Heidi Butler
We just moved to the area and kept passing Pizzaroni’s on our trips moving items to our new home. My whole family loves pizza and we were like, “we gotta check this place out!” So we went in this evening and placed an order. As soon as we walked in we were greated with friendly faces. We told them we were new and the young guy working the register made suggestions, had a smile on his face and made us feel very welcomed. We ended up getting a cheese pizza, a pepperoni pizza, the kitchen sink pizza and 2 orders of wings. And OMGGG everything was DELICIOUS! The crust was super crunchy. The taste was amazing! I was worried getting the kitchen sink pizza because its alot of toppings and some places its a sloppy mess, doesn’t hold together well and the crust gets soft. But not here!!! The crust was still crunchy and the pepperoni on top were crispy and not greasy! Im sorry for the long review but I was very impressed with everything! Thank you Pizzaroni’s for making us great food tonight after a very long and tiring move. We live a minute away and I see Pizzaroni’s becoming our new pizza spot!
… moreNicholas Dye
Best pizza in or around Columbus! If you are anywhere in the area, this is worth the drive! The Luau is definitely the most unique! Ranch as the base, Chicken, Pineapple, and bacon! There’s nothing “fancy” about the place but “fancy” isn’t what makes a great pizza. Here you’ll see the owner topping pizzas, folding calzones and taking orders over the phone like a classic mom and pop shop. Trust me, whether you’re a fan of pizza and looking to try a new spot or just trying to find something to eat after your kid’s baseball game, this is the place to go!
… moreLily Kho
Had a great experience at Pizzaroni’s! The pizza was delicious, and their Southern Thai dishes were surprisingly good too, a unique combination that worked really well. The staff were friendly and welcoming, and the service was smooth. With a reservation, we didn’t have to wait long at all. Will definitely come back again!
… moreBrann W
It’s alright. They forgot my hot honey though. And god the square cut thing is gross. It’s a 3.5 star pizza, probably won’t get it again.
… moreBob McKnight
I tried Pizzaroni pizza about 1 year ago, and now it seems it’s my go to every time I order pizza. The pizza is always consistent with sweet tasting sauce, and the brick oven crust is so delicious. The pepperoni aren’t greasy, just the right taste. Try them, I’m sure you will be convinced to have Pizzaroni pizza every time.
… morePatricia Tedrick
For a few months now we have been trying different pizza places. We’ve been from New Albany to Canal Winchester & many places in between. This was the BEST we’ve had so far! The staff & owner are above & beyond! Very small for dining in but 5 of us did!! Nice little outdoor patio to use when it’s warm out. Definitely a new favorite!!
… moreMs. Marie
They advertise ” it’s in the crunch” and this pizza is point on!
Ordered mine loaded so I paid a little more but they are not stingy with the toppings which is a bonus
This was my first time ordering so next time I will just ask for extra sauce because I like pizza sauce a lot and they do it pretty light.
… morePaul
A Slice Above the Rest
If you’re craving pizza that hits every note—flavor, texture, and atmosphere—this brick oven gem delivers in spades. From the first bite, it’s clear they’ve mastered the art of the perfect pie. The crust has that irresistible crunch only a true brick oven can produce: golden, crisp, and just smoky enough to make each slice unforgettable.
The toppings are fresh and thoughtfully balanced, with gooey cheese that stretches like a dream and sauce that’s rich without overpowering. Whether you go classic or something bold and loaded, every pizza feels crafted with care.
If you’re a fan of crunch, flavor, and authenticity, this spot is a must-visit. I’ll be back with friends, an empty stomach, and high expectations—because they’ve earned it.
… moreDavid Harris
Small local place with heart. The pizza was not bad. Saturday night and they were popping out pizzas. Jamie was very friendly and helpful. If you want 5 star dining go elsewhere, if you want small local pizza establishments this is your place.
… moreWill Hawkins
This place is amazing for Ohio pizza . One of the best brick oven pizzas in ohio . It’s worth trying if you haven’t. We live an hour away and the owner gave us plates so my kids could eat it fresh while we drove home . Excellent service .
… more