Lady Cahill
Local to the area
Will recommend
Will return and eager to try all the other offerings the pot pie bar has to offer whether that means to go eat in order out or have catered. The options are endless.
I probably won’t try another pot pie due to the consistency, which was thicker than I would like
We chose to go with your classic chicken pot pie. They say it can serve anywhere up to four people, but I have a good appetite and it’s myself and my husband and we got the large one for $17.99 and it fed us both well enough for the rest of the night.
In the chicken pot pie was chunks of potato chunks of carrot, peas, and chunks of chicken. I felt the quality of the ingredients was good. I felt it was very fresh in flavor and tasted very healthy.
I do prefer it to have a little bit more seasoning, but I just grabbed the salt jar
The staff members inside the restaurant were very friendly, very attentive, very informative about their products and other things they can offer for us and how to cook the chicken pot pie very welcoming
The appearance of the restaurant was very clean very well organize organized very clear menu with price points plenty of parking handicap entrance an the location is just right look forward to seeing everybody and trying the new stuff
… moreMatt Coderre
We went for the first time this afternoon. They had a bunch of pies in the freezer with a few different options at dinner size and a couple others in the personal size options. We took home a classic chicken pot pie. The pie was delicious! Staff was very friendly and helpful! The store is very clean. We’ll be making them a part of our dinner plans at least a couple times a month. Highly recommend!!
… moreZack
Fantastic pies, JJ hooked it up with a fresh chicken pot pie for me and my wife after finding out they had none left. He was in the middle of making some and made sure he had one ready for me, we thought it was delicious! Hospitality was very appreciated after a long day and the convenience of some good grub made it a nice relaxing night.
… moreJennifer Siik
Food was good, however the business model is very confusing and not well advertised. The women showed obvious frustration explaining how the ordering is done. You cannot stop by and pick up a warm pot pie ready for dinner. You have to order your pies 2 days ahead and receive them frozen. You also cannot customize the pie at all. (There are onions in most pies and we have some picky eaters in the family) We bought some for a party. Very expensive for the small size. We heated for recommended time and used tin foil as instructed and some pies cooked ok, but others were still very frozen in the middle. It was very disappointing. I believe buying a large one at the grocery store would be more cost effective with no loss in quality or taste.
… moreRaymond Negron
Came by to hear what all the buzzers about. I’ve got to tell you this is definitely a new approach to food. Being a man that doesn’t know how to cook. I eat out constantly when the wife does not cook. I ordered the classic chicken pot pie.I was a decent size and you could clearly taste the vegetables and ingredients were fresh. Then I I was a decent size and you could clearly taste the vegetables and ingredients were fresh. Then I stop by for a sandwich and the owner Caroline was nice Enough to give me a tour. Everything in that place is brand new and clean. I am happy to have this establishment only a few minutes from my home.
… moreLaura Kirby
Simply put, amazing!! We have purchased several of the varieties and each one was outstanding. What I love most is that they are handmade, from scratch, with fresh ingredients. We have recommended to numerous friends, who have also thoroughly enjoyed them. We actually keep several in the freezer for times when we need to prepare a quick meal at a moment’s notice. Given the demand for the pies, which we have seen grow considerably, I’d suggest going earlier in the day before they run out of inventory. Better yet, you can order pies in advance through the website and the order will be ready when you arrive for pickup. That’s the best way to guarantee you will have the pies when you need them. Well done Pot Pie Bar!!!!
Laura
… moreS T
Picked up two turkey pies and one seafood for Thanksgiving. There were four of us and we still had one and a half pies left. Very tasty and the crust was amazing. Definitely will be back to try some other flavors.
… moreDavid Lippmeier
If you like comforting, rich, substantial pot pies, The Pot Pie Bar does a excellent job. The Chicken Pot Pie is incredibly satisfying, classic in its comfort, with good crust and filling. The Braised Short Rib Pie is even more indulgent, more of a treat, with tender meat and heft. The take‑and‑bake format is well executed: convenience is high, prep is minimal, and the result feels homemade without being a hassle.
If I were you and wanted something quick, delicious, and comforting, these pies are an excellent choice!
… moremackenzie kirk
Classic Chicken Pot Pie – Delicious!! Also so EASY!! Just pop it in the oven when you get home – by the time you remember you need to make dinner -it’s already done. Fantastic healthy ingredients.
Extremely helpful and friendly staff!
We will be back tomorrow!
Thank you!
… moreMatt Bergeron
We got a pot pie from them at a farmers market event a couple years ago and it was great! I was so excited when I found out they had opened a retail shop in Goffstown. Unfortunately they don’t keep many pies in stock, this was our second time trying to get a buffalo chicken pot pie and leaving empty handed. The first time we went they didn’t have any pot pies at all, they said they had only recently opened and were still figuring things out. The person I spoke with said they’d have stuff in stock in a couple weeks.
I waited a few weeks (maybe a month?) and gave them another shot. Checked their website and nothing indicated they were out of what I wanted so I went across town only to be disappointed again. This isn’t really a retail location, more of a place to pick up pre ordered pies. Don’t waste your time stopping in, make sure to call ahead.
… more