Sharon Elsen
Cutest little cafe with awesome food and staff is all family. We stopped to have breakfast, we were snowmobiling up in Eagle River area, returning to Appleton area, and after we pulled into the parking lot, we had major vehicle issues. The staff was extremely helpful, cook came out and looked at our vehicle, gave us recommendations of who to call for assistance. Every person that came into the cafe was so friendly and kind. One of the local patrons offered to pay our bill, but we had already covered that. If you get the opportunity to stop here, do it. This is small town America at it’s finest!
… moreAshley Smith
Lovely little café! The food came out in a timely manner and it was delicious. Worth the trip to Summit Lake from Antigo. Excellent service from the staff.
… moreMoto MandD
First time visiting. Nice atmosphere. Friendly, fast service. There is a story behind the picture on the wall if you want to ask! Family working there with heart. Surprise biscuits with cinnamon honey butter. YUM!
… morebrittany barnett
The breakfast burrito was made to order so perfect for vegetarian visitors! We were delighted by the deep friend dinner rolls with cinnamon butter
… moreSusan Thiel
Never disappoint, food is excellent, services is great. Have had Breakfast also , always a great meal along with service!
… moreAngela Franer
Biscuits are hard as other reviews suggest Gravy is envelope gravy ( ) Mexican eggs were awesome and hubby said best pancakes around.
… moreMax Zaruba
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
If you’re looking for your new favorite cafe— May May’s is it. No questions asked.
From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with a smile that feels more like you’re stepping into a best friend’s kitchen than a restaurant. The customer service is top-tier—we’re talking fast, friendly, and downright fun. The servers aren’t just servers, they’re stand-up comedians, hype crew, and breakfast therapists all rolled into one.
The food? Five stars across the board. Every dish that hits the table tastes like it was made with love and delivered with purpose. Whether you’re diving into one of their legendary breakfast plates or grabbing a quick bite on the go, everything is fast, hot, and absolutely delicious. You’d think Gordon Ramsay was back there working with a stopwatch.
The place is spotless. Clean tables, tidy counters, and a welcoming environment that feels like a breath of fresh air. The vibe inside is upbeat and laid-back, with music, laughter, and good conversation filling the air. You’ll find yourself talking to the tables next to you—because let’s be honest, the customer base here is just as awesome as the staff.
Bottom line: May May’s Cafe is a rare gem. Exceptional service, incredible food, great laughs, and a community vibe that keeps you coming back. If you haven’t been yet, stop what you’re doing and get there now. Your taste buds (and your mood) will thank you.
… moreNate K
Everything was good! Service, food, atmosphere. Nothing was totally exceptional but it was all tasty. Prices were higher than expected but it is a bit out of the way. Our waitress offered great service too.
… moreTracy Ostrom
This place turned over ownership and has improved their menu and hours of operation. The price is good and the food was made perfectly! The waitresses where immature to be serving food. We prefer to not see camel toes when we eat and all they did was bicker at each other infront of the customers. It is nice to have this quaint establishment nestled up North in WI and is clean. You can sit in or outside. Let’s hope they can keep open!
8/14/25 HUGE improvement. The waitress was excellent!
… moreRudy McCormick
I come here a few times a month and the last couple of times the breakfast food wasn’t up to snuff. The service is always great and the place is very nice so I hope they can fix the food piece.
… more