Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Mario’s Pizzeria in Plainview is your go-to spot for authentic Italian food and hand-tossed pizzas made with the finest ingredients. Whether you’re craving a classic Margherita, a hearty pasta, or need professional catering in Plainview, we deliver with flavor and care. As a trusted Italian restaurant in Plainview, we’re known for our cozy atmosphere, friendly service, and consistent quality. Looking for the best pizzeria in Plainview? Mario’s Ristorante & Pizzeria is the answer. We serve lunch, dinner, and special orders for events—satisfying locals and visitors alike.
Standard Italian eats, bacon-topped pizzas & other specialty pies stand out at this informal eatery.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 635 Old Country Rd, Plainview, NY 11803
Phone: (516) 935-8800
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Ristorante – Marios Pizzeria Online
Plainview, NY 11803. (516) 935-8800 · Lunch · Order Online · Gluten Free · Party … The service was outstanding, and the atmosphere was great. ” PreviousNext. © …
Plainview – Marios Pizzeria Online
It’s definitely one of my favorites… the service was exceptional. ”.
Mario’s Ristorante & Pizzeria of Plainview – Order Online
Order online from Mario’s Ristorante & Pizzeria of Plainview, including COMBOS, Appetizers, Insalata (Salads). Get the best prices and service by ordering …
Last Updates
Reviews
Gary Tietjen
Careful when you are booking the party room. I needed a place to hold a pre-HS Reunion get together. I stopped here and spoke to Peter the manager. They have a party room upstairs that would work. My dilemma was that I couldn’t nail down the exact amount of people attending. Peter told me that’s okay “I want to earn your business”. When I hear that I know that this person is willing to work with me. I called him two days in advance to say I have possibly 16 people coming…maybe less, maybe more. He said no problem. 15 showed up but 2 had to leave due to a family commitment. So 13 all together. When I received the bill, he charged me for 15. When I pointed out the mistake, he told be there was a minimum of 15 upstairs. He never told me that and on the package sheet he gave me when I first walked in, it’s not mentioned at all. (see photo)
On top of that, we only received plain pizza. No other pizza types were offered which was part of the package. So I paid for 15. I work at a popular Long Island destination just a few minutes away. I have people from out of town always asking me where is the best Long Island Pizza…trust me, this place will never roll off my tongue. I guess you will never earn my business. Foot note: Nicholas, our server was outstanding.
… moreOn top of that, we only received plain pizza. No other pizza types were offered which was part of the package. So I paid for 15. I work at a popular Long Island destination just a few minutes away. I have people from out of town always asking me where is the best Long Island Pizza…trust me, this place will never roll off my tongue. I guess you will never earn my business. Foot note: Nicholas, our server was outstanding.
Tomahoe Prod
We walked in , it was packed ,it seems a party of 20 just showed up . No worries for manager Narcis and the staff , they sat us down , and the family feeling set in .
The food kept coming out , we we’re able to view all the different dishes , everything looked and smelled so good . We ended up ordering a Chicken Marsala , a Zucchini Parmesan , Lasagna and Chicken Parmesan , everything was mouth watering great , When we finished , we couldn’t budge , but we ordered dessert anyway.
A chocolate Moose , Creme brulee cheesecake and a couple of Tartufo’s .
Thanks to Narcis and the staff for , not only a great meal but a great experience .
… moreThe food kept coming out , we we’re able to view all the different dishes , everything looked and smelled so good . We ended up ordering a Chicken Marsala , a Zucchini Parmesan , Lasagna and Chicken Parmesan , everything was mouth watering great , When we finished , we couldn’t budge , but we ordered dessert anyway.
A chocolate Moose , Creme brulee cheesecake and a couple of Tartufo’s .
Thanks to Narcis and the staff for , not only a great meal but a great experience .
swansong butterfly
Amazing food served here ! Everything was fresh and delicious..definitely will be coming back. They also have 2 private rooms upsairs for parties. Real nice !
… morecavac@4ctech .com
Was ok. Service was nice. Atmosphere was nice. Food was a bit of a letdown. This was our first time here, but it would not be a “go back to” place. Food was not BAD, just not great. My chicken was paper thin and dry/way overcooked (if you’re going to pound/slice it thin, you gotta REALLY watch it when you cook it.). Had to hunt around a bit to find flavor – not subtle, just missing.
Eggplant was ok – again, flavor a bit lacking (better than chicken dish though). Fried squid seemed fresh made, but a bit oily and the coating kept falling off (got to get it somewhat dry before coating it, or it won’t stick well). Looked nice in plate.
To be clear, nothing was bad, and we ate everything either there or next day. I would just try another place next time. Dinner was about $50 for one appetizer and two dinners.
… moreEggplant was ok – again, flavor a bit lacking (better than chicken dish though). Fried squid seemed fresh made, but a bit oily and the coating kept falling off (got to get it somewhat dry before coating it, or it won’t stick well). Looked nice in plate.
To be clear, nothing was bad, and we ate everything either there or next day. I would just try another place next time. Dinner was about $50 for one appetizer and two dinners.
Elana S (Ticketjackass.com)
Delicious food. Nice atmosphere. Very good service. Pretty good size of portions. It was a lovely experience to try this place on my way home.
… moremiss Witzokoph
horrable food and service and manager is not helpful
… moreJoe
Update 6/15/2023
Another great meal at Mario’s. Great food and great service.
Thank you Alex.
Oh, can’t leave without ordering canolis.
I have been eating at Mario’s for years.
My family has been ordering take-out from up the road since well before the Restaurant opened.
My wife and I had our wedding reception here 17 years ago.
The family gathered here after my Dad’s funeral (he loved Mario’s too)
We just came to celebrated my brother’s birthday.
The food quality and service is as good as it has always been.
Marios is definitely our favorite Italian Restaurant.
… moreAnother great meal at Mario’s. Great food and great service.
Thank you Alex.
Oh, can’t leave without ordering canolis.
I have been eating at Mario’s for years.
My family has been ordering take-out from up the road since well before the Restaurant opened.
My wife and I had our wedding reception here 17 years ago.
The family gathered here after my Dad’s funeral (he loved Mario’s too)
We just came to celebrated my brother’s birthday.
The food quality and service is as good as it has always been.
Marios is definitely our favorite Italian Restaurant.
Varneet Kaur
Went there for our date, honestly, the food was meh. Didn’t really understand why it’s always packed and definitely wanted to go check it out for myself. So, the best thing we had was the Caesar salad, it was fresh, crisp and nice! Things took a turn when we ordered our entrees, I got penne Al vodka with grilled chicken and my date got Chicken parm. For Penne Al Vodka- the sauce didn’t have any flavor, at first I thought it could use a little salt then I thought maybe red crushed peppers but nothing fixed it. And the chicken, even though it looked appealing but it was dry. For Chicken parm, the sauce was so runny, maybe next time if it isn’t as runny, it could intact more flavor? We barely made a dent and left. Service was nice tho, will not be going back. 🙂
… moreSusan E
Enjoyed a nice lunch here for a friend’s birthday. Food was very good and the service was great.
There was a nice variety of Italian meals on the menu in addition to pizza.
… moreThere was a nice variety of Italian meals on the menu in addition to pizza.
Gary Zeidman
Unfortunately not the Mario’s I grew up with. Pizza doughy, cheese sauce integration non existent.
This place was great 30 years ago. Now disappointing
… moreThis place was great 30 years ago. Now disappointing