Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5609 Main St, Flowery Branch, GA 30542
Phone: (678) 828-8699
Website: http://peytonspiecompany.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Peyton’s Pie Company
At Peyton’s Pie Company, we craft hand-tossed pizzas bursting with … 5609 Main St, Flowery Branch, GA 30542. (678) 828-8699. GAINESVILLE 118 Main …
Flowery Branch – Peyton’s Pie Company
Located in the heart of Historic Downtown location. 5609 Main Street Flowery Branch, GA 30542. Sunday-Thursday 12:00-9:00. Friday and Saturday 12:00-9:30.
Peyton’s Pie Company – Flowery Branch GA – Facebook
Peyton’s Pie Company – Flowery Branch, Flowery Branch. 4395 likes · 17 talking about this · 1874 were here. Old world technique, American ingredients…
Reviews
IRONMAN27
Don’t sleep on this place. The pizza is REALLY good. We ate here last night for the first time and glad we tried it out. We got the Peyton Classic and it was very good. We also got a cheese pizza for our picky son and he said it was the best cheese pizza he’s ever had. Can’t wait to try out some of their pother pizza pies because I had my eye on that hot honey one. Will def be ordering from here from now on. Place is small so just be aware if you have a big party or try to go during peak hours. If you enjoyed this review please click the like button.
… morenoura
an amazing place for their famous delicious pizza! their chicken wings were as good! and i’d say I haven’t had better caesar salad anywhere else than in this restaurant 🙂
… moreBruce Dunn
Michael was great. Pizza was everything I expected. Tables small but fine. I lucked out and no wait. Perfect Birthday/early retirement party for little sister. This place is a must eat/do once.. if you had a bad experience try again. I cant see how.. and I bet they make it up to you. 2 sides, 2 front doors.. left side tables.. right side bar and tables. Outdoor sitting also. Take outs were flying out the door. Real fire taste from brick oven. Bread on pizza perfect, crust and all. Toppings on supreme are big chunks not like those other pizza places. I usually eat 1 slice other places and lose my appetite, I had 4 here. Big eaters should brace the double toppings.. hopefully wont mess up the perfect blend recipe. Great place to make my sister almost cry with necklace. Good family memory.
… moreStan Belyshev
Having personally worked at an Italian Pizzeria restaurant in New England Massachusetts and making pizza’s from scratch, I undoubtedly know a good quality pizza and Peyton’s Pie was exceptional.
Their Woodfried chicken wings were also off the charts. Well worth the price.
The pizza I got was SFI, and I devoured 5 slices in total. The dough was soft, chewy, and tastety.
The atmosphere is relaxing and the restaurant is superclean.
Somewhat challenging to find a parking spot on the side street, but still worth the walk.
… moreTheir Woodfried chicken wings were also off the charts. Well worth the price.
The pizza I got was SFI, and I devoured 5 slices in total. The dough was soft, chewy, and tastety.
The atmosphere is relaxing and the restaurant is superclean.
Somewhat challenging to find a parking spot on the side street, but still worth the walk.
Charlie Jones
For me personally, it’s really difficult to find truly great pizza in this area, until you drop in to Peyton’s. Just a fantastic pizza, best I’ve had locally, and one of my favorites anywhere I’ve been. The quality and taste are MORE than worth the price. Love the wood fired taste and quality ingredients. Everything we had was great. Highly recommend. The staff were very nice and it’s a great location.
… moreDori Gilder
Visiting family and decided on pizza. My husband is a huge pizza fan, especially wood fire! The pizza, garlic bread, and wings were amazing! Service and atmosphere great also!
… moreMakayla R
Peyton’s Pie is an absolute gem in Flowery Branch! The pizza here is top-notch — the dough was perfectly crisp on the bottom with a light, fluffy crust that had amazing texture and flavor. You can tell they really care about the quality of their ingredients.
The garlic bread with Tasso ham was a standout — rich, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. As someone who loves Tasso ham, I was thrilled to see it done so well. For the quality you’re getting, the prices are more than fair.
Our service was excellent, and our waitress gave great recommendations that really enhanced the experience. The whole vibe is cozy and welcoming — a great spot to enjoy a high-quality pizza in a relaxed, homey setting. The only thing I didn’t love was our pizza did not come with the fresh mozzarella it was advertised with. The mozzarella on top would have made it perfect.
I loved everything about this place and can’t wait to come back and try a different pie. 10/10 — highly recommend!
… moreThe garlic bread with Tasso ham was a standout — rich, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. As someone who loves Tasso ham, I was thrilled to see it done so well. For the quality you’re getting, the prices are more than fair.
Our service was excellent, and our waitress gave great recommendations that really enhanced the experience. The whole vibe is cozy and welcoming — a great spot to enjoy a high-quality pizza in a relaxed, homey setting. The only thing I didn’t love was our pizza did not come with the fresh mozzarella it was advertised with. The mozzarella on top would have made it perfect.
I loved everything about this place and can’t wait to come back and try a different pie. 10/10 — highly recommend!
Alexis Patonai
Pizza is phenomenal and the service is amazing, they have a real stone pizza oven super cool to see, thank you for the good service and food!
… moreE Parker
Peyton’s Pie has been recommended to me at least three times in the last month. I went today with a friend from out of state. We ordered the SFI, wings naked, all sauces to dip in, suggested by our server. This was hands down the BEST gluten free pizza of both of our lives. The wings were just as great! Our server was attentive, kind, and gave the best recommendations. I HIGHLY recommend this restaurant! We will be back, often.
… moreCha Lizdas
Peyton’s Pizza is our family’s #1 pizza spot! We crave it all the time and make it a point to visit at least once a month. Our go-to order is something we tried on a recommendation, “Nic’s Pizza with added sausage” and it is absolutely delicious! The flavor is unbeatable. We also like to get a side of hot sauce and ranch to dip our pizza crust…it adds even more flavor and makes the meal extra satisfying.
We recently tried the honey BBQ wings for the first time, but we still prefer the garlic wings, they’re packed with flavor and perfectly cooked. Another thing we love is the location…BetterDays is right next door, so there’s a great selection of adult beverages to enjoy with your meal.
If you haven’t been, you’re missing out!
… moreWe recently tried the honey BBQ wings for the first time, but we still prefer the garlic wings, they’re packed with flavor and perfectly cooked. Another thing we love is the location…BetterDays is right next door, so there’s a great selection of adult beverages to enjoy with your meal.
If you haven’t been, you’re missing out!