Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Please visit our official website or our Facebook page to view our complete menu. Menus generated elsewhere (including google) are not trusted or created by Heintzelman’s BBQ Pit. Please call us for any questions you may have, or to make a reservation.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 6361 Knickerbocker Rd, Ontario, NY 14519
Phone: (315) 333-1235
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Best BBQ in Ontario, NY | Heintzelman’s BBQ Pit | BBQ near me
Located at 6361 Knickerbocker Road in Ontario, Heintzelman’s BBQ Pit brings authentic pit-smoked barbecue to the community with bold flavor and traditional slow …
Heintzelman’s BBQ Pit Inc | Ontario NY – Facebook
Heintzelman’s BBQ Pit Inc is a family owned BBQ restaurant featuring homemade sides, rubs, marinades.
Heintzelman’s BBQ Pit Inc – Ontario, NY Restaurant | Menu + Delivery
Order with Seamless to support your local restaurants! View menu and reviews for Heintzelman’s BBQ Pit Inc in Ontario, plus popular items & reviews.
Reviews
Derek McAllister
Not going to claim it’s the best BBQ out there, but I will say it is quite good. The wing were really good. Smoked only per the menu yet the skin wasn’t gooey and the meat came right off the bone. The pulled pork was nice and lean (my preference). The brand packed a little flavor but a little of their gold sauce solved that. Mac and cheese wasn’t all that great. Almost as if their rue was to tight and it wasn’t a smooth and creamy cheese sauce though the flavor wasn’t bad. I prefer mine with a sharper cheese as this really tasted like a mild cheddar was used.
Overall, a good stop and it’ll certainly be a place we’ll keep in mind when we’re out that direction again.
… moreOverall, a good stop and it’ll certainly be a place we’ll keep in mind when we’re out that direction again.
Tina Fry
I order doordash from here a lot and its always tasty. My husband and I decided to go in and order take out for valentines day and see what their specials were. I got the prime rib with a snow crab add on. BEST PRIME RIB I’ve EVER had. Not kidding. That smoky, flavorful crust was to die for. The Mac and cheese is actual southern style. Dry and crumbly like I like it. Also the house bbq blue cheese with their homemade cornbread croutons is out of this world. The owner took our to go order and she was so sweet. You can tell she takes pride in her establishment and she has right to. It was fantastic. Definitely going back and dining in soon!
… moreConstance Kessler
Three strikes, you’re out. We’ve given numerous chances, always thinking we came on an ‘off’ day. Today was the final nail.
Brisket is consistently gray and dry. I didn’t even get the brisket I ordered. The waitress was cheerful and did her job well. She did remove the additional charge for my missing brisket, and Dawn visited the table and said my husband’s dinner would be refunded- he tried a slice of brisket and ate his sides.
Today was our very last visit.
I had no doubt Dawn would be right on here, slamming a poor review. It happens every single time someone leaves one. It’s amazing how many people you’ve encouraged not to come back. SERIOUSLY?!?!
Where’s Gordon Ramsay, when you need him?
The customers are all wrong, not your food!
… moreBrisket is consistently gray and dry. I didn’t even get the brisket I ordered. The waitress was cheerful and did her job well. She did remove the additional charge for my missing brisket, and Dawn visited the table and said my husband’s dinner would be refunded- he tried a slice of brisket and ate his sides.
Today was our very last visit.
I had no doubt Dawn would be right on here, slamming a poor review. It happens every single time someone leaves one. It’s amazing how many people you’ve encouraged not to come back. SERIOUSLY?!?!
Where’s Gordon Ramsay, when you need him?
The customers are all wrong, not your food!
Rob Zuber
The food here is outstanding! If you are visiting for the first time. Your waitress will offer a small tasting of their delicious side dishes. The prime rib I had was cooked perfectly. I also recommend trying the garlic pretzels! During dinner the owner and chef walked out into the dining room. He made a point to visit everyone making sure they were happy with their food. I was able to talk with Bob for a few minutes. It was nice to meet the person actually making the food! I can’t wait to visit again. So I can try the rest of the menu.
… moreRoy Dillenbeck
My girlfriend and I came here for the first time. We both ordered the 2 piece platter with 1/2 chicken and pulled pork. The Mac and cheese with the pork was to die for. Sorry, I ate it before I took the photo, so it’s not in the photo. All of the food was really great. The sampler platter of the sides they offer was an unexpected nice touch, which was a great idea by the owners. Very friendly staff, and one of the owners ( Bob ) came over and introduced himself. I’ve only been to 2 other restaurants in my life, and the owner went to the tables and introduced themselves. Very classy move. We also got to meet his wife, Dawn. Very nice people. And our waitress was very friendly and the service was great as well. We look forward to coming back again and again. The restaurant has a country feel to it and is very handicapped accessible. We wish them all of the success.
… moreSuper Camry
The food it’s actually really good, they serve fast with also great service, price is fair, nice enviroment, family oriented, they support Military, Law enforcement etc i think thats a nice detail… really confy chairs as well. Will come back to get food when am around, highly recommend!
… moreManuela Bussler-Sweeney
First time at this BBQ joint but not the last. Our waitress Michelle was great. So very friendly. We were offered a sampler of their favorite sides,so picking ours with our dinners wasn’t so hard to do ,since they have so many to choose from. This place is definitely worth a drive and indulge in some great BBQ.
… moreStephanie Reisenberg
The food sucked worse than the wait, and i didn’t even get cornbread with my plate. Pulled pork was inedible (tasted like water….?) as was the original bbq sause. I dipped the dry brisket in the beans. Wings were okay, but the sause was sweet. I got the house hot or whatnot. Worse part of this all is that I got take out. They didnt pack the order correct, and a slew of coleslaw soup, pulled pork water, and bean juice ended up all over my front seat with the bag set flat. That pissed me right off. Definitely wont be back.
Response to owner: The food sucked, I wouldnt come back for free food as stated above. I’m sure KFC is better haha. Maybe season the water next time you boil your pork butt . I’d suggest improving your food as well as your customer service. I see you can’t manage to maturely handle any poor review. And ya, 45 min wait for take out is a bit absurd. Good luck with it.
… moreResponse to owner: The food sucked, I wouldnt come back for free food as stated above. I’m sure KFC is better haha. Maybe season the water next time you boil your pork butt . I’d suggest improving your food as well as your customer service. I see you can’t manage to maturely handle any poor review. And ya, 45 min wait for take out is a bit absurd. Good luck with it.
valentina castro
This place was excellent. We ordered wings, ribs, and prime rib to share between four people, and everything came out fast and perfectly timed. The owner even came to our table to check on us, which was a great touch. Service was quick, friendly, and on point. I’ll definitely be back.
… moreBrooke Emily
Absolutely delicious food, cozy friendly atmosphere, great menu, super friendly waitresses, can’t recommend enough!
Went for the first time last night. It was busy and every one on the staff was friendly and the entire atmosphere was great.
The waitress inquired if we’d been there before and I had not so she brought a sampler platter to try a few of their menu items. It had applesauce, Cole slaw, collard greens, mashed potatoes and gravy, Cajun corn, Mac salad, bacon Mac n cheese, and smoked baked beans. Everything on the sampler was delicious! And what a great way to make people feel welcome and to experience the menu!
My friend had a BBQ platter with pulled pork and pulled chicken and collard greens and Cole slaw. I had the nachos with pulled pork.
We did not wait long for the food and I was very impressed at the portion sizes.
Highly recommend the nachos! They were absolutely loaded with corn and cheese and beans and pulled pork and sour cream and the original bbq sauce and so delicious!
Overall what a great experience and the food is amazing and the atmosphere is super inviting.
… moreWent for the first time last night. It was busy and every one on the staff was friendly and the entire atmosphere was great.
The waitress inquired if we’d been there before and I had not so she brought a sampler platter to try a few of their menu items. It had applesauce, Cole slaw, collard greens, mashed potatoes and gravy, Cajun corn, Mac salad, bacon Mac n cheese, and smoked baked beans. Everything on the sampler was delicious! And what a great way to make people feel welcome and to experience the menu!
My friend had a BBQ platter with pulled pork and pulled chicken and collard greens and Cole slaw. I had the nachos with pulled pork.
We did not wait long for the food and I was very impressed at the portion sizes.
Highly recommend the nachos! They were absolutely loaded with corn and cheese and beans and pulled pork and sour cream and the original bbq sauce and so delicious!
Overall what a great experience and the food is amazing and the atmosphere is super inviting.