Calvin Gondick
Restaurants get busy – that’s fine. But the staff working were insanely rude, and just not a good start for a first time experience. After waiting over an hour for the pizza, it was inedible. Literally zero sauce on the pizza, full of grease, and the dough was undercooked. I was very excited to try this place given the ratings – but they are in no way, shape or form accurate. Go down the street and get a frozen pizza if this is the baseline – cheaper, and tastes better by a mile.
… moreShawn Lawrence
I couldn’t tell you how good the food is because I didn’t even get a chance to try it. I went in 40 minutes before close and asked if they were still making food. I got a half ass “uuuuh sure” so I asked if they were sure and was completely ignored. I don’t even think they noticed that I left, or didn’t care. Oh well, I’m sure they’ll do fine without my business.
… moreShane Haphey
We stopped here to have lunch after visiting the Oswald Bear Ranch. It’s a nice roadside pizza joint. There is very limited seating inside. The food is very good and the service was excellent. I got the Pizza Pastie. Bring your appetite, it’s huge and delicious.
… moreSiddhi More
Stopped here for lunch at Newberry after visiting Taqemenon falls , it was one of the best pizza’s I’ve had very fresh and great service. We had a pizza and their garlic bread overall amazing food. Must visit 🙂
… moreMEC M.R.
What a delight it was to find this lovely gem of a pizzeria! We ordered a sausage and pepperoni pizza and the seasonal salad. This was one of the BEST salads I’ve had in a long time! Our pizza came out hot, cheesy, and delicious, and we absolutely devoured it. Fingers crossed we’ll be in the UP to enjoy their pizza again!
… moreConnie
Stopped at this cute & cozy little pizza place after visiting some shops. Pizza and salad for lunch. Everything is homemade with all fresh ingredients !! Tasted great you won’t be disappointed!
… moreIvy Potter
Fabulous! Pizza crust was perfection, toppings were fresh and delicious and perfectly balanced. Sticky bread was delicious! Everything was fresh and delicious! Service was excellent!
… moreJessica Cataldo
We went with our five kids and we’re given great pizza and service. We loved being able to see them make the pizza.
… moreKatie Bradley
I came here because of the positive reviews, and I was not disappointed. The pizza is absolutely delicious and that garlic butter is hype worthy. If I ever visit Newberry again, I will definitely be coming back to this place! 5/5 Stars!
… moreMack Buchanan
The stinky sticks are amazing! I love the atmosphere here! Will come again!
… more