Bryn Bizzigotti
Im a New Yorker ! Pizza is important and this place has what it takes! Closest to the classic NY taste I can find around here! Attentive and friendly staff too!
Highly recommend!
… moreSaltyNurse
First experience. Will be back to try the complete menu. Enjoyed the Grandma Pie adding fresh tomato and pepperoni. I love the red sauce! Great cheese and crust. Looking forward to more..
… moreLylia Kelley
Cutty’s Pizza is hands-down the best pizza spot in Little River. Every single time we walk in, we’re greeted with the friendliest staff and such a welcoming, laid-back atmosphere. You can tell they genuinely care about their customers, and that alone keeps us coming back. The pizza by the slice is SO good! Always hot, fresh, and packed with flavor. Our absolute favorite is the Grandma pie (truly unreal), with the white pie right behind it…!
What really sealed the deal for us was our last visit when one of the employees overheard me tell my kiddo I didn’t have any quarters, he was so incredibly sweet and gave my little one a few quarters to grab goodies from the machines. Such a small gesture, but it meant a lot and perfectly sums up the kindness and heart behind this place. Amazing food, amazing people, and an atmosphere that makes you want to stay awhile. Cutty’s isn’t just good it’s THE pizza place. Highly, highly recommend. ❤️
… moreChris Marchi
This place is legit! Pizza by the slice, garlic knots by the knot. Calzones, whole pies, super friendly staff. A little bit of NJ style nostalgia for me and – dang it’s good.
… moreChris Muonio
I love this place but watch it they will overcharge you on purpose. I ordered 3 Stromboli’s
2 with pepperoni and sausage
And 1 with just pepperoni they were supposed to be $11.39 each as there menu says a Stromboli for $11.39 comes with mozzarella and 2 toppings but they charged me $1.00 extra for the pepperoni and sausage toppings. Total bill should have been $34.17 but instead I was billed $39.20. I asked the employee about the discrepancy and he said the menu is incorrect as people who just get mozzarella are getting overcharged. This isn’t how you do business such a lame excuse to overcharge your customers.
… moreSean arnold
Wow, Cutty’s Pizza is a well hidden gem Little River SC. Today we got The Works pizza and it was awesome. Their sauce and fresh products on the pizza made the taste great. Dine in or Take Out it’s all good. A sign of good food is THE STEADY STREAM OF REPEAT CUSTOMERS. Brother they got that here. Not only repeat customers but they have been coming back for so long they know their first names. We will see you again for our next pizza fix.
… moreCarrie Machado
This was a gem find! It’s connected to a gas station so I prejudged it however, this pizza is by far the best pizza i have had in the myrtle beach/calabash area. I would never give white pizza a try EVER but it was on display and i felt it would be good; sure enough i walked out with a to go with that same pizza. I can’t believe for two years i drove by this place thinking the worse since its location. Come give it a try and see for yourself!
… moreDavid McClure
Awesomeness all the way across the board. The crew at Cutty’s is polite, professional, and the best pizza within 20 minutes around them! With all the new residents moving down from Jersey, NY, and PA Cutty’s is the 1st place I recommend. I have bought gift cards for clients so they could try it. The pizza is like you were back up North. Put them on your list of being your Go-To place when you want an awesome pie. Thank you.
… moreEssential Home Maintenance
I found this place by chance while walking into Speedway, and it quickly became my go-to spot. Hands down the best pizza I’ve ever had. The place is spotless, the selection of sodas is unbelievable, and the two brothers who own and run it clearly put a lot of love into what they do. The food, the service, and the atmosphere are all top-notch. I’ve become a regular, and for good reason. Highly recommend
… moreLauren Nangano
I don’t mind traveling here from the North Carolina area for a pie because it’s the best in the area, the only place my family will go to.
My favorite part of a pizza is where the cheese meets the sauce and crust—and this crust strikes the perfect balance between crispy and chewy. The sauce is rich and flavorful, perfectly complementing the toppings.
The staff is friendly, attentive, and genuinely passionate about ensuring you have a great meal. It’s clear they care about their customers just as much as their food. Whether dining in or taking out, this place never disappoints. Highly recommend!
My favorite Cutty’s pies: peppers onion & sausage, grandma pie or the classic cheese pie!
… more