Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 147 W 35th St, New York, NY 10001
Phone: (212) 500-7591
Website: http://villagesquarepizzanyc.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Village Square Pizza
Midtown. 147 W 35th Street. New York, NY 10001. Phone: (212) 500-7591. More … The best pizza in New York City HANDS DOWN. I don’t care what anyone else …
Village Square Pizza • NYC (@villagesquarepizza) – Instagram
26K followers · 1.7K+ posts · NYC East Village: 147 Ave A West Village: 118 Christopher Upper East Side: 1200 Lexington Midtown: 147 W 35th Upper West …
Menu – Village Square Pizza
Grandma (Most Popular). Slice: $5.50 | Pie: $36. Thin Crust. Fresh mozzarella, family recipe tomato sauce, fresh homemade pesto, parmesan cheese, …
Reviews
Trisha T
We wanted to grab a quick bite before a game and discovered this pizza spot. It looks like a regular pizza place from the outside but when you walk in it smells amazing and is very clean.
We got to chat with the owner who told us a little about the place and where in Italy he was from. Super nice. You could tell that quality is important to him. When he took a pie out of the oven the crust was a little too dark for his standards so he actually offered free slices to us folks eating inside. Personally I like my crusts crunchy so I was happy.
I got the grandma slice and it was delicious. Definitely would to back.
… moreWe got to chat with the owner who told us a little about the place and where in Italy he was from. Super nice. You could tell that quality is important to him. When he took a pie out of the oven the crust was a little too dark for his standards so he actually offered free slices to us folks eating inside. Personally I like my crusts crunchy so I was happy.
I got the grandma slice and it was delicious. Definitely would to back.
EE Grimshaw
***3 1/2 stars***
I’m always a little leery of this area that tends to cater to the tourist demographic (which was alive and thriving when I arrived – an out-of-towner father of two gleefully purchased a $1 ranch side and practically shouted his thank yous as he walked away from the counter), but this place is a bit under the radar given where it is, and ultimately provides a quality slice.
I stumbled across Village Square a few days ago after almost getting lost in that horrendous hellscape known as the holiday markets over by Herald Square. Given that it’s literally a half block from Macy’s, it’s stunning how subtle the location is – it’s tucked away between a few other nondescript businesses and could easily be overlooked if you didn’t notice the signage. When I came back to try Village Square for lunch, it was pretty empty, save the aforementioned tourists and a few people waiting for pickup orders. There’s only a few stools and metal countertops along the walls, so it’s not the most comfortable eatery to spend your lunch in, but it is what it is.
Honestly, pizza optics are important to me and I thought the tomato sauce-based slices looked a little sketchy. The vodka square slices were an easy pick and remain one of the most underrated options on any pizzeria menu. There is a chicken parm vodka slice at Krispy Pizza in JC I stil think about from time to time. Anyway. This wasn’t bad, but would have been dramatically improved if I’d eaten it at room temperature. I’m not crazy about reheated slices anyway, as dried up sauce and cheese don’t exactly get me hot and bothered, but it’s especially true for vodka slices, which need the moistness to work. In this case, the guy at the counter got a little distracted from some other orders so my slices were in there probably a minute or two longer than they should have been, and the quality suffered as a result. The potential is there though. It’s a nice, crisp crust and I’d give this another shot if I remember to give them instructions to forego the additional oven trip.
Beyond the overheating, the service was totally fine. Very personable fellow manning the register who was clearly handling a ton of orders on his end. I was in and out of there pretty quickly. The price point…eh. It is what it is. Vodka slices are going to have specialty pricing, and coupled with the area of NYC you’re in, this is going to set you back about $11 or $12. I’ve seen worse, but welcome to holiday season in 2025. One of the better and sadly cheaper options in the neighborhood. Ho ho ho.
… moreI’m always a little leery of this area that tends to cater to the tourist demographic (which was alive and thriving when I arrived – an out-of-towner father of two gleefully purchased a $1 ranch side and practically shouted his thank yous as he walked away from the counter), but this place is a bit under the radar given where it is, and ultimately provides a quality slice.
I stumbled across Village Square a few days ago after almost getting lost in that horrendous hellscape known as the holiday markets over by Herald Square. Given that it’s literally a half block from Macy’s, it’s stunning how subtle the location is – it’s tucked away between a few other nondescript businesses and could easily be overlooked if you didn’t notice the signage. When I came back to try Village Square for lunch, it was pretty empty, save the aforementioned tourists and a few people waiting for pickup orders. There’s only a few stools and metal countertops along the walls, so it’s not the most comfortable eatery to spend your lunch in, but it is what it is.
Honestly, pizza optics are important to me and I thought the tomato sauce-based slices looked a little sketchy. The vodka square slices were an easy pick and remain one of the most underrated options on any pizzeria menu. There is a chicken parm vodka slice at Krispy Pizza in JC I stil think about from time to time. Anyway. This wasn’t bad, but would have been dramatically improved if I’d eaten it at room temperature. I’m not crazy about reheated slices anyway, as dried up sauce and cheese don’t exactly get me hot and bothered, but it’s especially true for vodka slices, which need the moistness to work. In this case, the guy at the counter got a little distracted from some other orders so my slices were in there probably a minute or two longer than they should have been, and the quality suffered as a result. The potential is there though. It’s a nice, crisp crust and I’d give this another shot if I remember to give them instructions to forego the additional oven trip.
Beyond the overheating, the service was totally fine. Very personable fellow manning the register who was clearly handling a ton of orders on his end. I was in and out of there pretty quickly. The price point…eh. It is what it is. Vodka slices are going to have specialty pricing, and coupled with the area of NYC you’re in, this is going to set you back about $11 or $12. I’ve seen worse, but welcome to holiday season in 2025. One of the better and sadly cheaper options in the neighborhood. Ho ho ho.
Ish Cheema
Some of the nicest guys that I have dealt with in NYC. They take pride in their Pizza and you could tell when they were warming it up – they checked the underside handmade sure it was up to the mark before handing it over to me. To drop it off – they gave me an extra slice free of cost (likely because it was closing time but still the generosity is appreciated).
Pizza is bomb! Must try Vodka slice and I am going back for sure.
… morePizza is bomb! Must try Vodka slice and I am going back for sure.
Alan
I stopped by Village Square Pizza – Midtown and had a slice of their pepperoni pizza with hot honey. The square slice was delicious, with a crispy crust and soft, doughy center. The pepperoni was perfectly charred, and the hot honey added a unique sweet-and-spicy kick that tied everything together. The staff was friendly, and the atmosphere had that classic NYC pizza shop feel. A great spot for a quick and satisfying bite—I’ll definitely be back!
… moreHeidi Dee
Tiny spot and delicious pizza. First stop on our trip and were not disappointed! The pizza is top notch! Just what I expected for NY pizza and good price. Tried other spots nearby that had looong lines and this one still beat them all in my books!
… moreT Ro
Just went here with a few friends and it wowed us so much that we had to leave a review. Get the pepperoni and ask for hot honey! The vodka slice and grandma slices were added bonuses. Fantastic Brooklyn style pizza and surprised to find it in midtown
… moreZack Henry
Ive been here for a week trying over 12 of the “best” pizza places. This is the only one ive visited twice. I cant think of a better way to put it.
… moreDee Dee
This was the best pizza we’ve had here, and we’ve tried Joe’s, which everyone was over hyping.
The classic, margarita, and vodka square pizza were so delicious and not too expensive by the slice. Wanted to go back one last time before we left.
… moreThe classic, margarita, and vodka square pizza were so delicious and not too expensive by the slice. Wanted to go back one last time before we left.
A V
True New York Slices!
NYC long time resident but moved out a few years ago. I came back for a Knicks game at MSG and went to grab a slice before heading back to my hotel. Avoided the crappy dollar slices and gave this place a shot. PHENOMENAL pizza!! Between my family, we tried the pepperoni, the vodka and the grandma. I can’t explain how shocked and amazed I was to get a great slice of true NYC pizza in midtown. Not sure when I’ll be back to midtown but when I am, I’ll 100% be grabbing some pies from Village Square!
… moreNYC long time resident but moved out a few years ago. I came back for a Knicks game at MSG and went to grab a slice before heading back to my hotel. Avoided the crappy dollar slices and gave this place a shot. PHENOMENAL pizza!! Between my family, we tried the pepperoni, the vodka and the grandma. I can’t explain how shocked and amazed I was to get a great slice of true NYC pizza in midtown. Not sure when I’ll be back to midtown but when I am, I’ll 100% be grabbing some pies from Village Square!
Daniel Barber
The pizza was very nice, all the options in the window looked appetizing, and I thoroughly enjoyed my order of a pepperoni slice and a classic slice. There were no chairs or tables inside or outside the place unfortunately, and it was uncomfortably warm in the building, making it a less enjoyable experience waiting for the food.
… more