Joseph Angarola
Hidden gem! Enjoyed a delicious dinner here tonight. Excellent all around with fantastic views of the marina and canal. Food reasonably priced unlike the prices a block away on the nautical mile and the staff all very attentive.
… morePamela H.
I thoroughly enjoyed dining at Pier 95. Went for the first time on a Sunday afternoon for lunch, as a party of 6. The owner and all employees who served us were extremely kind and accommodating. The food was exceptional. I had corn chowder with shrimp soup, filet of Sole for my entree, which came with rice and a vegetable medley, and creme brulee for dessert. Everything was delicious. Other members of my party had the short ribs, with mashed potatoes and green beans, while one person had the paella. Everyone enjoyed their food. The decor is amazing and the view of the water is breathtaking. I will be back.
… moreM J L
pier 95 delivers excellent service with attentive staff who know their menu well. The seafood is notably fresh and prepared with just the right seasonings to bring out its natural flavors. A delightful spot where good service meets delicious food
… moreKimberly Faraci
THE MOST AMAZING RESTAURANT!!!!!!!! Jenny the owner is so passionate about making everyone happy. Her kindness is unmatched. Tiago is also such a dream maker with his ability to provide excellence in all h does at this restaurant. My clients had a marriage proposal here today and the accommodations could not have been more perfect. I am blown away by the way this restaurant is run. While I was here I also noticed so much about how this HAPPY PLACE truly makes everyone feel as though they are VIP’s. I can’t wait to come back. It’s not just a restaurant on the water with a view…it’s the loveliest restaurant on the South Shore of Long Island. Make your reservation now…but be prepared to feel as though you were on cruise. Everything here is just perfect.
… moreSamantha P
Highly recommend Pier 95 Restaurant. I went with my family for an early Christmas get together. The decorations were beautiful. Tiago was so nice and took a picture for us without hesitation. The food was great. The whole branzino is a must. Three of us got the mariscada; the seafood was fresh and perfectly cooked. We’ll be back!
… morec kershaw
This is a hidden gem. The Atmosphere in the dining room is warm inviting. The food is delicious and plentiful. Located on the water with plenty of parking, which is always a plus. They have lunch specials and prefix dinner.
Jenny welcomed us and made us feel very comfortable. Highly recommended
… moreRobert Bacchi
A window seat at the dock, a very knowledgeable waiter and passionate owners. There were many specials to choose from. Portions are generous. My fish dish was prepared well as were all the dishes our party of four ordered
… moreIrisa Llana
Horrible experience, the owner was super rude. I went there for lunch with 3 other people and our food took 1 hour to come out- and all we ordered was pasta. The staff was super kind, but the owner started yelling at me when I asked when the food will be ready. Finally, when the pasta came out, it was so overcooked and so bland I could I have just made it at home out of a jar. Waste of money and time, plus, super rude, he shouldn’t be running a restaurant if he gets so emotional.
… moreMiah Arif
The place is real nice. Has a nice view of the dock. The server was really nice. The food was delicious but isn’t worth the price. Had better paella with better presentation for cheap. Everything else was average. Their lobster bisc was delicious. The trios appetizer is a rip off. Other then that very nice classy place.
… moreSage Chang
Took them over an hour to serve us bland, overcooked pasta. We patiently watched them serving all the other patrons who came after us before asking them how much longer it would take, and the owner rudely replied “you want your food cooked, no?”. If we wanted to take an hour to do grocery shopping and cook everything from scratch by ourselves we wouldn’t have come to a restaurant, no? Terrible experience. Avoid at all costs.
… more