pizza, and then slapped the toppings on after the fact. The crust was burnt and hard as a rock, as was the bottom of the pizza. Additionally, they put pickled peppers on my pizza, which is a topping that I did not order. The peppers were disgusting. I did not appreciate these sour peppers on my pizza. The entire pizza was awful, so much so that I opted not to even finish it. The mozzerella sticks were very oily and had a strong oil flavor. You can see in the photos just how saturated with oil
they were. Finally, the Pepsi that I received just tasted off. It wasn’t flat, but it didn’t taste fresh at all. I noticed that the seal was not tight upon opening the soda, and would imagine that this had something to do with the strange flavor. Overall, I was extremely disappointed with my order. This food was absolutely awful. I will not be ordering from here again.
… morethey were. Finally, the Pepsi that I received just tasted off. It wasn’t flat, but it didn’t taste fresh at all. I noticed that the seal was not tight upon opening the soda, and would imagine that this had something to do with the strange flavor. Overall, I was extremely disappointed with my order. This food was absolutely awful. I will not be ordering from here again.
Thomas Manners
Amazing! Just a spur of the moment decision while getting a car wash on our way home from vacation but WOW! Best meal of our trip. What the heck? Such a cool little place definitely going back.
Food was excellent. Well cooked, warm and ready. Seriously delicious bread and overall obviously high quality ingredients.
Stop here, seriously. Everything looked amazing and they have such a cool little dining area and clean bathrooms!
I felt so compelled to write this that I haven’t even left their parking lot. And I’m late and don’t care I just had the best cheese steak in a long, long time.
Saved, favorited. See you next trip!!
… moreFood was excellent. Well cooked, warm and ready. Seriously delicious bread and overall obviously high quality ingredients.
Stop here, seriously. Everything looked amazing and they have such a cool little dining area and clean bathrooms!
I felt so compelled to write this that I haven’t even left their parking lot. And I’m late and don’t care I just had the best cheese steak in a long, long time.
Saved, favorited. See you next trip!!
Stephanie Taubner
Best pizza in the area!! Service is always great and the food is amazing every time.
… moreJay Mott
This place is a complete joke, the counter help is rude, she clearly hates her job.
The menu on the table says burgers, the wall menu says burgers! yet when you order a burger she rudly tells you we don’t make them anymore. Then follows it up with yeah it says it on the wall but we don’t do it.
The tables are dirty, floors dirty, people food plates left on tables no one even trying to clean up. And they are not busy.
This place will be just another failed statistic of liberty, and this one’s clearly of there own doing.
Makes me wonder how they have another location.
… moreThe menu on the table says burgers, the wall menu says burgers! yet when you order a burger she rudly tells you we don’t make them anymore. Then follows it up with yeah it says it on the wall but we don’t do it.
The tables are dirty, floors dirty, people food plates left on tables no one even trying to clean up. And they are not busy.
This place will be just another failed statistic of liberty, and this one’s clearly of there own doing.
Makes me wonder how they have another location.