4.4 – 406 reviews • Italian restaurant
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
Menu Photos
places.singleplatform.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Italian Village | Toast
Pickup from 5267 Philadelphia Ave, Chambersburg, PA. Schedule your order for … Sicilian Pizza. Sicilian Pizza. thick crust with mozzarella cheese & pizza sauce.
Reviews
Michelle Carey
Inconsistency is their constant. One day you go and it’s a 5-star experience but the next day it’s a 1-star meal. I’m close enough to enjoy both dining in and delivery, but it’s a roll of the dice each meal. Two weeks ago our food was exceptional and everything was great. Yesterday the lettuce on my sub was brown and had that oddly sweet flavor that lettuce gets when it’s spoiled. Till I removed the lettuce, there wasn’t much left to my sub. I paid extra for sweet peppers and found two slivers on the whole sub…while other times you definitely get your money’s worth. Hope you get the 5-star experience!
… moreGreg Walter
My wife got the Chicken Chesapeake and I got the Chicken Marsala. Both were very tasty and decent size portion and they were both around $20 a plate. It came with a nice salad and bread for each. The inside was well decorated, however it was pretty small and felt a little crowded. Since the dining area is one large room, it did get a little noisy whenever you had larger parties come in. Especially those who had younger kids. The wait staff was very friendly and did an excellent job and even gave recommendations when asked. Overall I thought this was a good value for your money and the food quality/quantity.
… moreJohn Wertz
Check your take out order before you leave the restaurant!! We really enjoy going to this restaurant. Food is usually very good and plentiful. I ordered take out Spaghetti with sausage. Although the flavor was very good, the amount of spaghetti was half the amount usually served with a dine in portion. Upon a call back, the only reason given was that they were very busy. Sad. Definitely sticking with Giacomos or Rosalie’s.
… moreRenee Grove
Absolutely delicious. One of the best Italian restaurants in the area for sure. The spaghetti with meat sauce was excellent and their homemade breadsticks are the best! The potato skins are more like a loaded baked potato but are also very good. The restaurant was clean and the staff were very nice and efficient. Highly recommend.
… moreC Vickers
Very good!!There are lots of great Italian food options all over Pennsylvania so generally speaking it is rare that I have had a negative experience. I typically order a Stromboli or pasta with onions peppers and sausage or chicken. In this case they had “sausage, green peppers and onions” on the menu so I ordered that and added chicken too. Served with a side salad and complimentary hot bread, I could not have been more satisfied with the flavor of my meal. For the salad I chose their house vinaigrette which was fantastic!!
We had a large group celebrating someone’s birthday and we were all pretty full. One of my brothers ordered the chicken Alfredo and thoroughly enjoyed it and my sister said her “crab Alfredo” was very good.
Atmosphere was nice but big issue was their air conditioner had gone out and it was quite warm in there. We had excellent service but their only seemed to be one waitress who was stretched thin.(but did a marvelous job). They were very busy that evening as there were several groups like ours of eight or more.
… moreLondon Shoemaker
Phenomenal food and service! Me and my fellow trumpet player Everet went here after a jazz concert and our waitress Grace did an amazing job, and the food tasted absolutely delicious.
… moreRaymond Bailey
New Italian Restaurant is a casual but very nice place to eat. The interior is decorated like a street cafe without being chokski. Both sizable booths and plenty of four or six-top tables. Tables and chairs are sturdy, a genuine pleasure from plastic or bendy types elsewhere.
Both dine in and takeout.
Food is quite good. Normal selection of Italian menu items. The pizza is very nice with luscious cheese and plentiful topping and crispy crust. Chicken parm was crispy and the marinara chunky enough to not drown the parm soggy, Well prepared!
Serving staff is polite and well trained. The owners seem to have a good handle on things, leaving one with. Good experience!
… moreKevin Flanagan
I read “stuffed crust” and I immediately thought of pizza hut style stuffed crust not, the entire pizza being stuffed . It was pretty good, pretty doughy the last couple of inches. The service was great, they gave lots of sauce and it was ready quicker than expected. Definitely a place worth checking out.
… moreAmy Genery
I order from this place every week! I am currently in the hospital and asked if they would deliver. They told me within a 5 mile radius. She checks. It’s 5.6 ! .6 miles over the 5 mile radius. I ask to speak to a manager she then puts me on hold comes back and says he said no we can’t do it! Thanks Italian Garden even when your sick customers wanted to order well over a $60 order you couldn’t spare that extra .6 of a mile! No more $20 tips for you guys. Jasmine and Angelos will definitely deserve this one!
… moreLisa Azary
Best Italian food. Great service. It is our favorite local restaurant.
… more … View more