Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 944 NJ-166, Toms River, NJ 08753
Phone: (732) 240-1331
Website: http://www.attiliospizza.org/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Attilio’s Pizza – Toms River NJ
Attilio’s Pizza. 941 Rt 166; Toms River, NJ 08753; (732) 240-1331. CALL US. Return to Main Menu. Online Ordering · Home · Menus · Lunch Specials · Catering …
Attilio’s Pizzeria | Toms River NJ – Facebook
Attilio’s Pizzeria, Toms River. 1458 likes · 354 were here. Toms Rivers oldest pizzeria. Opened and operated by the same family since 1973.
Attilio’s Pizza – Toms River, NJ – 941 NJ-166 – Hours, Menu, Order
View the menu, hours, address, and photos for Attilio’s Pizza in Toms River, NJ. Order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com.
Product
Reviews
STON3 K1LLA
I ordered through the website. My pizzas came burnt and hard. And the delivery driver had the nerve to ask for a tip, for burnt food. Was a waste of $17 dollars to be honest. Wouldn’t recommend the pizzas sorry.
… moreJason Luckey
First time ordering from here. Let me start off by saying one of the reasons I tried this place is because the responses to the reviews, especially the negative ones. Plus I like pizza and recently moved to Toms River and wanted to give something new a try. Many people only take the time to complain and they feel entitled to something for whatever reason. This is a small business and they need people to talk and support them. I admire them calling out the missing part of the stories where they were abused verbally by some of these “customers” prior to becoming keyboard commandos. Mistakes will happen and they own some mistakes but that doesn’t entitle you to act like a fool and abuse them. Kudos to the ownership for calling out the ones that should be called out for lies.
Now the important part . Their pizza has a nice thin crust and the toppings were flavorful with a subtle sweet taste to the sauce. We also got a salad for my wife and she loved it as well. It was our first time here and they have got me interested in trying out their dishes. Thanks to you for a good meal and being an honest business that gives it back to those deserving of a reality check. I’ll be sure to give some more business to you guys for making my first experience a good one. Lots of choices out there and this place won’t disappoint.
… moreNow the important part . Their pizza has a nice thin crust and the toppings were flavorful with a subtle sweet taste to the sauce. We also got a salad for my wife and she loved it as well. It was our first time here and they have got me interested in trying out their dishes. Thanks to you for a good meal and being an honest business that gives it back to those deserving of a reality check. I’ll be sure to give some more business to you guys for making my first experience a good one. Lots of choices out there and this place won’t disappoint.
ian metzger
This place is great, I dont even know where to start. The food is quite delicious and the seasonal decorations are welcoming. With a wide variety of fresh made dishes to include pizza, there is something for everyone, there is even a good variety of vegan, vegetarian and gluten friendly options for those with such dietary restrictions. Might I also mention that the staff is attentive and caring. This is the spot to be if you want a good bite.
… moreBriana Kraft
*door dash delivery 1000/10!*
Literally had to stop myself from devouring the entire thing so I could take a picture of it first. I’m originally from NJ but have been in VA for 4 years and I’ve had every pizza known to man…. This was DELICIOUS. I asked for well done and it came WELL DONE. That crunch was incredible but not too crunchy where it could break your jaw. I cannot stand sweeter pizza sauce and this was just PERFECT. Literally 1000/10. Can’t wait to order again… tomorrow !
… moreLiterally had to stop myself from devouring the entire thing so I could take a picture of it first. I’m originally from NJ but have been in VA for 4 years and I’ve had every pizza known to man…. This was DELICIOUS. I asked for well done and it came WELL DONE. That crunch was incredible but not too crunchy where it could break your jaw. I cannot stand sweeter pizza sauce and this was just PERFECT. Literally 1000/10. Can’t wait to order again… tomorrow !
Christine Anna Kochmann
If you are looking for vegan options, I can’t recommend this place enough. A small little pizza place tucked away in a strip mall …who knew! The vegan sausage in the sausage roll was to die for. It was like a stromboli. Five out of five stars. The garlic knots were amazing, so were the v rice balls. As was the pizza. I can’t wait to go back.
… moreAHMAD ALEX
wish I could give it zero stars , they sent us 2 pizzas all like that i called to speak to a manger ( I didnot ask for credit ) never complained before , they did nothing and said owner will call you in 2 days !!! horrible !! they dont even know to to bake a pizza !!
my replay to the owner is
that was a lie Noone offer any credit or to fix the order she didnot say owner out of the state or any thing she said exactly we CANNOT do anything about it now the owner will call you in a day or 2 !!
… moremy replay to the owner is
that was a lie Noone offer any credit or to fix the order she didnot say owner out of the state or any thing she said exactly we CANNOT do anything about it now the owner will call you in a day or 2 !!
C B
To each is own I wish I would have read the reviews and saw that picture at the bottom of the reviews of that slice pizza baby slices bar pizza thin pizza to crunchy hurted my gums. I ordered a large pie $17.00 really you literally can eat the whole pizza it’s hardly anything there. Chicken fingers french fries $11.00 overcooked cheap fries the thin fries large cheesesteak $1150 let’s just say no Philly cheese steak cheese steak was sad dry two crunchy cheap on the Mayo and the ketchup it’s sad cheap products for big bucks you will leave hungry with a hole in your pocket the drinks c&c drinks $ 3.99 Ice -T in the glass bottle $ 3.50 like I said C&C should be $1.99 cheap products for big bucks.this is sad attilio’s you robbed me for $55.99 my oder was 50.49 tax was 3.35 so my bill should be $53.84 we’re is my $2.15 at this is not adding up right way I paid 55.99 attilio’s stealing from the people shame on you shame on you shame shame shame .
… moreDana Telaj
I complained and spoke to to owner who did not care about my concerns as a costumer what’s so ever he told me to basically deal with it .. I spent $60 dollars on 1 pie and 2 small chicken cheese steaks .. the pie was tiny and the thinnest pizza . there was no chicken on the sandwich was so dry not a real chicken cheesesteak .. the owner didn’t care to accommodate us what so ever just dismissed our concerns I will never order from here again !.. do not recommend!
… moreKelly Mortellite
Never again! Received a cold pizza that looks and tastes 3 days old for $30. We called to let them know and the kid had nothing to say but my boss left. We will not be ever ordering again and we have been steady customers over the years.
… moreMonica Jerminario
Grabbed a gluten free pepperoni pizza, a GF white pizza, and GF mozzarella sticks for $55ish (with tax, tip, and 2 drinks).Generally happy with what we had and there were no issues with cross-contamination. Wish there was more sauce on the pizza because it was so delicious. That could have been a GF crust issue since they tend to soak up a lot of sauce. Nothing special with the crust, but it gets the job done. Mozzarella sticks were awesome– haven’t had those in a decade. Will eat here again.
… more