Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Monticello Bagel Bakery, a neighborhood favorite, offers a wide selection of freshly baked bagels, breakfast sandwiches, and deli sandwiches. Their menu features a variety of bagel flavors, from classic favorites to unique creations, all made with traditional baking methods since 1967. The bakery also caters to wholesale orders, perfect for businesses and events. Please keep in mind that our grill closes at 2pm.
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Monticello Bagel Bakery – Facebook
A Monticello Landmark: Family owned and operated for three generations and making bagels since 1967. www.monticellobagelbakery.com
Monticello Bagel Bakery (@monticellobagelbakery) – Instagram
1.5K+ followers · 74 posts · Family Owned Est. 1967.
MONTICELLO BAGEL BAKERY | Online Ordering – Clover
MONTICELLO BAGEL BAKERY. 475 BROADWAY, MONTICELLO NY. (845) 794-7746. Closed. Bagels, Breads and Spreads. 8oz. Plain Cream Cheese. $5.20. 8oz.
Reviews
Jessie Wu
The Best Bagels in the Neighborhood (Maybe in NYS!)
This spot is known as the most popular breakfast joint in the neighborhood, and since we were just visiting, we came in with a bit of healthy skepticism. Well, we were completely blown away. Their bagels are genuinely phenomenal! (I personally think they’re better than any I’ve had in NYC proper.)
The texture of their bagels is distinctively moist and delightfully chewy, making them great to eat even on their own without feeling dry. All four of us ordered different bagel sandwiches and every single one was excellent. We immediately went back to buy some extra bagels to take home! We particularly loved the Egg Bagel, Blueberry Bagel, and Chocolate Chip Bagel.
They have a drive-thru and you can also go inside to order (though the line is always long!). The only minor downside is the coffee, which is just average. But I would come back solely for these incredible bagels without hesitation!
(sorry no pictures as we ate them all before we realized)
… moreThis spot is known as the most popular breakfast joint in the neighborhood, and since we were just visiting, we came in with a bit of healthy skepticism. Well, we were completely blown away. Their bagels are genuinely phenomenal! (I personally think they’re better than any I’ve had in NYC proper.)
The texture of their bagels is distinctively moist and delightfully chewy, making them great to eat even on their own without feeling dry. All four of us ordered different bagel sandwiches and every single one was excellent. We immediately went back to buy some extra bagels to take home! We particularly loved the Egg Bagel, Blueberry Bagel, and Chocolate Chip Bagel.
They have a drive-thru and you can also go inside to order (though the line is always long!). The only minor downside is the coffee, which is just average. But I would come back solely for these incredible bagels without hesitation!
(sorry no pictures as we ate them all before we realized)
Margaret McCaig
If you want a fresh bagel this is your place!!! Great selection and loaded our bagels up with eggs, cheese and ham. We went back and picked up some bagels and cream cheese for the road! Yummy !!
No public bathroom and there were people out in front of the store sitting on the benches of which one actually said he didn’t want us there. They were not buying anything. I personally think it is a city issue that needs correcting. The employees, food and inside the store atmosphere were definitely worth another visit.
… moreNo public bathroom and there were people out in front of the store sitting on the benches of which one actually said he didn’t want us there. They were not buying anything. I personally think it is a city issue that needs correcting. The employees, food and inside the store atmosphere were definitely worth another visit.
Gene Panaro
When they start Sunday morning, bagels were made fresh the only issue they’re not cooked long enough. I highly recommend you toast The Bagles, too soft need to be baked a little longer To make more crispy I ordered two whip cream cheese. They were excellent. First one I had right out of the oven, but it was too soft. The second one I had toasted and it was great. Highly recommend the place. Staff was pleasant very accommodating a big plus for Monticello.
… moreCharlene Carlies
It’s hilarious! I’ve lived here in Monticello for 3 years now and never tried this place until now! The lines were always so long and so I always pushed it off. I regret not trying it sooner! I see now why they have so much business! I ordered a bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich on an everything bagel. So delicious! Very tasty! The service is also top notch! The staff are friendly, efficient, and fast! The way they run things is very organized and orderly. I only deducted a point for not being able to order hot food at the drive thru. I guess I understand it, it definitely helps the line to move quicker but it would be nice! I will definitely be coming back!
… moreMicky Hope
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Very friendly staff at the drive thru
Crazy amount of choices in bagels
First day I tried French toast bagel awesome
Soft fresh tasty hot buttery !
Absolutely delicious bagels !!
If there is a perfect cup of coffee
It’s here don’t hesitate
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
… moreVery friendly staff at the drive thru
Crazy amount of choices in bagels
First day I tried French toast bagel awesome
Soft fresh tasty hot buttery !
Absolutely delicious bagels !!
If there is a perfect cup of coffee
It’s here don’t hesitate
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
SE
Besides charging us for 2 extra bagels, and a container of lox (which wasn’t even in the bag). The bagels we did order were amazing! Delicioussssas! We got the monster, and lox and cream cheese. Best bagels I’ve had in my life. Even ordered another Monster. Better bagels than the city. Coffee was pretty freakin great too. What a gem.
… moreAlyse Scoyni
I love bagel places, but there aren’t a lot of good ones in this area. Monticello Bagel Bakery is the exception. First, there is a drive up window, so you don’t even have to leave your car. But, most importantly, the bagels are delicious. There is a nice variety of flavors. I like to mix it up in terms of flavors. I also love the muffins, a nice size and very good. Convenient and tasty.
… moreRussell Hirschorn
Fresh bagels are really good, lox spread is weak, chicken salad is pretty good, needs extra seasoning. Super nice people working here! Drive thru is fast but no hot food.
… moreNoah Shields
The best bagel I have ever had, very friendly and helpful staff. Can’t wait to go back
… morevickie felton
on 12 -13 approx 12:50p I went through the drive threw and placed an order– sesame bagel w/ cream cheese, everything bagel w/ cream cheese , A small hot tea 1 sugar milk….my order totally wrong both bagels toasted, got coffee instead of tea. total using a card $9.88 I got home and tried to call and figured NO one will answer the phone…. great CS and company.
I AM not driving back to stop in the store for a credit. UNBELIEVABLE — hope they read this…the next time I come in I hope to speak to the manager…. WAIST !!!!
… moreI AM not driving back to stop in the store for a credit. UNBELIEVABLE — hope they read this…the next time I come in I hope to speak to the manager…. WAIST !!!!