Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
A family run pizzeria striving to please every customers’ wish. We take pride in our consistent, authentic, Buffalo style pizza. While also serving a wide variety of cold/hot subs, we also specialize in chicken wings and tenders. Come try us out today!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 6040 Sheridan Dr, Amherst, NY 14221
Phone: (716) 626-5550
Website: http://mattinaspizzeria.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Mattina’s Pizzeria – Our Family to Yours | Williamsville and …
Welcome to Mattina’s Pizzeria. We offer delivery and pick-up at both locations, and offer an eat-in experience in Tonawanda. We can’t wait to serve you.
Mattina’s Pizzeria (@mattinaspizza) – Facebook
Mattina’s Pizzeria. 1727 likes · 1 talking about this. Family run pizzeria … Amherst Supervisor Shawn Lavin is with Amherst Center for Senior Services – NY and …
Mattina’s Pizzeria Review – YouTube
Mattina’s Pizzeria Review with Jay Langfelder 6040 Sheridan Dr, Amherst, NY 14221 #food #pizza #review #foodblogger #foodie #cheese …
Reviews
Tenzing Norgay
Not happy about the total inconsistency here. There used to be a time when you could order a pizza and KNOW what to expect. Not anymore. I also want to say the people working here are not friendly, they all look annoyed, each time I have been here.
Look at the photo – one slice is loaded with WAY TOO MUCH cheese (gag), and the other, dried out with nothing – this is from the same pizza. The pizza size has been steadily shrinking (but they are charging more – upping the price every so often, to unrealistic prices). To get one of their “specials,” that is two slices of cheese or pepperoni pizza and one soft drink is $10.00. Insane.
The fact that I have personally been screwed multiple times in a row now – one time they told me the wait time would be 30 minutes (when I called) that it would be ready. I showed up way early, after 10 minutes, and they said, ‘Oh here is your pizza’ – he had the box in his hands before I even got to the ordering counter (or before I even told him the name on the order) – he was getting rid of a reject pizza that someone else did not want (I found that out once I got it home). Looked like crap, tasted like crap – super super thin, I think it had a 3mm crust – I could not believe it, like the dough never rose, it was gross. Many other times dried out pizza that had barely any sauce.
Another time the same thing happened – but this time I wanted to order slices – yet there were none in the case – but he just so happened to have a half a pizza sitting on the side cut in tiny squares (another reject pizza, trying to pass it off on us) and once again – squares are NOT what they put in the case for the special/individual slices (they are large triangles). I think they must think we are stupid and have no idea what they are doing – think again, We Do.
I used to really love their pizza, especially the sauce – but honestly, it has been one bad incident after another – there is NO consistency. Instead of treasuring regular customers and trying to make them happy (and to be honest in their dealings) they are passing off rejected pizzas to their regular customers. Not a way to keep a customer. There are plenty of other pizza places in the area – and I will go elsewhere from now on. They have lost one of their ‘regulars’ and I am sure they care less. I would tell you to go somewhere you are appreciated and taken care of for the long haul. A place where you know what to expect. This is not it.
… moreLook at the photo – one slice is loaded with WAY TOO MUCH cheese (gag), and the other, dried out with nothing – this is from the same pizza. The pizza size has been steadily shrinking (but they are charging more – upping the price every so often, to unrealistic prices). To get one of their “specials,” that is two slices of cheese or pepperoni pizza and one soft drink is $10.00. Insane.
The fact that I have personally been screwed multiple times in a row now – one time they told me the wait time would be 30 minutes (when I called) that it would be ready. I showed up way early, after 10 minutes, and they said, ‘Oh here is your pizza’ – he had the box in his hands before I even got to the ordering counter (or before I even told him the name on the order) – he was getting rid of a reject pizza that someone else did not want (I found that out once I got it home). Looked like crap, tasted like crap – super super thin, I think it had a 3mm crust – I could not believe it, like the dough never rose, it was gross. Many other times dried out pizza that had barely any sauce.
Another time the same thing happened – but this time I wanted to order slices – yet there were none in the case – but he just so happened to have a half a pizza sitting on the side cut in tiny squares (another reject pizza, trying to pass it off on us) and once again – squares are NOT what they put in the case for the special/individual slices (they are large triangles). I think they must think we are stupid and have no idea what they are doing – think again, We Do.
I used to really love their pizza, especially the sauce – but honestly, it has been one bad incident after another – there is NO consistency. Instead of treasuring regular customers and trying to make them happy (and to be honest in their dealings) they are passing off rejected pizzas to their regular customers. Not a way to keep a customer. There are plenty of other pizza places in the area – and I will go elsewhere from now on. They have lost one of their ‘regulars’ and I am sure they care less. I would tell you to go somewhere you are appreciated and taken care of for the long haul. A place where you know what to expect. This is not it.
Gmail Account
Normally I love Martina’s pizza, the sauce is the best – but there is no consistency in their baking/the recipe. One week it will be thicker, next thinner crust, one week too much cheese, the next not enough, one week perfectly baked, and other times burnt on the bottom. I do want the pepperoni’s blackened, and the top crust, but not the entire bottom. This really should not have been served. I am giving it 3 stars – should have been one star this time, but since their pizza is good other times, am not going lower than that. I hope their people in the kitchen will be more consistent so we know what to expect.
… moreKasim Sallaj
The pizza here is phenomenal! It’s a classic ‘Buffalo’ style with a generous amount of toppings and a perfect, slightly charred crust on the bottom. Truly delicious.
The wings, however, were a bit of a mixed bag. While they were a great size and perfectly crispy, they had almost no sauce on them. We ordered Medium and Mild, but both tasted as if they hadn’t been sauced at all. I’m hoping it was just a one-off mistake, as the quality of the chicken was great. I’ll definitely give them another shot!
… moreThe wings, however, were a bit of a mixed bag. While they were a great size and perfectly crispy, they had almost no sauce on them. We ordered Medium and Mild, but both tasted as if they hadn’t been sauced at all. I’m hoping it was just a one-off mistake, as the quality of the chicken was great. I’ll definitely give them another shot!
Ashley Oldman
Tried Mattinas pizza for the first time ever and it was very good. We ordered a Chicken Finger Sub and also a Pizza. The chicken fingers were very thick and meaty and seemed as if they may have been made in house but definitely good quality chicken fingers and at the usual price. Their pizza was very good and almost was reminiscent of Boccis club pizza, which in my opinion is a great thing. Their sauce was flavorful, and they had generous portions of topping.(I wouldn’t have minded extra sauce and cheese, but it was good how it was). You cannot dine in which I was not expecting but was fine. The staff were friendly and constantly cleaning/ scraping the ovens between each pizza. I definitely recommend trying them out if you have never. They are worth it.
… moreP.J. Robert
Great food, at both locations. I’ve been a.customer since day one. Huge fan of their pizzas, BBQ charred fingers, and charred BBQ wings. If I had to say anything negative it would be at times not enough sauce on the pizza, but that’s rare and might because I just live their sauce.
… morepamela johnson
Went to pick up preordered pizza special : large cheese/pepperoni 36 wings which costs $69 and some change . Waited for wings for about 10minutes , order for the wings were sauce (hot) extra crispy . Well the place was pretty busy being that the Buffalo Bills football game was being televised . My pizza had an over amount of sauce , half done pepperoni and the wings were not crispy and were undercooked as well with very little sauce . I’ve ordered from Mattinas a couple times before and the food was spectacular !!! Yesterday was a no win for my food and football team . I will give them another try , just not on game day !!!
… moreAlex Romano
Since moving to the area, Mattina’s has become our go to! We’ve tried at least 15 pizza places around, and this one happens to be our favorite as far as taste, quality and consistency! (Pics from 3 different days)
… moreArianna A
I really like the pizza and wings here and it is very close and convenient. Usually I end up having to ask for light cheese on my pizza and extra sauce and that way it is perfect! I find that 90% of the time their pizza is great but sometimes they can be slightly inconsistent ive noticed as I order from them very often. Other than that their pizza and wings have great flavor id recommend asking for the wings to be extra crispy too! My favorite thing from here would probably be the fried ravioli! Great place for pizza, wings, or any other game day snacks or food!
… moreSteve Baker
Loved this pizza and the garlic bread, just beware the large pizza is huge. 18 inches by 18 inches square. We ordered a half size, 9 inches by 18 inches, it was more than enough to feed four adults.
… moreTyler Ljungberg
Ordered the Wednesday special, a large pizza and 24 wings for $40.99. The pizza was cooked just right, the sauce was sweet, the dough was a nice consistency, and the cheese was right up to the crust. The wings were nothing special, typical pizza joint wings, but I would definitely come back for the pizza.
… more