Amelia M
The best cookies I have ever had. The atmosphere was great, and the employees were so nice. I will 100% be going back.
… moreNicole Clark
Delicious! Our group tried several cookies: the Hail Mary, the Double Hitter and the Touchdown with a scoop of ice-cream– no disappointments here! Beautifully clean and inviting atmosphere with super yummy cookies!
… moreDun “Dun Best” Beaty
Enjoyed the ice cream and cookies. Staff were nice and helpful.
… moreThe Cook Family
My company likes to use local vendors to supply holiday gifts. We were thrilled to find Angela at All-Star Cookies & Creamery. She put together a beautiful presentation and card for our local client. Absolute pleasure to work with and client said the cookies are AMAZING!
… moreSavannah Vaquera
I’ve been so excited to try this place but had yet to get into town to do so. While at Moo-La Fest, I came across their booth and stopped to talk to whoever was there and let them know that I’ve been wanting to try it. I’d already stopped at the other bakery stand before realizing All-Star Cookies & Creamery had a booth or I would’ve definitely tried them out. Whoever I had the pleasure of speaking to, was so kind and generously gave me a free cookie. It was GENUINELY DELICIOUS. One of the most delectable cookies I’ve ever eaten. Soft and gooey on the inside with the right amount of crustiness on the outside. Truly so good! I will 1,000% be stopping by their storefront this week for more and bringing the fam when they visit too. I highly recommend giving them a try if you’re looking for something worth your money!
… moreTeriva
They are always nice, everything is clean and all the cookies are wonderful…I have tried them all and love them all!!!
… moreDaniel Perez
Great ice cream, Even Better Cookies!
Found this spot on Google, and I’m glad we did. Easy parking made life simpler, and the staff welcomed us with friendly, fast service.
The cookies? Unreal. The ice cream? Exactly what you need after a long day. They had no trouble handling our whole crew, which was a big plus because we were 12 people.
The only thing is I wish there were a few more tables. But honestly, it didn’t take away from the experience.
If we’re back in town for another tournament, we’ll definitely stop by again!
… moreCharles B
So wanted to try this based on the name and the original website description.
Sadly we pulled up and we’re greeted by a huge sign for disgusting blue bell ice cream…
So, we had to move on to another place that has locally made ice cream.
… morekarli carlile
I’m so glad to have a place in Stephenville to get some great cookies and ice cream! Luv the store and its location…easy access!
However the cookies are the best part of the new business. I have tried them all and they are all my favorite!
When I picked them up for the Thanksgiving holidays, they were packaged beautifully with each cookie individually wrapped.
Angela reached out to my several times regarding my order. She and her staff were the best!
I’ll be back!
… moreDouglas Young
Ordered two dozen of The MVP and a dozen of The Double Play for Thanksgiving and a birthday. Good grief The Double Play were better than any cake we could’ve purchased much less made. We put The MVP out as an alternative dessert for Thanksgiving. They were a huge hit with the whole family. All-Star Cookies definitely exceeded my expectations, and that is not to say they were low expectations to begin with. I didn’t figure the owners would produce anything less than the best. I highly recommend All-Star Cookies and Creamery.
… more