Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Serving up authentic, handcrafted pies made with the freshest ingredients and a whole lot of love. From classic favorites to creative specialties, every slice is made to bring people together. Beyond pizza, we’re proud to serve a variety of Italian dishes and offer catering for any occasion. Dine in, take out, or order online — your neighborhood pizza spot, done right.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 591 E Main St, Islip, NY 11751
Phone: (631) 581-9500
Website: https://www.thepizzeriany.com/islip
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Islip,NY – The Pizzeria
pizza sauce | light mozzarella | burrata | hot honey | basil | olive oil crust 28.95. Tri-Fecta. fresh mozzarella | vodka sauce | pizza sauce | pesto …
Pizzeria Restaurant | The Pizzeria | Long Island
Smithtown. The Pizzeria on Main Street in Islip. Islip. 591 Main St, Islip, NY 11751 … THE PIZZERIA OF BAY SHORE, LLC on behalf of all The Pizzeria locations.
Order The Pizzeria of Islip – Menu & Prices – Islip Delivery | Uber Eats
591 Main St, Islip, NY 11751 This place is one of the 3 most popular Pizza delivery spots in all of Islip.
Reviews
K silly Di
Expensive pizza by the slice, but it was delicious. Had the Ricotta slice, the hot honey with pepperoni, and a Sicilian regular. They were all delicious. Unfortunately we were on the motorcycle so we really couldn’t order a whole pie.
The staff was nice, the place is clean. It was about closing time so it wasn’t crowded.
… moreThe staff was nice, the place is clean. It was about closing time so it wasn’t crowded.
LongIsland Foodtastic
The pizza here is always SPOT ON! We tried hot honey pepperoni, another similar with sausage (OMG yum!), and a Caesar salad wrap with cheese baked on the outside(I’m hooked).
Staff is wonderful, they bring the food to your table and they are patient and help answer any questions you have.
There are two sides to the pizzeria, the front where you order and seating, and a second room with seating. There are restrooms as well! By the way, it is always super clean when we visit.
By the way, parking…
They have a few spots out front, but that’s a hit or miss. But, a couple of feet before you hit the pizzeria there is a free parking lot by the bank.
… moreStaff is wonderful, they bring the food to your table and they are patient and help answer any questions you have.
There are two sides to the pizzeria, the front where you order and seating, and a second room with seating. There are restrooms as well! By the way, it is always super clean when we visit.
By the way, parking…
They have a few spots out front, but that’s a hit or miss. But, a couple of feet before you hit the pizzeria there is a free parking lot by the bank.
Joesph Harrison
Does this look like a well done pie? No seal for orders that are delivered anything can be tampered with, this just sucks all around… Won’t be back. Pay attention to detail.
… moreMimi Sorrentino
During my recent visit, I indulged in a vodka slice, a grandma slice, and some garlic knots. They were so delicious that I was too busy enjoying the meal to take pictures! The pizza never disappoints with its perfect crust. A must-visit for any pizza lover!
… moreEnrico Mule
My favorite place to eat the food is fresh all the time ❤️
… moreKrystal
5 Star for both food and Price. 2 huge slices of NY pizza, 8 garlic knots, and a drink for $10 and change. That’s amazing to me.
The pizza was delicious. I got the meatball and the margherita pizza. Both were great, but I highly recommend the margherita.
… moreThe pizza was delicious. I got the meatball and the margherita pizza. Both were great, but I highly recommend the margherita.
Chris K
I love pizza and the first time I saw an uncle Benny pie I was a little iffy about it, as it looked too busy of a pie for my liking. I was so wrong and ate my words. Now I’ve got to try them all.
Easy top 5 pizza place on LI, stands out and above the rest. Maybe even the best depending on which pie we are talking about. Not a greasy doughy messy pizza, nice and firm especially when requested as well done. Can eat a slice with no plate without a stained shirt. Support this place! Real deal pizza shop
… moreEasy top 5 pizza place on LI, stands out and above the rest. Maybe even the best depending on which pie we are talking about. Not a greasy doughy messy pizza, nice and firm especially when requested as well done. Can eat a slice with no plate without a stained shirt. Support this place! Real deal pizza shop
Jenn Perk
I love the taste of the pizza, but aside from our very first order, it has been overcooked. We keep ordering, hoping that won’t be the case this time, but it always is. This time it was over cooked and hardly warm.
… moreChris Callow
Delicious Italian food with lots of options, it’s hard to choose. The chicken roll was great. Quick service too.
… moreAaron Vazquez
Sabrina my absolute goat, super friendly staff, amazing food, good music, clean and very modern environment. Overall an amazing first experience at this restaurant & will definitely come back.
… more