Amanda
I love the thin crust but pretty disappointed with the toppings amount, and the way it wasn’t spread well. $2 for broccoli and $4 for chicken, and it barely covered the pizza.
… moreKimberly Lambert
My kids wanted NY style pizza since we were in NY for a friend’s wedding. We stumbled across this place only 3 min from our hotel room. The pizza was good and all the kids enjoyed it. I also ordered cannolis and they were amazing!
… moreMassimo Lotruglio
I’ve always been a huge fan of Gennaro’s since the day it opened. The original management was great. When the new owner came in, the price increased.
In the past, a meatball pie was ~$17. Today, that same pie is ~$25. In the past, the meatballs were large disc slices, now they are crumbles, meaning each meatball is roughly 50-80% smaller. Often times, the pizza is cold or undercooked.
The old owner was there every day, while the new owner is almost never seen. The hours on weekends are also absurd. What kind of pizzeria closes at 10 PM on a Friday or Saturday night?
I know four phone numbers by heart: my own, my home phone, my mom’s, and gennaro’s. I ordered a pizza last week over the phone. When I got there to pick it up, the staff had no clue about my order. It was as if I never even called.
The pizza is still usually good. The management is not. The service is okay.
I’d love to see the prices go back down, or the pizza quality match the price.
… moreMARIE COLUCCI
Any professional pizza shop would never let a pizza out the door over cooked, dry and burnt. We received 2 pizzas this way. It can happen to any shop, but you make right by it and either offer to make new pizzas or reimburse the customer. They offered to do neither. Can’t even get in touch with the shop. Keeps going to automated answering, asking you to call back later.
… moreKyle Register
I don’t know what it is about NY pizza, but that crust is TO DIE FOR. I had two slices: meat lover and tomato basil mozzarella. Both were phenom. I was just expecting decent when I saw this place from a search on the interstate, but what I got was outstanding!
Check it out, Saratoga Springs!
… moreJessica O’Boyle
Gennaro’s is my go-to for pizza parties! Their delicious pizzas are a crowd-pleaser with a variety of toppings ensures there’s something for everyone. We got a blanca, gennaro, and cheese pie today. The crust was perfectly crispy, and the sauce-to-cheese ratio was spot-on. With Gennaro’s, you can’t go wrong when planning a pizza-centric gathering! Their wings are always crispy! (Our fav)
We also enjoy their weekday dinner specials when we need an easy night. My husband loves the arancini balls.
Highly recommend this local pizza shop!
… moreCarolyn Corcoran
Extremely disappointed! They were running late and did not even offer an apology. The pizza was burnt to a crisp and overall had poor taste. Will definitely not be back.
… moreFoster Kucij
This is my favorite pizza place in New York. (not including NYC) Thin crust wood fired and perfect on the toppings and sauce. Hands down the best chicken parm sandwich I’ve ever had.
… moreJamie Sittner
Loved the pizza here! Thin, crispy crust with great flavor!! The eggplant! YUM!
… moreSharon Jones
Business Lunch. One of the two pizzas were burnt.
Boneless Chicken wings and pasta dishes left a lot to be desired.
Would not reccomend and will not return.
… more