Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Casual Italian eatery offering pizza, baked pastas & other traditional dishes in a strip-mall space.
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 140 NJ-10, Randolph, NJ 07869
Phone: (973) 537-0444
Website: https://mariosfamouspizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Mario’s Famous Pizza in Randolph NJ – Home
At Mario’s Famous Pizza, we believe that a great pizza starts with great ingredients. We use only the finest tomatoes, highest quality mozzarella cheese and …
Mario’s Famous Pizza – Randolph, NJ – 140 Rt 10 W – Hours, Menu …
Order Hours About. 11:00 AM-10:00 PM; Shop address is 140 Rt 10 W, Randolph, NJ 07869140 Rt 10 W, Randolph, NJ 07869; (973) 607-3202.
Order Authentic Pizza Online | Mario’s Famous Pizza – Pickup or …
Experience the best of Italian-American cuisine in Randolph, NJ! Indulge in our expertly crafted dishes that blend classic flavors with contemporary flair.
Last Updates
Reviews
L. a
I’ve been ordering from Mario’s for eons, and
typically it’s delivery all the way with my schedule! The pizza is good, although if you’re looking for that deep down authentic Nona-just-made-it Italian cuisine Mario’s may not your place, I’ll level with you. They pre-make their noodles (not uncommon and not a crime) so you’ll never have an opportunity to experience anything al dente (at least for delivery). Their sauce…not bad but it has definitely gone through phases throughout the years, much akin to the rate of social media lingo trends. If you are looking for a basic pizza pie or a generous helping of baked ziti, or even a very generous hot or cold sub sandwich, Mario’s does a pretty stand up job. Also, nobody can beat their BBQ chicken wings! The sauce is outstanding and the wings are plump and tender!! The half sub portion is big and the whole will last you for a couple meals if you play your cards right. Their meatballs are also not too shabby. I enjoy the chicken cutlet sandwich, the Margherita pizza, and the fact that they serve Anthony and Sons Bakery dinner rolls with their delivery orders. I do miss the bread that used to accompany the delivery orders but I found that I often didn’t finish all of it and it ended up getting tossed so in terms of food waste, the pre-wrapped individual rolls are probably much kinder. The tuna salad has a funky taste and has for quite some time so I no longer dig the tuna salads. Delivery is usually very prompt and they have very nice delivery drivers. The dining room is cute and it’s BYOB if you’re in the mood and have the time to kick back and chow down on carbs while sipping your vino. To cap it off, Mario’s is good if you’re hungry and your palate mood is not particularly discriminatory. I wish they could really impress me but I’m here to speak truth folks. That said, Mario’s will always be a cozy little pizzeria down the road when my stomach calls for a quick bite.
… moretypically it’s delivery all the way with my schedule! The pizza is good, although if you’re looking for that deep down authentic Nona-just-made-it Italian cuisine Mario’s may not your place, I’ll level with you. They pre-make their noodles (not uncommon and not a crime) so you’ll never have an opportunity to experience anything al dente (at least for delivery). Their sauce…not bad but it has definitely gone through phases throughout the years, much akin to the rate of social media lingo trends. If you are looking for a basic pizza pie or a generous helping of baked ziti, or even a very generous hot or cold sub sandwich, Mario’s does a pretty stand up job. Also, nobody can beat their BBQ chicken wings! The sauce is outstanding and the wings are plump and tender!! The half sub portion is big and the whole will last you for a couple meals if you play your cards right. Their meatballs are also not too shabby. I enjoy the chicken cutlet sandwich, the Margherita pizza, and the fact that they serve Anthony and Sons Bakery dinner rolls with their delivery orders. I do miss the bread that used to accompany the delivery orders but I found that I often didn’t finish all of it and it ended up getting tossed so in terms of food waste, the pre-wrapped individual rolls are probably much kinder. The tuna salad has a funky taste and has for quite some time so I no longer dig the tuna salads. Delivery is usually very prompt and they have very nice delivery drivers. The dining room is cute and it’s BYOB if you’re in the mood and have the time to kick back and chow down on carbs while sipping your vino. To cap it off, Mario’s is good if you’re hungry and your palate mood is not particularly discriminatory. I wish they could really impress me but I’m here to speak truth folks. That said, Mario’s will always be a cozy little pizzeria down the road when my stomach calls for a quick bite.
Wendy Peitzer
We dined there with the Randolph 55+Active Seniors on 12/6/25, for a holiday get together. The food and service were top notch ! The waitress was very kind, helpful and efficient! We will return there again. We highly recommend this restaurant!
… moreAna B
I had a very disappointing experience with this place. I placed a delivery order and waited over an hour without any update. When I finally called, I was told they only had one driver but that he was close. I gave it another 25 minutes and called again, only to be told that I had supposedly canceled the order—which I absolutely did not. Not only did I wait far too long, but then they tried to blame me for canceling. Completely unprofessional and frustrating experience. I will not be ordering from here again.
Update 12/14 :
I did not place my order through DoorDash. I ordered directly from the restaurant and called twice after waiting over an hour. During those calls, the staff was rude, unhelpful, and ultimately blamed me by saying I canceled the order, which I did not. The owners response only reinforces my original review: there was poor communication, no accountability, and a lack of professionalism in how the situation was handled
… moreUpdate 12/14 :
I did not place my order through DoorDash. I ordered directly from the restaurant and called twice after waiting over an hour. During those calls, the staff was rude, unhelpful, and ultimately blamed me by saying I canceled the order, which I did not. The owners response only reinforces my original review: there was poor communication, no accountability, and a lack of professionalism in how the situation was handled
Chuck Mound
Been a few years since my last visit for the Pizza Hunters App. Orderer a Sausage Slice that was fresh out of the oven. The sausage was very good and there was plenty of it. The cheese and crust was ok, but the slive really lacked Sauce. There was little to none which really lowered their Pizza Grade. Usually this brings down the whole grade, but it did not because the sausage was so good. If its a regular slice without sauce, this is a bigger issue. People were nice at the counter. I found a back entrance to the Pizzeria, but watch your step when you leave. Mario’s Famous has potential, just needs sauce. I will be back.
… more4feathers
Great pizzeria/restaurant to go to. Always go with my wife and daughter at least once a week or every other week and never leave hungry . Also brought some friends from out of town visiting for a convention that was nearby and they all loved it as well!
… moreEd K
Staying at a local hotel and was recommended Mario s famous. Food was very good, as a former resident of the state I do miss good pizza and Italian. Where Mario s went above and beyond was the service. We did a pick up order, ended up missing a dessert. I should of checked before I left, but I understand things happen. I called to see if they could refund my card, because of the processor it would of been challenging, but they would of made it work. Alternatively they brought the single dessert out to us. When they could of told me to kick rocks they went above and beyond to correct the minor mistake. Customer service like this is not seen often these days.
… moreErik Maietta
We’ve ordered delivery several times now, and everything has been incredibly delicious! I especially love the flounder and shrimp francaise, chicken marsala and Grandma’s Pizza .. the eggplant rollatini is also very good. The indoor restaurant is cozy and plays fun oldies music.
… moreJessica Patlak
We were quoted an hour which was fine. We waited a full hour and 15. All the food was ice cold. The cheese was hardened on the pizza and we were sent the wrong salad. The cheese sticks were ice cold as well. When we called they offered credit or to send out another pizza. We said we will take another pizza if this one arrives hot, and she said how about a credit. We aren’t expecting the next pizza to be hot but we don’t live around here so we will wait and see. The bruchetta was cold but tasted fine.
Edited to add that they never brought another pizza at all.
… moreEdited to add that they never brought another pizza at all.
Ery A
I always eat there. Food is always fresh and delicious. Never get tired of their amazing chicken Caesar salad or buffalo chicken pizza.
… moreMonica Sansi
Amazing food..very authentic italian. The chicken cacciotore was delicious as well as the eggplant manicotti was well done. Go support local business!
… more