Morgan Cerra
Dined here for the first time last night and it was amazing! Food was delicious and fresh and the service was just as great. We definitely found another great spot since moving to the area! Highly recommend the cheese tortellini with pesto sauce it’s to die for.
… moreMichelle Iorio
A huge thank you to La Piazza for catering our holiday lunch! We ordered multiple full trays of baked ziti, chicken marsala and eggplant parm. They were all amazing! I highly recommend trying all 3 dishes. Working with Anthony and setting up the order was a breeze! I appreciate him working with us and helping us work this out. Take a night out a try La Piazza you won’t regret it.
… moreJeffrey Wolf
This is a great little local restaurant. The food is very good and the prices are reasonable. Our server, Hailey was super nice, helpful, attentive and knowledgeable. She was awesome. It is a small place and the spacing between tables is a little close. The noise level was ok but if it were fully loaded I think the noise level may be too much for older folks especially those with hearing aids. I got the baked ziti which Hailey recommended and she was spot on. My wife is gluten-free and she got the vodka pasta which was superb. My brother got lasagna which he said was excellent- loaded with cheese and meat sauce. This is a great local restaurant with excellent service and super food reasonably priced. If you are thinking Italian- give them a try. You won’t be disappointed.
… moreBecause Wendy Says So
My son chose pizza as where he wanted to eat out for his birthday. So we came in a Thursday evening. There were a few people in the bar area and only one table occupied when we arrived. I’m pretty sure our waiter’s name was Aiden, he was a really nice young man. He checked on us often, joked with my kids and made sure we were having a good experience. If we go back and he’s working I’ll request to sit in his section. Our order consisted of cheese pizza, chicken parm, kid’s spaghetti and meatballs, and saltimbocca. Everyone enjoyed their dish. My son’s pizza was really good, had a slightly crunchy crust which is my favorite so he lost a couple of slices I ordered an apple martini which was really good. Overall a good experience. We’ll definitely come back.
… moreRose Beauty
Absolutely appalled by the blatant lies on the pricing at this establishment. My husband and I ordered a large calzone and a chicken parm hero tonight and were overcharged! They are charging way more than the prices listed on the website. We were also told by the owner himself, over the phone that if we ordered by phone call it would be cheaper than online, a lot of good that did us. Unacceptable. The food was also very subpar. We will never order from this restaurant again. Pictures attached.
… moreLogan Hall
I had called in to make a reservation for 2 on Valentine’s Day about 3 weeks before prior. They hostess said she had me down in the books. I called today (valentines day) just as a precaution and they notified me that my reservation didn’t exist. This is absolutely unacceptable
Edit: I had called back to speak to a manager only to be told he informed that there isn’t one present??? What a joke. Either the staff is lying or the management is completely incompetent.
… moreKayla Moore
We had AMAZING service from Charlie! Wow! He greeted us as soon as we walked in. He was so kind and attentive. He gave great recommendations and our drinks never went below half full! He even remembered our names. I’m a recruiter and would hire him immediately ! I wish I could give him 10 stars!!! Aside from service, the food was outstanding! Definitely recommend the fettuccine alfredo and the lobster ravioli with vodka sauce (the sauce is amazing) Will definitely be returning!
… morechantee quarles
I highly recommend Anthony’s La Piazza Italian 10/10!
I celebrated my birthday and the owner, his staff, and food are excellent, top tier . They take time with details and are very welcoming! If you are looking to enjoy a beautiful restaurant, look no further! All of my guests thanked me inviting them to such a wonderful dining experience
… moreJohn Costanzo
Manager really took care of my wife and I. We made a reservation for 9 pm for my birthday dinner. Unfortunately the kitchen closes at 9 at the 42 location. He was able to keep a server and cook for us to accommodate our reservation. Service and manager awesome and food is top notch Italian…
… moreGerard “Uncle Gerry” Rosso
Walking in I noticed that this restaurant is Italian food Staten Island style. Being a Staten Island boy myself I was very excited to try the food here.
Everything was exceptional, the chef even came into the changes I desired. The wait staff was top-notch and the owner was very very friendly, this is going to be my go-to Italian place from now on.
Anthony the owner, did Staten Island proud!
… more