Jayni Whitefield
This place was a hidden gem! I think it isn’t slammed because it’s kind of hidden. Great local vibe! Food was amazing! One of the best cheesesteaks I’ve ever had! Bread was soft and crunchy! Great service! Portions were great size! My hubby and I were stuffed. The soup was wonderful!
… moreStef
Best Philly cheesesteak outside of Philly. Lived in Philly 25 years ago, and have been looking for the perfect sandwich ever since, and it lives in New Braunfels Texas. Soft roll, perfect balance of meat and mushrooms, thank you for the addition of the provolone and the garlic aioli . Fantastic owner, friendly, fast and very well priced. We’ll be looking for excuses to try everything on the menu on every road trip now. Thank you so much!
… moreAnthony Holder
Wow, total hidden gem. I’ve been driving past this place for years and never stopped. Saw another post online that finally sparked our curiosity, so we gave it a shot. I got the meat lovers, my wife had the deluxe hoagie. Both were absolutely delicious. We’ll definitely be back.
… moreTaylor Tyminski
Very cute hole in the wall shop. Great service but there was only one employee there on a Saturday lunch shift. It was slow enough it didn’t effect wait times for me but speaks more on store volume. I got the Philly and fries. Philly was just okay and I’m pretty sure the fries were frozen fries that they cooked in an air fryer. To me, not worth the price.
… moreMaria Donatiello
Delicious cheese steaks Italian ice friendly staff def would highly recommend this place !! Yumm
… moreSummer
I ordered a Philly cheese steak and pesto fries with a sweet tea. The tea tasted okay but it had a weird aftertaste. My Philly cheese steak was stale on the bottom and soggy on top. It had absolutely no flavor. I added spicy pepper relish and that was a mistake. It tasted like an Italian sub sauce not a spicy pepper relish. My fries were cold and burned. It was my first time and I cannot say I will return.
… moreSage Williams
Why are people still going to Subway or Firehouse? Serious question.
Marco Polo blows them both out of the water. Better bread, better meat, bigger portions, and way more flavor.
Once you eat here, everything else just feels like fast-food cosplay.
Oh and the staff, super friendly!
… moreJumbo Brigante
So 1st time here.. ill was looking for a sub sandwich and this spot popped up. Lady in front was very helpful.. guided me to their Philly. Said thats what they are most known for. It was ok I think I just wasn’t in the mood for one I should have got a cold sandwich (who eats a hot sandwhich?? Lol) but service was great and fast. Definitely comming back and trying a cold sub next time
… moreSammy Bug
GREAT food and Italian ices. SO many options a little bit for everyone. Small indoor area, but enough to hang out or you can always take to-go. We enjoyed different paninis and cream-ices. Awesome locally-owned business. Definitely don’t hear enough people taking about this place. Also a cool skate shop on the back side of the restaurant.
… moreGary Jack
Absolutely delicious and authentic Hoagies, Paninis, and Cheesesteak sandwiches! Love the Classic Italian! This is a hidden gem in New Braunfels. Great food, great service and very friendly Mom & Pop owners. We went to this place before our trip to Italy (Amalfi coast) and they even gave us tips on Italy. Since then, we’ve ordered sandwiches repeatedly. We’re hooked! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Enjoy!!
… more